Strengthen New Hampshire's Penalties for Wildlife Cruelty

1,668

The Issue

Over the course of about a week in June, someone drove a utility vehicle down Bog Road in Hillsborough, New Hampshire, and killed at least 15 painted turtles on purpose. Wildlife officers eventually identified Charles Puccio, 78, as the person behind it. One incident stands out: a witness watched him get out of his vehicle, pick up a nesting turtle, set her down in the road, and stomp on her. That turtle survived only because the witness rushed her to New Hampshire Turtle Rescue, where she is still recovering months later and will not be released back into the wild until spring 2027.

Puccio pleaded guilty on August 18 to misdemeanor cruelty to wild animals and two lesser violations. That is the entire legal consequence for killing more than a dozen turtles and crushing another one under his boot: modest fines, and little else.

Painted turtles need years to reach breeding age, and every nesting female killed takes her future offspring with her. New Hampshire's current wildlife cruelty laws simply do not reflect how serious, and how deliberate, this kind of harm can be.

We are calling on the New Hampshire Legislature to strengthen penalties for intentional cruelty to wildlife, so a case like this results in consequences that actually match the crime.

Sign the petition to demand tougher wildlife cruelty penalties in New Hampshire, before another animal pays the price for a law that is not taking this seriously.

J
M
K
A
Petition Advocates

The Decision Makers

New Hampshire House of Representatives
2 Members
1 Responded
James Spillane
New Hampshire House of Representatives - District Rockingham 2
Thank you for reaching out and for giving me the opportunity to respond directly to the 530 constituents who have signed this petition. I want them to know that I fully support strengthening New Hampshire’s penalties for intentional and egregious acts of wildlife cruelty. I was outraged and frankly sickened when I learned of the deliberate crushing and killing of these turtles. There is an enormous difference between the lawful taking of wildlife through hunting, fishing, trapping, or legitimate wildlife management and the intentional torture or wanton killing of an animal simply for the sake of causing suffering or destruction. What was allegedly done to these turtles falls into an entirely different and deeply disturbing category. As Chairman of the New Hampshire House Fish & Game and Marine Resources Committee, I strongly believe our laws should recognize that distinction. When someone intentionally tortures wildlife or engages in an egregious act of cruelty such as deliberately crushing nesting turtles, the potential penalty should reflect the seriousness of that conduct. A minor penalty is simply inadequate for conduct this deliberate and horrifying. New Hampshire has a proud tradition of responsible stewardship of our wildlife and natural resources. Protecting that tradition means not only supporting ethical hunters, anglers, trappers, conservation officers, and wildlife professionals, but also ensuring that those who intentionally and maliciously torture or destroy wildlife can face meaningful consequences. Please share with the petition signers my full support for examining and strengthening these penalties. I appreciate their advocacy and their willingness to bring this issue to the Legislature’s attention. Sincerely, James A. Spillane Chairman House Fish & Game and Marine Resources Committee New Hampshire House of Representatives [Note: The Change.org Civic Engagement Team reaches out to decision makers to let them know about petitions in their community and to help facilitate engagement with supporters. The above was an email response we received regarding this petition.]
Mike Ouellet
New Hampshire House of Representatives - District Coos 3
New Hampshire State Senate
2 Members
Kevin Avard
New Hampshire State Senate - District 12
Howard Pearl
New Hampshire State Senate - District 17

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates