

Upholding the Integrity and dignity of Election Commission and other constitutional bodies
The Issue
AN OPEN PETITION TO THE HON’BLE PRESIDENT OF INDIA
In Defence of the Constitutional Independence of the Election Commission of India, Democratic Accountability, and the Rule of Law
To
The Hon’ble President of India
Rashtrapati Bhavan
New Delhi – 110004
*Subject: An academic appeal to uphold the constitutional independence of the Election Commission of India and resist extra-constitutional coercion against independent institutions*
*Respected Madam President,*
We, the undersigned academics, researchers, teachers and scholars, write to express our concern over the growing confrontation surrounding the Election Commission of India (ECI), particularly the campaign demanding the resignation of the Chief Election Commissioner. Our concern arises not from an allegiance to any political party or office-holder, but from a commitment to the constitutional principles upon which the Republic of India rests.
A democracy cannot be sustained by elections alone. It also depends upon the credibility of the institutions that administer them, the fairness of the procedures through which political power is contested, and the willingness of all political actors to resolve their disagreements within a constitutional framework.
The Election Commission occupies a uniquely consequential position in this arrangement. It administers the electoral process through which governments acquire democratic legitimacy and citizens exercise their sovereign political choice. Its independence, therefore, is not a privilege granted to its office-holders. It is a safeguard belonging to the electorate.
*We stand in solidarity with the constitutional independence and institutional dignity of the Election Commission of India.* We are concerned by attempts to secure the resignation of its leadership through intimidation, personal threats or extra-constitutional coercion. The tenure of a constitutional functionary must not become contingent upon the intensity of political mobilisation or the capacity of any party or group to exert pressure.
At the same time, our position must be understood precisely. Institutional independence does not confer immunity from criticism, and democratic disagreement must never be mistaken for disloyalty to the nation. Peaceful protest, demands for accountability and scrutiny of electoral administration are legitimate elements of democratic life. The issue is not whether citizens may question the Election Commission; they must be able to do so. The issue is whether questions of institutional responsibility are pursued through evidence, transparent procedures and lawful remedies, rather than intimidation or the presumption of guilt.
Article 324 of the Constitution vests the Election Commission with the superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Article 324(5) provides the Chief Election Commissioner with special protection against removal, placing it on the same grounds and through the same manner applicable to a Judge of the Supreme Court. This constitutional safeguard reflects the importance of insulating the office from arbitrary political retaliation. It should not be reduced to a formality that can be displaced by pressure.
The constitutional significance of electoral integrity has also been recognised by the Supreme Court, including in *Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain* (1975) and Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023). These principles require us to protect the conditions under which elections can be conducted fairly and their administration can command public confidence.
The present controversy over electoral-roll revision makes this responsibility especially urgent. Allegations concerning deletions, verification procedures and the possible exclusion of eligible electors deserve examination. The right to vote is meaningful only when eligible citizens can exercise it in practice. A voter wrongly omitted from an electoral roll is not merely an entry missing from a database; that person may be deprived of an essential means of political participation.
Consequently, defending the Election Commission must go hand in hand with insisting upon transparency. The Commission should be prepared to explain its decisions, publish verifiable data and provide effective procedures through which eligible voters can challenge errors. Equally, allegations against it must be assessed on evidence rather than treated as established merely through repetition. Neither institutional denials nor political accusations can substitute for credible verification.
The scale of this responsibility is evident from the 2024 general election, for which approximately 97.98 crore electors were registered and 64.64 crore votes were polled. The integrity of an institution administering an electoral exercise of this magnitude is a matter of national constitutional importance, not merely a dispute between political competitors.
We are also conscious that institutional independence depends on sound constitutional design, not simply on defending the incumbent office-holder. Questions about the appointment framework for Election Commissioners remain under judicial consideration. Such questions should be resolved through the appropriate constitutional and judicial processes. Our appeal is therefore not to shield any institution from reform, but to ensure that reform is pursued through law, evidence and institutional deliberation.
A constitutional republic must resist the damaging tendency where institutions become hostage to partisan conflict. It makes independent administration increasingly difficult. The answer is not unquestioning institutional loyalty, but principled independence accompanied by transparent accountability.
In this spirit, we respectfully request Your Excellency, acting within the constitutional scope of your office, to lend your voice to the following principles:
1. Protection of constitutional independence: Reaffirm the importance of preserving the autonomy, dignity and lawful functioning of the Election Commission of India, and the constitutional safeguards governing the tenure of its leadership.
2. Commitment to due process: Encourage political parties and public representatives to pursue grievances concerning the Commission through appropriate legal, parliamentary and institutional mechanisms, without resorting to intimidation or extra-constitutional coercion.
3. Transparency in electoral administration: Encourage the competent authorities to ensure that electoral-roll revisions are supported by publicly verifiable data, clear reasons for deletions, effective notice and appeal procedures, and safeguards against the exclusion of eligible voters.
4. Long-term institutional reform: Encourage a non-partisan national discussion on strengthening the independence, accountability and public credibility of electoral institutions, so that their legitimacy rests on robust constitutional safeguards.
Madam President, the strength of a democracy is measured not by the absence of disagreement, but by its capacity to manage disagreement without undermining the institutions that make democratic competition possible. Constitutional institutions must be protected from coercion, just as citizens must be protected from unaccountable authority.
We therefore appeal for a democratic culture in which criticism remains evidence-based, accountability remains meaningful, and institutional independence remains non-negotiable. We stand in solidarity with the constitutional Election Commission of India—not because it must be beyond question, but because no democracy can afford to make the independence of its electoral institutions dependent on the political pressures of the moment.
With profound respect for the Constitution of India and the democratic aspirations of its people
The Undersigned Academics, Researchers, Teachers and Scholars
Date: 13-10-2026
Place: Whole of India

