A Call for Missing 1945 Evidence: Establishing a Safe Harbor for Paddy Mayne’s VC

UPDATE: A Call for Undisclosed Archival Evidence and Establishing a Protected Safe Harbor
To All Supporters, Military Historians, Veterans, and Friends of the Regiment:
As our international campaign to secure the Victoria Cross for Lt. Col. Robert Blair "Paddy" Mayne moves forward, we must address the single greatest administrative hurdle standing between our petition and the British Honours System. The Ministry of Defence consistently falls back on a rigid statutory threshold: retrospective reviews of historic awards will only be considered if "significant, contemporary documentary evidence" is produced that was unavailable to the original committee in 1945.
I recognize completely that this is an uphill battle and a long shot. However, as an independent researcher who has forensically dissected the 1944–1945 operational paper trail, I have a deep and unshakable conviction that critical contemporary documents still exist somewhere in private hands. Whether preserved within the private vaults of the SAS Regimental Association, tucked inside family papers connected to the Mayne estate, held in trusts linked to early SAS founders, or sitting in the uncataloged correspondence of former staff officers, the truth did not vanish. It was preserved.
The reality of 1945 is well known to those who study the founding era of Unconventional Warfare. When the 1st SAS Brigade was abruptly stood down at the end of the war, a vast amount of primary documentation, operational logs, personal diaries, and carbon copies did not enter the official War Office registry. For decades, those records were guarded quietly. The most famous example is the original SAS War Diary (1941–1945), which was preserved in absolute secrecy inside regimental vaults for over sixty years before ever being seen by the broader public.
There is an understandable fear surrounding unreleased documents from that era. In the British honors and regimental culture, questioning an official decision is often perceived as an attack on the integrity of the system itself. If an unredacted carbon copy, a private staff journal, or an internal War Office memo exists showing why Mayne’s VC recommendation was crossed out and downgraded to a DSO on October 16, 1945, releasing it might cast an uncomfortable light on historic figures. It might reveal administrative bias, personal rivalries, or deliberate interference by senior wartime commanders, desk-bound staff officers, or even members of the royal household of that era.
To anyone holding such records, let me state this unequivocally: The historical truth is more important than protecting 80-year-old reputations.
Protecting the pride of men who have been in their graves for more than half a century at the expense of Paddy Mayne's rightful honor is not loyalty; it is the continuation of an 80-year-old injustice. True loyalty to the Regiment and to the men who forged the Allied victory means letting the full operational facts speak without censorship.
For those who may possess such documents—or who know where they reside—the greatest hesitation is often safety. People fear bureaucratic retaliation, the loss of standing, legal harassment, or having sensitive family papers quietly seized and permanently buried behind closed doors by Whitehall civil servants.
Because of that risk, you must never send original historical materials into the standard civil service or Ministry of Defence postal system. Doing so invites administrative burial. Instead, there is an established, constitutionally protected Safe Harbor.
The safest and most powerful destination for this evidence is Jim Shannon, Member of Parliament for Strangford (Paddy Mayne's home constituency).
Jim Shannon MP has staked his parliamentary reputation on this cause. He has fought for Paddy Mayne on the floor of the House of Commons for years, secured official debates, and challenged successive Defence Ministers directly. Most importantly, turning to a Member of Parliament invokes the historic protections of the Bill of Rights 1689 (Article 9: Parliamentary Privilege).
Under Parliamentary Privilege, proceedings and evidence laid before Parliament cannot be questioned, censored, or prosecuted in any court or by any administrative body. Once a document is brought forward to an MP and placed on the parliamentary record or tabled in the House of Commons Library:
1. It is permanently entered into the public historical record and can never be hidden, classified, or "lost."
2. The government is constitutionally compelled to give an official on-the-record response across the dispatch box.
3. The individual or family bringing the evidence forward receives maximum legal protection from institutional retribution or civil liability.
HOW TO CONTACT JIM SHANNON MP (IMPORTANT PROTOCOL):
CRITICAL INSTRUCTION: DO NOT SIMPLY MAIL ORIGINAL HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS.
Original wartime papers, carbon copies, and personal diaries are irreplaceable. Do not put originals in the post. Instead, contact Mr. Shannon’s office directly by telephone or email to state that you have contemporary material regarding the 1945 Oldenburg recommendation for Lt. Col. Mayne. His staff can coordinate a verified, secure, and confidential protocol to inspect or scan the material.
Constituency Office:
Address: 34A Frances Street, Newtownards, County Down, Northern Ireland, BT23 4DN
Telephone: 028 9182 7990(From outside the UK: +44 28 9182 7990)
Westminster Parliamentary Office:
Address: House of Commons, London, SW1A 0AA
Telephone: 020 7219 7160(From outside the UK: +44 20 7219 7160)
Official Email Contacts:
jim.shannon.mp@parliament.uk
We are asking our supporters across the globe to share this update into every military history circle, veteran community, and regimental forum. If you are holding the missing piece of this puzzle—or if you are the custodian of an archive that holds the proof of what happened in October 1945—the door is open. The safe harbor is ready. Help us right this historical record once and for all.
Who Dares Wins.
Bryce Mallory
Independent Military Historian & Veteran Advocate