The Dilemma of Overseas Dentists with the Australian Dental Council

Petition Closed

This petition had 259 supporters

The issue

Shortages, Inconsistences & Unfair Recognition and Examination Process of Overseas Trained Dentists in Australia by the ADC


Introduction
It is no surprise to anyone that Australia lags behind other developed countries in terms of the supply of practicing health professionals , Although this deficiency is very prominent in the case of medical practitioners(doctors), especially in rural areas , this issue is even more critical in the case of dentists, This situation affects the most vulnerable members of our society (e.g., low income earners and the elderly) , who often needs to rely on public dental hospitals, which the waiting lists are often several years long !, after which time the only available dental options are typically the extraction of teeth that could otherwise have been saved if treated promptly.
In this submission I discuss the situation faced by overseas trained dentists attempting to have their qualifications recognized in Australia, I elaborate on the current examination format, difficulty level, booking process and how it had been deliberately made in a way that alienate, disregard and marginalize a large percentage of overseas dentists who came to Australia with good qualifications and long practice histories and experience, to be faced by such illogical, unclear exam formula and process, bureaucratic procedures and stubborn mentalities of the people who have been allocated the job of planning, organizing and supervising the exams, selecting the questions from the presumed (questions bank) in a format that is far from a fair, right or scientific way of testing ,and lastly revising, checking-up and scoring the applicant’s tests in a disappointing manner!, I will focus on the written part and in another time I will dwell more on the practical part.
The Australian Dental Council (ADC) is the authority that assesses the suitability of overseas trained dentists to practice in Australia, Overseas trained dentists need to go through the ADC assessment process to obtain the ADC Certificate, which in turn, allows them to lodge their registration application with the Australian Dental Board.
For assessment purposes, the ADC classifies the overseas qualified dentists into three different groups:
1) In the first group are dentists who graduated from Universities in the United Kingdom, Ireland, Canada (after 31 March 2010) or New Zealand, this group is eligible for direct registration in Australia without further assessment ?!, and pay attention that Dental Graduates from USA, Germany, France and many other European Countries which their degrees are in same level or higher than UK, Ireland, and Canada are not eligible for direct registration which is a controversial issue and should be clarified and justified by ADC ?

2) In the second group is the so-called Public Sector Workforce Scheme (PSDWS), introduced to help alleviate workforce shortages in the public sector, particularly in rural and remote areas, This group includes dentists who graduated from various dental programs in Canada, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore, South Africa and the US., Members of this group are eligible for exemption from the ADC Preliminary Examination (Written Examination), and they receive a restricted form of registration which allows them to practice in the public sector for a period of up to 3 years, during which time they must pass the ADC Final Practical Examination, in spite of the fact that the dental graduates of the last 4 countries (Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore, South Africa) are not more advanced or prestigious than the holders of dental degrees from tens of other world countries which are equal if not superior to those countries degrees, So what is the significance in selecting those only countries to be treated differently and given this merit or advantage, in the same time it worth mentioning that finding or securing a job position with the PSDWS is extremely difficult if not impossible nowadays !.

3) In the third group are dentists who graduated from dental schools in other countries not listed above. This group must proceed through the full ADC examination procedures before they can practice the profession in Australia, and here is the problem, as everyone is talking and complaining (rumors are a lot), that the ADC pushed by the ADA, AHPRA and many Dental Institutions, Universities, government, dental figures and practitioners are working to make the process of applying, booking, taking the exams and passing it, and succeeding in the clinical exam the most difficult, costly and time consuming experience that a dentist from the third group could ever encounter or face, trying to dissuade and deter the overseas dentists from proceeding in the accreditation process by putting hurdles, obstacles in their way, and by tacitly silencing about such silly, stupid, shameful training courses that some Universities in Australia are advertising and promoting which train the Overseas Dentists to become dental assistants?!.

If we started with the first step in the accreditation process which is the Written Exam or MCQ & Case Scenarios Exam, which is supposed to measure the scientific dental knowledge of dentists, the first remark will be the high exam fee which is currently 2000 AD$ (increased from 1100 AD$?) and that is huge amount for overseas dentists whom most of them are with very limited financial resources since they are still not allowed to work in their dental profession, or working in marginal jobs which hardly cover their living costs, and many are humanitarian refugees with no financial ability at all, So is the ADC trying to profit from these exams at the expense of those hapless by raising the fees each time ignoring all the pressure they predispose the overseas applicants to?. ¬¬

The second remark about the written exam is the format, construction or the kind of questions and multiple choices underneath since most questions have several correct answers and they request the most correct and here is the calamity? as the correct choice according to the ADC desire & opinion could not be the one that is mentioned in many text books or in the British, American or European Dental schools, so how the applicant could know what to select or the correct choice in the exam if there is no previous guidance or orientation by the ADC ?