1,107
The Issue
AN OPEN PETITION TO THE HON’BLE PRESIDENT OF INDIA
In Defence of the Constitutional Independence of the Election Commission of India, Democratic Accountability, and the Rule of Law
To
The Hon’ble President of India
Rashtrapati Bhavan
New Delhi – 110004
*Subject: An academic appeal to uphold the constitutional independence of the Election Commission of India and resist extra-constitutional coercion against independent institutions*
*Respected Madam President,*
We, the undersigned academics, researchers, teachers and scholars, write to express our concern over the growing confrontation surrounding the Election Commission of India (ECI), particularly the campaign demanding the resignation of the Chief Election Commissioner. Our concern arises not from an allegiance to any political party or office-holder, but from a commitment to the constitutional principles upon which the Republic of India rests.
A democracy cannot be sustained by elections alone. It also depends upon the credibility of the institutions that administer them, the fairness of the procedures through which political power is contested, and the willingness of all political actors to resolve their disagreements within a constitutional framework.
The Election Commission occupies a uniquely consequential position in this arrangement. It administers the electoral process through which governments acquire democratic legitimacy and citizens exercise their sovereign political choice. Its independence, therefore, is not a privilege granted to its office-holders. It is a safeguard belonging to the electorate.
*We stand in solidarity with the constitutional independence and institutional dignity of the Election Commission of India.* We are concerned by attempts to secure the resignation of its leadership through intimidation, personal threats or extra-constitutional coercion. The tenure of a constitutional functionary must not become contingent upon the intensity of political mobilisation or the capacity of any party or group to exert pressure.
At the same time, our position must be understood precisely. Institutional independence does not confer immunity from criticism, and democratic disagreement must never be mistaken for disloyalty to the nation. Peaceful protest, demands for accountability and scrutiny of electoral administration are legitimate elements of democratic life. The issue is not whether citizens may question the Election Commission; they must be able to do so. The issue is whether questions of institutional responsibility are pursued through evidence, transparent procedures and lawful remedies, rather than intimidation or the presumption of guilt.
Article 324 of the Constitution vests the Election Commission with the superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Article 324(5) provides the Chief Election Commissioner with special protection against removal, placing it on the same grounds and through the same manner applicable to a Judge of the Supreme Court. This constitutional safeguard reflects the importance of insulating the office from arbitrary political retaliation. It should not be reduced to a formality that can be displaced by pressure.
The constitutional significance of electoral integrity has also been recognised by the Supreme Court, including in *Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain* (1975) and Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023). These principles require us to protect the conditions under which elections can be conducted fairly and their administration can command public confidence.
The present controversy over electoral-roll revision makes this responsibility especially urgent. Allegations concerning deletions, verification procedures and the possible exclusion of eligible electors deserve examination. The right to vote is meaningful only when eligible citizens can exercise it in practice. A voter wrongly omitted from an electoral roll is not merely an entry missing from a database; that person may be deprived of an essential means of political participation.
Consequently, defending the Election Commission must go hand in hand with insisting upon transparency. The Commission should be prepared to explain its decisions, publish verifiable data and provide effective procedures through which eligible voters can challenge errors. Equally, allegations against it must be assessed on evidence rather than treated as established merely through repetition. Neither institutional denials nor political accusations can substitute for credible verification.
The scale of this responsibility is evident from the 2024 general election, for which approximately 97.98 crore electors were registered and 64.64 crore votes were polled. The integrity of an institution administering an electoral exercise of this magnitude is a matter of national constitutional importance, not merely a dispute between political competitors.
We are also conscious that institutional independence depends on sound constitutional design, not simply on defending the incumbent office-holder. Questions about the appointment framework for Election Commissioners remain under judicial consideration. Such questions should be resolved through the appropriate constitutional and judicial processes. Our appeal is therefore not to shield any institution from reform, but to ensure that reform is pursued through law, evidence and institutional deliberation.
A constitutional republic must resist the damaging tendency where institutions become hostage to partisan conflict. It makes independent administration increasingly difficult. The answer is not unquestioning institutional loyalty, but principled independence accompanied by transparent accountability.
In this spirit, we respectfully request Your Excellency, acting within the constitutional scope of your office, to lend your voice to the following principles:
1. Protection of constitutional independence: Reaffirm the importance of preserving the autonomy, dignity and lawful functioning of the Election Commission of India, and the constitutional safeguards governing the tenure of its leadership.
2. Commitment to due process: Encourage political parties and public representatives to pursue grievances concerning the Commission through appropriate legal, parliamentary and institutional mechanisms, without resorting to intimidation or extra-constitutional coercion.
3. Transparency in electoral administration: Encourage the competent authorities to ensure that electoral-roll revisions are supported by publicly verifiable data, clear reasons for deletions, effective notice and appeal procedures, and safeguards against the exclusion of eligible voters.
4. Long-term institutional reform: Encourage a non-partisan national discussion on strengthening the independence, accountability and public credibility of electoral institutions, so that their legitimacy rests on robust constitutional safeguards.
Madam President, the strength of a democracy is measured not by the absence of disagreement, but by its capacity to manage disagreement without undermining the institutions that make democratic competition possible. Constitutional institutions must be protected from coercion, just as citizens must be protected from unaccountable authority.
We therefore appeal for a democratic culture in which criticism remains evidence-based, accountability remains meaningful, and institutional independence remains non-negotiable. We stand in solidarity with the constitutional Election Commission of India—not because it must be beyond question, but because no democracy can afford to make the independence of its electoral institutions dependent on the political pressures of the moment.
With profound respect for the Constitution of India and the democratic aspirations of its people
The Undersigned Academics, Researchers, Teachers and Scholars
Date: 13-10-2026
Place: Whole of India

The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 12 October 2026