Message aux signatairesSupport Phone-Free SVVSD Schools -- But Allow Smartwatches in "School Mode" for PK-8

184 Signatures and Growing -- Help Us Reach 200 and Bring Parents Into the Conversation

Braun MincherErie, CO, États-Unis
30 sept. 2026

Thank you to everyone who has signed, shared, and helped bring attention to this issue. We are now at 184 verified signatures -- just 16 away from the next milestone of 200! This grassroots effort continues to grow through conversations among families, neighbors, and friends.

Once we reach 200, we intend to send another update to the School Board and Superintendent, renewing our request for a narrow, practical clarification. Please keep sharing SmartWatchChoice.org, especially with other St. Vrain families.

Our request remains simple: continuous wear does not mean continuous use.

We support phone-free, distraction-free classrooms. We are asking that qualifying, parent-managed smartwatches be allowed to remain on PK-8 students’ wrists in a restricted school mode, with ordinary school-day use limited to checking the time.

Calls, messages, games, and other distracting activities would remain prohibited. Parents would configure the watches. Staff would address observable misuse. A student whose watch becomes a distraction could be required to remove it, with repeated misuse resulting in loss of that individual student’s wearing privilege.

That preserves the watch’s practical value before and after school without allowing classroom communication or entertainment.

Amy Bounds’ reporting last weekend, which appeared in the Boulder Daily Camera, Longmont Times-Call, and Colorado Hometown Weekly, brought greater attention to both the district’s position and families’ concerns. I have heard from additional people as a result. Another media outlet contacted me this week about potentially covering the story, and further media outreach is underway.

Read the Boulder Daily Camera article here.

As our public-records review continues, two questions remain especially important.

First, where is the record of parent input on the smartwatch-removal requirement?

In its August 12 announcement, SVVSD said the changes came “directly from the feedback we received from our community and from our school administrative teams.”

The CORA production includes substantial internal communications, administrator input, and staff descriptions of purported parent support for existing cellphone practices. But, our review has not identified any records documenting a district-led process asking parents about the proposed smartwatch-removal requirement before adoption, or substantive parent/community feedback on that specific proposal.

We have repeatedly asked the district to identify records that would correct that finding. Our review of tonight’s additional production remains underway.

Support for putting phones away does not establish support for requiring children to remove restricted watches. Regardless of someone’s position on smartwatches, families deserve to understand whose feedback informed this decision and how alternatives were evaluated.

Second, what evidence supports requiring restricted watches to be removed?

The records reviewed so far have not identified incident data demonstrating classroom disruption specifically from watches operating in Schooltime or an equivalent restricted mode, or a documented evaluation explaining why that alternative was rejected.

Tonight’s production includes an FHS document concerning Frederick High School’s cellphone practices. Its student FAQ answers “Can I wear my smartwatch?” with:

“Yes, smartwatches are allowed. Teachers will address individually if they are a distraction to learning.”

This document does not establish the current districtwide rule. However, it does show that distinguishing between wearing a watch and addressing individual distraction has appeared in the district’s own school guidance.

Other districts also make that distinction. Nearby Weld RE-4 permits silent smartwatches to remain worn strictly as timepieces. Minnesota’s School District 197 expressly excepts elementary smartwatches from its storage requirement and directs families toward do-not-disturb settings, including Apple Schooltime. These are published policy examples demonstrating that an alternative exists.

The American Academy of Pediatrics’ educator guidance likewise recommends school-hour restrictions on notifications, games, and media, and specifically explains Apple Schooltime. 

If SVVSD wants more local evidence, we remain willing to help with a controlled pilot that measures disruptions, compliance, and staff workload, with a defined review date.

Obtaining the public record has also required persistent follow-up.

Our Colorado Open Records Act request was submitted September 3, 2026 -- now 27 calendar days ago. The district described its response as "complete" on September 17, 18, and 22, yet still supplied additional requested documents tonight after further follow-up.

We appreciate that production, which substantially addresses the attachment issues, subject to review. However, questions remain about text-message search coverage. Counsel now says the policy work was not conducted through district-operated messaging systems. We have asked separately whether the search included responsive texts on district-issued devices and district-business texts on personal devices or accounts within the district’s custody or control.

CORA generally presumes availability within three working days, with extensions permitted for qualifying circumstances. We continue to maintain our stated deadline position while working directly with district counsel to resolve the remaining questions.

You can review the production and correspondence in our shared records folder. Request access through the link, and we will be happy to grant it. We want supporters and other interested readers to examine the records for themselves.

Our goal is a workable clarification: allow qualifying restricted smartwatches to remain worn, address actual misuse individually, and preserve focused classrooms. If the district prefers to evaluate that approach through a pilot, we are ready to participate.

Please keep sharing the petition. You can also write respectfully to BoardofEducation@svvsd.org and Kapushion_Jackie@svvsd.org, explain your family’s experience, and ask for this narrow clarification or a controlled pilot.

Thank you for helping families be heard. Questions, comments, and experiences are welcome at Braun@BraunMincher.com.

Soutenir maintenant
Signez cette pétition