Other school districts expressly allow restricted smartwatches. Why not St. Vrain?


Our grassroots effort is continuing, and we now have 184 supporters -- just 16 signatures from 200. Thank you to everyone who has signed, shared, and helped keep this issue moving.
There is an important development worth sharing: school districts in different parts of the country explicitly distinguish between wearing a smartwatch and using its distracting features.
That is the same distinction we are asking St. Vrain to recognize.
These examples come directly from the districts’ published policies:
- Weld RE-4, Colorado: At every grade level, smartwatches may remain worn, silenced, and used strictly for timekeeping. Communication, games, notifications, and other non-watch functions violate the policy.
- School District 197, Minnesota: Its elementary procedures expressly exempt smartwatches from the storage requirement. Calls and texts remain prohibited, and parents are directed to use Do Not Disturb, with Apple Schooltime specifically identified as an example.
- Grapevine-Colleyville ISD, Texas: Students may wear personal smartwatches to check the time. Using them for calls, messages, or other communication results in confiscation.
- Weber School District, Utah: District policy permits smartwatch wear while prohibiting application use during restricted periods, including the entire elementary school day.
The details differ, but the central point is clear: restricting device use does not automatically require prohibiting smartwatch wear.
Why is St. Vrain continuing to require removal when other districts have written this distinction directly into their rules?
Our request remains narrow: allow qualifying, parent-managed smartwatches to remain on students’ wrists in Schooltime or an equivalent restricted mode, with ordinary school-day use limited to checking the time. Calls, messages, games, and other distracting activities would remain prohibited. Parents would manage the settings, and misuse would carry consequences, including loss of the wearing privilege.
There are also unanswered questions about how St. Vrain reached its decision.
In its August 12 announcement, the district said the changes “come directly from the feedback we received from our community and from our school administrative teams.”
The district has produced more than 1,000 pages of material in response to our public-records request. Our review has identified internal discussion and administrator input, including staff descriptions of parent support for existing cellphone practices.
What we have not identified is documentation of a district-led parent survey, listening session, or comparable opportunity for families to weigh in specifically on requiring restricted smartwatches to be removed before that requirement was adopted. We also have not identified an analysis establishing why wearing a watch in a restricted mode requires the same treatment as using an unrestricted device.
Informing parents of a decision is not the same as inviting their input before making it.
We have asked the district to identify any records that correct these findings. Whether you support or oppose smartwatch wear, parents, taxpayers, and community members deserve a clear explanation of what input informed a districtwide decision affecting their children.
Today, October 6, marks 33 days since our original public-records request. Supplemental records supplied September 30 resolved significant issues, but questions remain about whether relevant text messages were searched and the location or custodian of a referenced document the district could not locate. I sent another follow-up today requesting substantive answers by October 8.
Our substantive questions to the Board also remain unanswered.
We continue to support distraction-free schools. We are asking St. Vrain to explain its decision, meaningfully engage families, and consider a narrow approach that other districts already expressly permit.
Please help us reach 200 supporters and keep growing:
Share this petition directly with at least one St. Vrain parent, friend, or neighbor today.
Ask them to read the proposal, sign if they agree, and share it with someone else.
Explain the request simply: worn in restricted mode, with ordinary use limited to telling time.
Sign and share the petition here.
Thank you for helping keep this issue visible. We are continuing to press for answers and a practical resolution.
Braun Mincher
Braun@BraunMincher.com