Appeal for Edward 'Eddie' Ekiyor's Case & Call for Improved Training on GBV for Judges

14,789

The Issue

Call for Improved Training on Gender-Based Violence for Judges and Lawyers in Ontario and an Appeal in Edward 'Eddie' Ekiyor's Case

Gender-based violence, including sexual assault, is an unacceptably common experience for women on post-secondary campuses in Canada. In the wake of the numerous occurrences of sexual violence on Western University's campus located in London, Ontario, it is clear that this crisis is not receiving the level of public outcry and response that it deserves.

You can read more about Western here:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/western-campus-sexual-violence-reports-1.6173443​

https://globalnews.ca/news/8236496/london-police-sexual-assault-drugging-western-university-evidence/​

https://thevarsity.ca/2021/09/26/western-university-party-culture/ 

This violence is not unique to Western University. This petition is regarding a recent case that needs our urgent attention.

In Ottawa, Edward 'Eddie' Ekiyor was charged with overcoming resistance to commit an offence, kidnapping, and sexual assault in August 2019. In the original press release, Ottawa police reported that Ekiyor met a 23-year-old woman at a bar, "where he plied her with alcohol and drugs". "He then took her to an address in the city's west end where he sexually assaulted her while she drifted in and out of consciousness." (CBC News, 2019)

"On April 7th, [2019], [Edward "Eddie" Ekiyor] met a 23-year-old woman at a bar in the ByWard Market area, 'where he plied her with alcohol and drugs,' Ottawa police alleged in a news release (CBC News).

Almost all news articles associated with this case mention at least once that Ekiyor was a member of the Carleton University Ravens basketball team.

Why does this need Public Outcry?

We are writing this petition because we became aware of a recent verdict where Edward 'Eddie' Ekiyor was acquitted of all charges, including overcoming resistance to commit an offence, kidnapping, and sexual assault. The verdict that was given by Ontario Court Justice Trevor Brown on Friday, October 1st, 2021, was shocking, and another example of why survivors have little to no faith in the 'justice' system. Justice Trevor Brown acknowledged that the survivor was administered a date rape drug, like GHB (gamma-hydroxybutyrate), yet stated that the survivor, "acted consciously, but was unable to form reliable memories because of the effects of the drug" (Duffy, 2021). The logic of this ruling demonstrates Justice Trevor Brown's lack of knowledge and understanding of consent and the legal system's harmful capacity to generate, enable and perpetuate gender-based violence.

While issuing his decision, Justice Brown stated, "it is a dangerous and utterly demoralizing reality that men use these drugs to target and victimize vulnerable young women. People need to exercise extreme care when out drinking in public...Men and women need to look out for one another in such situations."

He also stated, "It is my belief that after hearing all the evidence in this case, that [the survivor] inadvertently ingested a date rape drug like GHB while at the bar."

In May 2021, amendments to the Judge's Act for Superior Courts introduced a new law, which intended to, "help ensure that the public has confidence that judges have the awareness, skills and knowledge of sexual assault law necessary to deal with cases in a manner that is respectful to sexual assault survivors" (Government of Canada, 2021). This law clearly needs to be implemented retroactively to every Justice regardless of date of appointment, jurisdiction and location. We need to also evaluate whether this training is survivor-centred and survivor-led, trauma-informed, comprehensive, and has an understanding of the complex and intersecting historically rooted injustices survivors of gender-based violence navigate.

The Demand - Mandatory Training & Appeal

Survivors are consistently asked why they choose not to report violence to the police. Yet when they do, judges like Justice Brown take the opportunity to blame the survivor and reinforce misinformation about consent. Victim blaming deters other survivors from coming forward and allows aggressors to escape accountability. The judge believes that the survivor was drugged, but fails to recognize the impact that has on the survivor's legal capacity to consent.

By stating that the survivor could have 'inadvertently ingested' a date rape drug implies that such drugs are a part of bar culture, further implying that sexual assault and rape are an unavoidable part of bar culture. 

This sentiment removes accountability from the person who drugged and assaulted the survivor, and diminishes the part we all play in eradicating date rape and sexual assault.

We cannot be passive in our responses to gender-based violence. It is not to be commonplace in bars, post-secondary institutions, or anywhere.

Many lawyers and judges who are representatives of the criminal legal system continue to cause harm by re-victimizing survivors and reinforcing misinformation about consent. We are not only calling for this case to be appealed, but also to implement at the provincial level mandatory training to educate judges and lawyers about sexual assault, similar to what has been implemented on a federal level, to ensure that those with decision-making authority are trained in this area.

We have until the end of October to raise enough awareness and pressure for the case to be appealed!

Contact Doug Downey (Attorney General of Ontario) & the Attorney General of Ontario's Crown Law Office to demand that this case be appealed!

Who We Are

We are the Women's Centre for Social Justice, better known as WomenatthecentrE (@Womenatthecentre), a unique non-profit organization created by and for women and trans survivors of gender-based violence, with over 4,000 members globally. We are a respected leader in the gender-based violence (GBV) sector, renowned for our work in elevating the capacity of survivors to use our lived experience as the basis for social action, policy reform, community programming, research and education, and collective healing. As a survivor-led organization, some of whom have navigated the criminal legal system, we know firsthand how traumatizing and re-victimizing the court process can be, especially for survivors of sexual violence. Our research (CourtWatch monitoring of Sexual Assault trials in Toronto, and ethics-approved interviews & focus groups with survivors who reported, as well as those who did not report the sexual violence) has shown that the low conviction rate, lack of understanding of gender-based sexual violence from courtroom professionals and the length of the traditional court process are just some of the barriers to accessing justice that make it a tremendously difficult experience, leading many to question its utility.

What Can You Do: Call to Action

1. Sign & Share the Petition on Social Media

2. Share & retweet this post to bring awareness

3. Contact Doug Downey (Attorney General of Ontario) & the Attorney General of Ontario's Crown Law Office to demand that this case be appealed!

Doug Downey: doug.downey@pc.ola.org

Attorney General's Office: attorneygeneral@ontario.ca

4. Call Ottawa MP & MPPs to demand change

a. Mona Fortier - Ottawa Vanier MP
b. David McGuinty - Ottawa South MP
c. Yasir Naqvi - Ottawa Centre MP
d. Anita Vandenbeld - Ottawa West-Nepean MP
e. John Fraser - Ottawa South MPP
f. Merrilee Fullerton - Kanata - Carleton MPP
g. Joel Harden - Ottawa Centre MPP

5. Call your local MP & MPP to demand change

6. Call in your friends, family and networks to this call to action

7. Share social media posts from @womenatthecentre (Instagram) & @womenatcentre (Twitter)

avatar of the starter
WomenatthecentrE .Petition StarterA unique survivor-led organization in Canada created by and for women, trans and gender-diverse survivors of gender-based violence (GBV). We are committed to eradicating all forms of GBV through personal, political and social advocacy.

The Decision Makers

Doug Downey
Attorney General of Ontario
Attorney General of Ontario
Crown Law Office

Petition Updates