
Stop the harmful use of tebuthiuron in Taos County
The Issue
Petition: Halt the Aerial Herbicide Drop Above the Rio Grande Until BLM Completes the Analysis
Rio Grande del Norte National Monument, Cones Fire Project (DOI-BLM-NM-F020-2025-0001-EA) ·
A note on donations to Change.org: Please do not donate through Change.org. Sacred Earth Alliance is in the process of finding a fiscal sponsor. Until then, we gratefully accept donations directly. Donations are not tax-deductible at this time.
To donate, email sacredearthalliancetaos@gmail.com.
Who this petition is addressed to
Decision-makers (the ones who can act):
BLM Taos Field Office, Field Manager, and the Rio Grande del Norte National Monument Manager
BLM Farmington District Manager (the Taos Field Office reports to this office)
BLM New Mexico State Director
Copied, with a request that they intervene (federal):
New Mexico's two U.S. Senators
The U.S. Representative for New Mexico's 3rd Congressional District (Taos and Rio Arriba counties)
Copied, with a request that they intervene (state and local):
Governor of New Mexico
The New Mexico state senators and state representatives for every district in Taos and Rio Arriba counties
New Mexico State Land Office (Commissioner of Public Lands). 13,899 acres of the project area are State Trust Land.
New Mexico Environment Department, Surface Water Quality Bureau
New Mexico Department of Agriculture, Pesticide Compliance program
New Mexico Energy, Minerals and Natural Resources Department, Forestry Division, Rare and Endangered Plant Program. The Assessment identifies potential habitat for rare plants, including Taos milkvetch and clipped wild buckwheat, along the Rio Grande Gorge rim within the treatment area.
Taos County and Rio Arriba County Commissions
The Pueblos and Tribes BLM lists as consulted, including Taos Pueblo, Picuris Pueblo and Ohkay Owingeh
Our statement
We, the undersigned residents, river users, and neighbors of the Rio Grande del Norte National Monument, call on the Bureau of Land Management to postpone the aerial application of the herbicide tebuthiuron in the Cones Fire Project until BLM has given the public a complete, updated analysis (current as of November 2026), real data from its past herbicide treatments, and a fair chance to comment.
The project's Environmental Assessment allows BLM to drop tebuthiuron pellets from aircraft on up to 13,706 acres of sagebrush (the largest figure the Assessment gives) within the 106,634-acre project area above the Rio Grande Gorge. By BLM's own account, the herbicide works once rain carries it into the soil, it can stay active for two to four years, and the watersheds of the project area ultimately flow into the Rio Grande. Even so, the Assessment dismisses surface water quality without detailed analysis. It contains no runoff study, no water testing plan, no stated buffer distance from the river, and no data from the herbicide treatments BLM has already carried out on this landscape. The only formal public comment period the Assessment describes was in 2020, and residents were not given the dates of the drop.
The Cones Fire Project covers 106,634 acres. Across that whole area it authorizes tree and sagebrush thinning, prescribed fire and managed wildfire. Herbicide is limited to the sagebrush areas, but the Assessment gives three different figures for how much can be sprayed: 13,706 acres (70% of 19,580 sagebrush acres, Table 7, p. 21), 9,781 acres (p. 39), and 70% of the acreage outside the exclusion areas, roughly 6,850 acres (p. 17). In October 2026 BLM announced an aerial drop of about 2,929 acres north of Cerro Chiflo and east of Cerro de la Olla, for the first two weeks of November. BLM has not told the public how many acres have been sprayed under this project so far or how many remain. This petition addresses every future drop. We support responsible wildfire management and restoration with regenerative solutions that do not have long lasting detriment to the watershed and wildlife inhabitants. Sagebrush is a native plant, and a native plant community should not be chemically suppressed without full disclosure of the impacts, the objectives and the results.
The Rio Grande beside the project area is a federal Wild and Scenic River. Since 2022 the State of New Mexico has also protected this stretch, from the Colorado state line to the Rio Pueblo de Taos, as an Outstanding National Resource Water, the state's highest level of water quality protection. A decision to drop herbicide above it deserves more than the single table entry that dismisses water quality from detailed analysis (Table 2, p. 11).
What we are asking for
Tell us the dates of the next herbicide drop, now. We demand that BLM publicly state the exact dates (or date window) of the next aerial tebuthiuron application, which treatment units and acres will be treated, and which aircraft contractor will apply it. When residents asked in person, Eric Valencia of the Taos Field Office would give only a general window, not exact dates, and that is not sufficient. The Assessment itself states that the public will be informed with signage in areas where tebuthiuron will be applied, before aerial application and shortly after (p. 70). Post the dates at least 30 days ahead on the BLM website, at trailhead kiosks, at the Wild Rivers Visitor Center, in the Taos News, and to all BLM field and law enforcement staff, and give the same notice for every future drop.
State how many acres will be sprayed. Resolve the Assessment's conflicting figures (13,706, 9,781 and roughly 6,850 acres) and publish one authorized total. Publish the acres already treated under this project, with dates and maps, and the acres and locations still planned.
Pause the herbicide drop. Do not apply tebuthiuron in the Cones Fire Project until the steps below are done and the public has been given the dates.
