Make Facial Masks Mandatory in University of Minnesota Buildings

Petition Closed

This petition had 85 supporters

The Issue

Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, public health measures must be in place to severely limit the spread from infected individuals, asymptomatic or not to other members of the public. The University of Minnesota system has over 67,000 students across its campuses, with a majority on the Twin Cities campus. Due to the unprecedented infectivity of COVID-19, individuals who choose not to put on a facemask put others at great risk. At the time of writing, 1.9 million US citizens are infected meaning statistically, at least 400 students will be infected. If any are asymptomatic and due to a lack of mandated face mask policy, they choose not to wear one, another outbreak is inevitable.

The concensus among meta-analyses of mask usage to limit transmission is that mask usage is a good policy. Below are a few, but since this is a hot topic, you can find tons of new ones at PubMed.

https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202004.0203/v1​

https://www.bmj.com/content/369/bmj.m1435.short

Arguments against universal masking are the lack of COVID-19 specific studies and the subsequent risk of triggering a needless mask shortage. The WHO for example has not recommended such a policy due to a lack of infection specific research. It's unlikely that we will ever see a peer reviewed, double blinded, randomized, placebo controlled study on the effectiveness of face masks against COVID-19 due to the ethical constraints of running such a study. But, based on studies of highly similar viruses, SARS in particular, face masking was an effective practice which limited transmission when properly used. Since Fall classes will begin in 2 months, it's expected that a majority of students will have already made or purchased one which may be used since a reasonable fraction of retailers have implemented masking policies, promoting their usage. The minority of facemask hoarders who will don a fresh N-95 mask every day despite a shortage will continue to do so regardless of a policy by the Regents so this should have no significant effects on a shortage, although it may have early on in the pandemic.

As to the efficacy of the various types of masks, although homemade masks were found to be around half as effective as surgical masks in some studies, an ounce of prevention is still better than an ounce of hydroxychloroquine.

The Decision Makers

The Board of Regents of the University of Minnesota

Petition Updates