The Wallace Animal Neglect Case- Final Verdict & Conclusion


It is with a heavy heart and ambivalent emotion that I write to you, the final verdict in the Deitrick Wallace Animal Neglect Case. Last Friday, we received word that Wallace had plead guilty to all five felony charges brought fourth against him:
"Deitrick Wallace entered a guilty plea to Judge Daryl Burt this morning on all five counts of animal cruelty and he has been sentenced. The sentence is as follows: COUNT 1 - Aggravated cruelty to animals (felony). A sentence of ten years, of which six months will be served in the Winston County Jail. After his release he will serve five years supervised probation with the State of Alabama. COUNTS 2 through 5 - Misdemeanor cruelty to animals. A sentence of one year for each count. He will serve six months in the Winston County Jail, and after release will serve two years of supervised probation with the state of Alabama for each count. These sentences will run concurrently, but if Mr Wallace violates his parole he will serve the balance of all these sentences consecutively, a total of 11 1/2 years. He is also forbidden to own or care for any animal, domestic or otherwise, for a period of five years. He is also ordered to pay court costs, bail, and restitution. Details of the ordered restitution are unknown at this time."
In summary, Wallace will serve 6 months in the Winston County Jail, followed by a 5 year probational period in which if he violates, he will have to serve out the remainder of his 11.5 year sentencing. He cannot have a domestic animal under his care for five years. His sentencing time is concurrent not consecutive.
Was this enough? Well, it depends on who you ask. According to Animal Cruelty Laws in the State of Alabama, ALA. CODE Section 13A-11-14 (1977) "Intentionally torturing a dog or cat is a Class C Felony punishable with a fine up to $5,000 and/or imprisonment up to 10 years.” So in hindsight, a maximum sentencing per each of the five felony guilty pleas, four in which appear to have been reduced to misdemeanors, would have come out to be about a 50 year prison term (10 years for each count of aggravated animal cruelty, originally brought fourth against Wallace).
So the 6 months that Wallace is sentenced to serve juxtaposed with the maximum outcome of 50 years, for many, does not feel like nearly enough of a punishment and are outraged at yet again, another example of leniency when it comes to prosecuting cases of extreme animal abuse and neglect in the State of Alabama.
If we review the case one more time- the photos, the witness testimony, the condition that Malachi, Athena, and Camille were found in at the time of the rescue, the two deceased dogs that were imprisoned- one chained, the other confined to a crate that slowly died of starvation, and dehydration (both shown in the above photo),- then yes, this does not feel like the justice that many of us were quite hoping for.
But for those close to the case that know all to well, the long history that Alabama has had with failing to prosecute animal neglect cases, then this case does feel like a win or at least a step in the right direction. For many of the Free State Four Paws (FSFP) members that have worked this case, they are content with any jail time being sentenced, since more often than not, that is not the case in these sort of situations.
Johnna Franks, founder and director of FSFP reflects on a case many years ago, even before FSFP was founded in 2014, where an Alabama man shot the family dog and lit it on fire in front of his own children. “He did not serve a single day in jail for that,” Franks says. Franks is satisfied with Judge Daryl Burt's ruling and believes that this is much needed progress. For a state where lawmakers can't even pass a law that allows cats and dogs to have a top and two sides from the elements, Frank says, this is a better outcome than what was to be expected, referring to bill HB-305 that has been voted against on multiple occasions, partly in due by companies like ALFA Insurance that are opposing it.
Many of us would have personally liked to have seen this case go to trial so the evidence that had been stacked up against Mr. Wallace could have been presented to a Jury. We have strong reason to believe, that Mr. Wallace had sufficient resources to adequately take care of these dogs in his care- the same week in November of 2017 in which FSFP rescue workers rescued Athena, Camille, and Malachi and discovered the two deceased pitbulls, Wallace had allegedly attended the Alabama VS. LSU Football game and posted on social media of himself before apparently getting a tattoo done at a tattoo parlor- keep in mind, this was during the exact time that two dogs laid dead in their own excrement while three others were on the verge of dying themselves.
Going back to the five original requests stated in our original petition (see the first petition update for more information), here is where we are at:
1. We wanted justice for the Dogs!
Verdict: You decide, is 6 months of jail time, probation, and 5 years restriction from owning or caring for a live animal enough?
2. We want less lenient laws in the State of Alabama when it comes to animal neglect!
Verdict: Wallace appealed his misdemeanor charge from the 2017 complaint in Haleyville, AL which allowed him to be classified as a “first time offender” against the felony charges- how did this loophole exist to begin with? Reform takes time but we need to continue to bring these existing laws into public eye and scrutiny
3. We want to put a national spotlight on what is going on in Winston County, AL
Verdict: this petition has definitely allowed us to talk openly about the lack of resources available in Winston County, AL, but we need to continue to put pressure on the local government to budget for an animal shelter. Without that animal shelter, Free State Four Paws, will continue to be overworked as they combat the myriad of local issues caused by the absence of available resources
4. We demand a formal statement from local law enforcement that handled the Wallace case- why did it take so long for authorities to intervene? All five dogs were still alive at the time that FSFP pleaded with responding officers to go inside the Wallace residence to carry out a rescue in which they were told they would be arrested for trespassing
Verdict: We are still waiting for an answer...
5. Help with funding FSFP
Verdict- Win! We have received a few donations from petition signers, a few online and one in person, and for that we are unbelievably grateful! We are currently trying to raise $1,500 so we can get FSFP a newer gently used transport vehicle since their current one has a whopping 222,500 miles on it and could breakdown for good at any minute. If you are interested in donating, Click Here. Many of you have started following FSFP on Facebook, as well, so you can stay up-to-date on the work that they do and the problems that they face! At anytime, you can make a donation directly to them or send a bag of dog chow (they accept Amazon packages) and are always in need of food and funding.
In conclusion, it is clear that this case has been more of a step than a win. In a state where it is perfectly legal to shoot someone's dog or cat for defecating on your lawn, we have a lot of work to do! It is important that we continue to fight for basic rights for domestic animals- not just in the state of Alabama but everywhere! We encourage you to take this as an opportunity to personally become familiar with laws in your own state or country and help vote to pass laws that work to protect our four legged friends and increase their overall quality of life- tethering laws, shelter laws, criminality of abuse and neglect- just to name a few.
If you would like to stay up-to-date on current Alabama legislation, head over to Facebook and follow the “Alabama Voters for Responsible Animal Legislation (AVRAL)” page.
If you would like to express your concerns with this case to the state of Alabama, you can formally send a complaint here:
P.O. Box 297,
Hamilton Al 35570
Thank you for continuing to follow this case with us, we felt your support and your love for these dogs since starting the petition, just a few short weeks ago. I will keep it open as a means to continue to garner public support, honor the five dogs, and to continue to send a clear, concise message to lawmakers and animal abusers alike: we are watching you.
-Jaclyn L.