

Supporting Mumbai Metro Line 3 Carshed at Aarey Milk Colony Locality
The Issue
Currently, everyone is aware of the ongoing Quarrel in Mumbai about the Aarey Carshed of Mumbai Metro Line 3.
There are claims from both sides. But when the So-called environmentalists say that they tell the truth, it becomes heights of Hypocrisy.
Believing them as True environmentalists, people supported them initially, thinking that they really care about the environment. following to this, all the concerned authorities, that's The High Court, Supreme Court, and National Green Tribunal gave clearance to the project stating that it won't harm the environment or Forest, and the long-term advantages be exponential considering factors like reduction in Carbon Emission, etc.
But, even after these statements, the So-called environmentalists continued to oppose the project.
When the Tree factor didn't appease anyone now, they claimed that the mere 33 hector plot (that's 1/3rd of that of Mahalaxmi Racecourse) is home to 5 leopards. If anyone knows Ecology with even the basics, he/she would know how Hilarious the claim is.
When the Leopard Factor didn't work, they started claiming the Plot is a Land scam, initially saying for Rs 60,000 Crores, then randomly Rs 1 Lac Crores, without any proofs or base. Just for Info, 1 Lac Crore is the total budget of the Bullet Train Project, which Includes Land Acquisition from Sabarmati to BKC, Erecting the 508km elevated Corridor, Procuring High-speed Rolling Stock, and commissioning it.
The so-called environmentalists also claimed that Constructing the Carshed would result in flooding of the Marol area due to altering the path of the Mithi River, which is a clearly false claim, anyone who has seen the plan drawing of the Carshed would know the thing.
Along with all these protests and Claims, this has resulted in an escalation of the Project cost going up by Approx Rs 10,000 Cr due to the 2.5-year delay caused by the inactivity of the previous Government. Further delay would add the cost more, and the hardship faced by Common daily commuting Mumbaikar would still continue.
Many Claim that carshed can be made at the Kanjurmarg site, but no one says what would be the additional cost to construct the 12km long Corridor from Aarey to Kanjurmarg, and how many trees would be cut for the same. Also, One can't have his house in Andheri and Washrooms in Kanjurmarg, they need to be together. A carshed or Depot is a place to Park the trains after they are done with their daily duties. This ensures regular maintenance of the trains resulting in flawless services daily. The operating staff also Starts and signs off their duties from the depot. No one has ever parked a Metro train at Random station along the corridor. The same case can be seen for the Buses as well.
These protests have clearly been more political than environmental. Some bodies don't even know clearly that it's a train depot and not an Automobile Car Parking.
So, an appeal to everyone, kindly Know all the details thoroughly and do support the cause to denote what the majority of Mumbaikars want.
I am a Mumbaikar and I support Carshed at Aarey
#CarShedWahiBanega
Petition Closed
The Issue
Currently, everyone is aware of the ongoing Quarrel in Mumbai about the Aarey Carshed of Mumbai Metro Line 3.
There are claims from both sides. But when the So-called environmentalists say that they tell the truth, it becomes heights of Hypocrisy.
Believing them as True environmentalists, people supported them initially, thinking that they really care about the environment. following to this, all the concerned authorities, that's The High Court, Supreme Court, and National Green Tribunal gave clearance to the project stating that it won't harm the environment or Forest, and the long-term advantages be exponential considering factors like reduction in Carbon Emission, etc.
But, even after these statements, the So-called environmentalists continued to oppose the project.
When the Tree factor didn't appease anyone now, they claimed that the mere 33 hector plot (that's 1/3rd of that of Mahalaxmi Racecourse) is home to 5 leopards. If anyone knows Ecology with even the basics, he/she would know how Hilarious the claim is.
When the Leopard Factor didn't work, they started claiming the Plot is a Land scam, initially saying for Rs 60,000 Crores, then randomly Rs 1 Lac Crores, without any proofs or base. Just for Info, 1 Lac Crore is the total budget of the Bullet Train Project, which Includes Land Acquisition from Sabarmati to BKC, Erecting the 508km elevated Corridor, Procuring High-speed Rolling Stock, and commissioning it.
The so-called environmentalists also claimed that Constructing the Carshed would result in flooding of the Marol area due to altering the path of the Mithi River, which is a clearly false claim, anyone who has seen the plan drawing of the Carshed would know the thing.
Along with all these protests and Claims, this has resulted in an escalation of the Project cost going up by Approx Rs 10,000 Cr due to the 2.5-year delay caused by the inactivity of the previous Government. Further delay would add the cost more, and the hardship faced by Common daily commuting Mumbaikar would still continue.
Many Claim that carshed can be made at the Kanjurmarg site, but no one says what would be the additional cost to construct the 12km long Corridor from Aarey to Kanjurmarg, and how many trees would be cut for the same. Also, One can't have his house in Andheri and Washrooms in Kanjurmarg, they need to be together. A carshed or Depot is a place to Park the trains after they are done with their daily duties. This ensures regular maintenance of the trains resulting in flawless services daily. The operating staff also Starts and signs off their duties from the depot. No one has ever parked a Metro train at Random station along the corridor. The same case can be seen for the Buses as well.
These protests have clearly been more political than environmental. Some bodies don't even know clearly that it's a train depot and not an Automobile Car Parking.
So, an appeal to everyone, kindly Know all the details thoroughly and do support the cause to denote what the majority of Mumbaikars want.
I am a Mumbaikar and I support Carshed at Aarey
#CarShedWahiBanega
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 25 July 2022