The third remark is that, Unlike the American Dental Board Exams (Basic part I and Clinical Part II) which there are many institutes and colleges in US that organize or have special courses for preparation to take the exams and the Kaplan’s wide network of institutes are an example, We don’t find similar courses in Australia to prepare applicants for the Australian Dental Council Exams, and the ADC doesn’t want to play a role in encouraging, promoting, or approving some educational centers who are willing to host such courses.

The fourth remark is that the ADC is surrounding the exam with a halo of secrecy since no information about the following points is disclosed or announced (unlike the American dental exams where everything is clear and explained):

• How many right questions shall the applicant have in order to pass the exam? Or to get the A, B, C, D, or E grade??
• What is the correct answers for the questions in a given exam? how will the applicants or exam takers know the right answer for some controversial questions as each of them believe he has the right choice since there are no ADC reference base to depend on.
• Many rumors circulate and say that the ADC policy is not to make the applicants pass from their first trial even if they deserve that? In a way to profit from the high fee payments.
• The new changes in allocating the task of conducting and running the exam process by a private company (Pearson VUE) needs a review and investigation as the preliminary indicators shows a discrepancy between what many test takers had responded and selected in the allocated computers at the exam venue and what had been delivered and scored by the ADC, so this exam change policy need evaluation before adopting it permanently.
• Why the ADC doesn’t display the number of applicants who have taken the exam, how many pass it, how many fail it inside and outside Australia, why they deal with such statistic like a military secret!? That is ridiculous!
• Why they make the fee for the independent appeal committee in unbelievable figure (5000 AD$)! If the applicant is not trusting the verification of written exam results which is done by the ADC themselves? Isn’t that a way to deter the even full confident applicants from further appealing and complaining?
• The current written exam questions and their vague and suspicious answer format is another element in the secrecy of the ADC, as the level of difficulty is even experienced by graduates of Australian Dental colleges whom many of them will fail the exam if they will be required to take it.
• Why the ADC doesn’t publish the exam questions for the previous years and their answers in some booklets that can be purchased from the ADC directly as the case with the American Dental Board Exams which for the last 25 years they are being sold by the American Student Dental Association? is the bank of questions of ADC so shallow or poor so that they don’t want to disclose or publicize the already used questions even the previous year’s exam questions?! , or they don’t want to confess or admit which answers they adopted for the past exam questions?


Shortages regarding the booking process for the Practical Exam

The ADC announced the start of booking for the July 2016 Practical Exam on Feb 16 but the 163 seats available were booked within few minutes?!, and that left hundreds of dentists who wanted to take the exam on July with no hope, and also they repeated the same mistake when they opened the booking for the Nov 2016 Practical Exam on 22 March in spite of the fact that the presumed and declared opening was basically from 30 Aug to 28 Oct 2016 and again the 170 seats were booked in the first few minutes and that left a lot of dentists with no place in that exam, BUT the ridiculous, bizarre and unbelievable thing was the opening of the booking on 22 march which is 2-3 weeks before the announcement of the results of the Written Exam taken on 2-3 March which meant that the ADC intentionally and purposely made the booking in a time that will not allow the successful applicants of the March Written Exam to apply and book for the Practical Exam of Nov and that means they need to wait over a year to be able to take the Practical Exam (in April 2017)?!.

This reinforces the suspicion that these additional barriers were only enacted to deter and alienate the overseas dentists from proceeding in the accreditation process ,and also from the other side serves to financially benefit the assessing and regulating bodies (The Australian Dental Council, The Australian Health Practitioners Regulation Agency AHPRA, The Dental Board of Australia and the Australian Universities that have bridging or orientation courses for overseas dentists ), which are flourishing financially at the expense of applicants assessment & exam fees, registration and courses fees, as it became a profitable business, meanwhile Australia’s people dental health continues to suffer from the serious under-supply of dentists.

The rules also become even more stringent, and pathways more limited and previous avenues to overseas qualified dentists keep closing, As the only orientation course available now is the Melbourne University OTC, as the other bridging courses for overseas trained dentists leading to the Bachelor in Dental Sciences at the University of Adelaide and the same at the University of Sydney had been permanently cancelled, also the NSW International Dental Graduate Program at Sydney Dental Hospital which was a very important program that assisted many overseas trained dentists through study and rural placements to complete and pass their Australian Dental Council exams and are now registered to work in Australia, many in rural NSW, this program is no longer in operation, why, no answer?!.

It seems that the position of the regulating authorities is to place as many barriers as possible in the way of overseas qualified dentists who might seek to obtain registration in Australia.

It’s what draws attention is the number of times the Dental written and Practical exam are being held in Australia which is two times for each part a year in comparison with 36 times for the Australian Medical Council (MCQ Exam) each year and 7 times each month for the Clinical Medical Examination and that is really strange reality?

