Support the Judicial Contempt Accountability and Due Process Act of 2025

2

Let’s get to 5 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

My name is Jimmy P, and I'm a Floridian who believes in fairness and accountability in our courts. I've seen how the power of contempt can be misused not to preserve order, but to punish people for perceived disrespect or minor gestures that pose no threat to justice.

In Florida, a person can be jailed for up to six months for “contempt” without a jury, lawyer, or real hearing. Losing one’s freedom because a judge feels personally offended is not justice; it’s abuse of authority. This issue is deeply personal to me because I believe judges should uphold the law, not stand above it.

The Judicial Contempt Accountability and Due Process Act of 2025 aims to reform the system by ensuring that penalties are appropriate, reasonable, and consistent with the principles of fair justice. This bill includes provisions for ensuring that judges do not use contempt as a tool of personal vendetta. It proposes limits on contempt penalties and the removal of immunity for judges who act with malice or bias.

By supporting this bill, we can protect both the dignity of the courts and the rights of the people. It ensures that no one loses their liberty to ego or emotion, but only to due process and the rule of law. We need a judicial system where judges are accountable, and this act is a crucial step in achieving that.

Sign this petition to urge lawmakers to pass the Judicial Contempt Accountability and Due Process Act of 2025 and ensure justice remains fair for all.

 

Judicial Contempt Accountability and Due Process Act of 2025 Proposal 


A Bill to be Entitled
An act relating to judicial contempt, accountability, and due process; amending chapter 38, Florida Statutes; providing for proportional sentencing, due process safeguards, limits on judicial immunity, and independent review of contempt orders; providing an effective date.

 
Section 1. Short Title
This act may be cited as the “Judicial Contempt Accountability and Due Process Act of 2025.”

 
Section 2. Legislative Findings and Intent
(1) The Legislature finds that:
(a) The contempt power is essential to maintain order and authority within Florida’s courts, yet unchecked use of that power has resulted in arbitrary arrests, excessive confinement, and deprivation of liberty without due process.
(b) Existing law permits up to six months’ incarceration for contempt, a penalty disproportionate to the severity of the conduct and inconsistent with principles of fairness.
(c) Public trust in the judiciary requires transparency, proportionality, and accountability for malicious or prejudiced use of judicial power.

(2) It is the intent of the Legislature to:
(a) Protect the integrity of the judicial process while safeguarding constitutional rights;
(b) Establish reasonable limits on contempt sanctions;
(c) Provide due process and independent review of contempt orders; and
(d) Create civil and criminal liability for judges who abuse their authority with malice or prejudice.

 
Section 3. Section 38.22, Florida Statutes, Amended
38.22 Contempts; limitations on summary punishment.

(1) Courts may punish for contempt as provided by law; however, the power shall be exercised strictly in accordance with constitutional due process and this section.

(2) A judge may summarily punish direct criminal contempt only when—
(a) The contemptuous conduct occurs in the immediate presence of the court and causes an actual and substantial obstruction of judicial proceedings; and
(b) Immediate punishment is necessary to maintain order or ensure safety.

(3) Limitations on punishment.
(a) For direct contempt, incarceration shall not exceed 24 hours, and any fine shall not exceed $500.
(b) For criminal contempt following a hearing under Rule 3.840, Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure, incarceration shall not exceed 10 days, and any fine shall not exceed $1,000.
(c) For civil contempt, confinement may continue only so long as the contemnor has the present ability to comply with the court’s lawful order.

(4) Procedural safeguards for direct contempt.
Before imposing summary punishment, the court must:
(a) Inform the alleged contemnor of the specific conduct constituting contempt;
(b) Afford a reasonable opportunity to explain, apologize, or present mitigating facts; and
(c) State on the record the factual basis for the finding and the reasons immediate punishment is required.

(5) If the alleged contempt involves personal insult, disrespect, or affront directed at the presiding judge, another judge shall conduct any further proceedings or determine punishment.

(6) All contempt proceedings shall be recorded, and any order of incarceration shall be in writing, reciting the facts, findings, and punishment imposed.

(7) Any contempt order resulting in incarceration shall be automatically reviewed within 72 hours by the chief judge of the circuit or a higher court to ensure compliance with this section and the Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure.

(8) Abuse of contempt authority constitutes judicial misconduct subject to investigation by the Judicial Qualifications Commission under Article V, section 12 of the Florida Constitution.

 
Section 4. Section 38.24, Florida Statutes, Amended
38.24 Judgment of contempt; record; appellate review.

(1) Every judgment of contempt shall be in writing and shall specify the acts constituting contempt, the evidence relied upon, and the punishment imposed.

(2) A person adjudged in contempt shall have the right to immediate appeal. Execution of any incarceration exceeding 12 hours shall be stayed upon filing of a notice of appeal unless the reviewing court finds that immediate confinement is essential to maintain order or safety.

 
Section 5. Judicial Immunity; Exceptions for Malicious or Unlawful Conduct
(1) A judge of this state shall not be immune from civil liability for acts performed in a judicial capacity when:
(a) The act was committed with actual malice, personal bias, or willful intent to deprive a person of liberty or rights guaranteed under the Constitution or laws of the United States or this state;
(b) The act was performed in the clear absence of jurisdiction; or
(c) The act involved the knowing issuance of an unlawful order of arrest, confinement, or punishment for contempt.

(2) A person injured by conduct described in subsection (1) may bring a civil action against the judge for damages, attorney’s fees, and equitable relief.

(3) Any judge who, under color of judicial authority, willfully deprives another person of liberty or property without due process of law, or orders confinement for contempt in bad faith or with malice, commits a felony of the third degree, punishable as provided in §§ 775.082 and 775.083, Florida Statutes.

(4) Nothing in this section shall impair judicial immunity for good-faith judicial acts taken within lawful jurisdiction and without malice or bias.

 
Section 6. Transparency and Reporting
(1) The Office of the State Courts Administrator shall publish quarterly reports detailing contempt citations, penalties imposed, and reversals or modifications on appeal.
(2) Reports shall exclude personal identifiers and be publicly accessible on the Florida Courts website.

Petition Updates