Petition updateWho Dares Wins ….The Truth: Award Paddy Mayne the Victoria Cross

Let’s get more signatures for this petition

bryce mallorycamby, IN, United States
Oct 29, 2026

PETITION UPDATE: Beyond Numbers — Forensic Audit, Grassroots Momentum, and Our Next Step

1. RESPECTFUL ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF PREVIOUS EFFORTS

First and foremost, I want to express my sincere gratitude and respect to the creators and supporters of the existing petitions advocate for Lieutenant Colonel Robert Blair "Paddy" Mayne to posthumously receive the Victoria Cross.

Those grassroots efforts have played an indispensable role in keeping Paddy Mayne’s extraordinary legacy alive in the public consciousness. Without their dedicated advocacy over the years, the conversation surrounding one of World War II’s most revered combat leaders might never have reached this pivotal moment. We build upon the foundation they laid, and we remain deeply thankful for their pioneering work in raising vital public awareness.

2. HOW THIS INITIATIVE DIFFERS: AN INDEPENDENT FORENSIC AUDIT

While previous petitions have largely focused on general public appeals or Parliamentary nominations, this effort approaches the objective from a distinct, evidentiary standpoint:

 Independent Historical Review: This initiative is led by an outside, independent military historian with no institutional bias.

 Archival & Forensic Audit: Rather than a request based purely on sentiment, this campaign demands a formal forensic administrative audit cross-referencing verified After-Action Reports (AARs) against War Office records (WO 373).

 Exposing the Administrative Error: The goal is to establish proof that the downgrade of Mayne's formal VC recommendation was the result of 1940s-era bureaucratic friction, personality clashes, and post-war administrative oversight rather than any lack of extraordinary gallantry on the battlefield.

We are not simply asking for a medal to be awarded—we are proving through historical equity and archival accuracy that the original recommendation was systematically mishandled.

3. REAL-WORLD IMPACT: RIPPLES BEYOND THE SIGNATURE COUNT

While the raw counter currently stands at 17 signatures, that number reflects only the tip of the iceberg.

Over the past several days, targeted outreach to key journalists, historians, veterans' organizations, and political figures has sparked widespread discussion across the veteran and military history communities. The real measure of this campaign right now isn't just on a web page—it is in the veteran hubs, regimental associations, and pubs across the UK where Paddy Mayne’s story and the demand for a forensic audit are being vigorously discussed by those who know what real gallantry looks like.

Cultural momentum and institutional pressure always begin with focused conversations in the right rooms. The wave has already started.

4. ONE SIMPLE ACTION YOU CAN TAKE TODAY TO HELP

To every single person who has signed so far: Thank you. Now, we need your help to multiply our reach.

If everyone who has signed takes just one action right now, it will accelerate this momentum exponentially:

 Share the direct petition link on your personal social media profiles (Facebook, X/Twitter, LinkedIn, Reddit, or veterans' forums).

Adding a personal note about why historical equity matters for Paddy Mayne when you share the link will help reach military historians, service members, and advocates who care about rectifying this 80-year-old administrative error.

Direct Link to Share: https://www.change.org/Paddymayne

SINE CERA,

Bryce Mallory

Independent Military Historian