Add to that, Overseas qualified Doctors have several preparation courses at a number of Australian Universities and Hospitals, while the Overseas Qualified Dentists has access to only one preparation course (The Highly competitive, very expensive and costly Orientation Training Course OTC, provided by the Royal Dental Hospital of Melbourne).

We understand that the ADC aims from making the accreditation and registration process more difficult and rigorous for overseas dentists to protect the interests of Australian Dentists and maintain their level of income and living, but in same time most statistics and studies shows a shortage in the number of dentists in many regions and areas of Australia and the forecasts are also confirming a decline in the number of dentists in comparison with the increase in population, we also understand that there are more dental schools (4 or 5 ) and more new graduates, but that doesn’t mean to close the doors or makes it much harder for the Overseas Dentists whom many of them have tens of years of experience besides many degrees and prestigious qualifications.

I believe the ADC doesn’t care about how the overseas dentists survive while struggling to take the exams and how they support their families several years until they overcome the barriers and obstacles of ADC from booking to taking the exams to waiting the results anxiously whether fail or pass then booking again besides the intensive study and preparation, also the ADC show no interest in knowing from where they can collect the high exam fees and the orientation course fees which totals 25000-30000 AU$? , when most of them are either with slim budgets or with humanitarian background and no stable financial resources, so if they are pushing them to work as dental assistants then that will not succeed as the majority are determined to work in their original profession as dentists in Australia.

Recommendations

• The ADC should amend or change the booking process for the Practical Exam as it proved to be an unfair and unjust process in its current status (booking through the ADC website exam portal), as each applicant who passed the Written(Preliminary) Exam should have the right (when logging to the portal) to have an open seat (within the booking period), So the ADC should assume and handle their responsibility and guarantee that by increasing the number of available seats several folds or return back to the paper booking process through the ADC postal address.

• The Written and Practical Exam offerings should be increased from 2 times yearly for each exam to 6 times yearly or every two months, and that will provide equal and balanced opportunity for all the overseas dentists willing to take the two exams, besides it’s a source of extra income and revenue for the ADC through the considerable fees which are being charged from applicants.

• The new system of contracting with a private company (Pearson VUE) to handle the task of conducting and running the exam require review and investigation as the preliminary indicators shows a discrepancy between what many test takers had responded and selected in the allocated computers at the exam venue and what had been delivered and scored by the ADC, so this exam change policy need evaluation before adopting it permanently.

• The Written and Practical Exam registration fees should be revised and reduced, especially the Written Exam fee which should be returned to what was last year around 1100 or 1000 at maximum, as it poses a heavy burden on the financial abilities of most overseas dentists.

• The ADC should be required to report on a six monthly basis to the general public and through its site the statistics of the Written and Practical Exams with all information including the number of takers, how many passed and how many failed, number of successful applicants from the first, second or third trials, as it’s the right of dentists who take the exams to know such statistical information, it’s not secrets like the ADC wants to keep?

• The ADC should publish and print the exams of previous years with their respective answers in an authorized publication available for purchase by registered exam takers.

• The independent appealing committee fee should be reduced sharply and made affordable as many applicants need to have an independent opinion in their test results.

• The ADC should promote, encourage and authorize the starting of preparation courses for the written exam part in the Dental colleges, TAFE institutes, and private educational centers according to agreed syllabus and reasonable fees.

• The ADC should encourage additional support for overseas trained dentists, by promoting and funding formal Dental Bridging or Orientation Courses at every Australian Dental Program or University.

• The ADC should cooperate with Ministry of Health in each state to explore the possibilities of recruiting Overseas dentists (Australian permanent residents) who passed the Written Exam in their rural and remote areas dental positions, or the (PSDWS) program.

• Also the ADC should Explore the possibility of implementing an on-the-job supervised assessment process for overseas qualified Dentists.

• The ADC should communicate and appeal to the Australian Education International (AEI) (Department of Education) for continuation of ASDOT program (The Assessment Subsidy for Overseas Trained Professional Program) which provided financial assistance (grants) to cover the fees of the Preliminary(Written), Practical and English Exams for overseas dentists, this program had been discontinued in July 2015.

• The ADC should follow and adopt the policies and procedures of the Australian Medical Council in many ways as they sound to be more flexible, realistic and logical especially what concerns the exam process, bookings, frequency, dates, fees…etc.

Finally, I would like to say that many overseas dentists that I know personally, and who are affected by these rules and procedures, are reluctant to make formal submissions for fear of reprisals, and further impediments to their registration, while I certainly hope and expect that this would not be the case in Australia, and I confirm that the content of this paper reflects the opinion and thought of a large percentage of overseas dental applicants which they confess and express in private gatherings and social media, and which they have been adversely influenced in many ways by the examining process of ADC.

The Decision Makers

Australian Dental Council
P.O. Box 13278 Law Courts Victoria 8010 Australia
Professor Michael Morgan President, Director and Chair of the Board of ADC

Petition Updates