Show the results of past herbicide drops. The Assessment reports 10,004 acres of past sagebrush treatments in the project area, including 2,500 acres of chemical treatment (p. 27), and cites BLM monitoring reports, but presents none of the underlying data. BLM's October 2026 announcement claims past tebuthiuron treatments produced 75% less bare ground and 120% more perennial grass cover than untreated plots, yet the underlying data have not been released. Make the data public so independent ecologists can review it. Release, for every past tebuthiuron treatment in the Taos Field Office:maps showing where and when herbicide was applied, with topography and drainages
the pre- and post-treatment monitoring data, including the 2012–2015 Farmington tebuthiuron monitoring report and the AIM plot data BLM relies on
whether the treatments actually reduced fire fuels and improved plant diversity
whether invasive weeds such as cheatgrass came in afterward, and what BLM did about them.
Release any water testing, and commit to new testing. Disclose any sampling ever done for tebuthiuron in the Rio Grande, its side drainages, springs, stock tanks or wells near past treatment areas. Identify the distance from every treatment unit to wells, springs, recharge areas and the gorge rim. The Assessment's groundwater depth comes from a 2007 county map, so verify it at each treatment site, including springs in the gorge. If none exists, say so, and commit to baseline sampling, using laboratory methods able to detect 0.1 micrograms per liter (the EU limit for any single pesticide in drinking water), before application and to sampling after rain and snowmelt events afterward, with results made public.
Analyze runoff properly in a revised Environmental Assessment. The revised analysis should cover rain and spring snowmelt moving herbicide toward the river during the two-to-four-year period it stays active; the actual distance between treatment areas and the gorge rim, as well as the landscape slope analysis; the river's Outstanding National Resource Water status; effects on fish, acequias and downstream water users; and a fixed, mapped no-application buffer along the rim and every drainage.
Account for repeated and combined herbicide use. Analyze the cumulative effects of successive tebuthiuron drops on the same landscape, each active in the soil for two to four years, together with other herbicide treatments in the Taos Field Office, such as the drone application of the herbicide imazapic for cheatgrass on Cerro de la Olla. Analyze effects on pollinators, birds, small mammals and soil organisms as well as on water.
Disclose the objectives of the treatments.
State plainly whether increasing livestock forage or benefiting grazing permits is among the purposes of the herbicide treatments, alongside wildfire risk reduction. The Assessment describes reduced forage for livestock as a baseline problem (p. 28) and cites a study finding that tebuthiuron increased forage production (p. 40).
Reopen public comment and hold a public meeting in Taos. The Assessment describes one formal comment period, August 5 to September 5, 2020. It says the project was "again available" on BLM's website from October 18, 2024 "until finalized," but describes no new comment period and no public meeting before the April 2025 decision.
Work with the Taos community on non-herbicide, regenerative alternatives. We ask BLM to form a working group with local residents, acequia associations, grazing permittees, the Pueblos, conservation organizations, and soil and restoration specialists, and to develop sagebrush and fuels treatments together that do not rely on chemical herbicides. BLM has already analyzed a no-herbicide option (Alternative D: mechanical treatment and prescribed fire), so a non-chemical path is available under the existing analysis. The working group should evaluate approaches such as mosaic mowing and hand thinning, prescribed fire, managed grazing, native seed collection and reseeding, and protection of biological soil crusts. It should also set shared goals for fire risk reduction, plant diversity, soil health and water quality, and monitor results together in the field, with the data made public. The Assessment says the project team was formed under CFRP grant funding (p. 72). In New Mexico, CFRP is the Collaborative Forest Restoration Program, a federal program designed around community collaboration. The people who live alongside this landscape should help shape how it is restored.
Finish the required consultations first. Complete cultural resource surveys and Section 106 consultation with the Pueblos and Tribes before any treatment. The Assessment says about 76,634 acres still need an approved cultural resource survey before treatment (p. 23), and that Section 106 consultation is not covered by the Assessment and still needs to be completed (p. 67).
Fix how the Taos Field Office communicates with the public. Keep one clearly marked webpage listing every project open for comment, where and how to submit comments, deadlines, and the dates of public meetings.
Respond in writing. Provide a written, reasoned response to each request in this petition, consistent with the Administrative Procedure Act's requirement that an agency give prompt notice and a brief statement of grounds when it denies a written request (5 U.S.C. § 555(e)). The response should identify the authority and evidence for continuing each future treatment, and the administrative review or appeal options available to the public.
Why the current Assessment is not enough
These points come from BLM's own final Environmental Assessment (April 2025). Page numbers are the document's printed page numbers.
The Assessment does not agree with itself on how much land can be sprayed. It gives 13,706 acres (Table 7, p. 21), 9,781 acres (p. 39), and 70% of the area outside the exclusions, about 6,850 acres (p. 17). The public cannot evaluate a plan whose size is not consistently stated.
Water quality was dismissed, not analyzed. Surface Water Quality is listed under "Issues Not Analyzed in Detail" (Table 2, p. 11). The only reasons given are that BLM will follow the EPA label precautions, that exclusion areas are mapped in an appendix, and that groundwater is 250–1,000 feet deep.
The herbicide needs rain, and it stays. The Assessment says tebuthiuron becomes effective when sufficient rainfall moves it into the root zone, and that it has a two-to-four-year residual on dry sites (p. 17). It never examines where that water goes next.
Everything drains to the Rio Grande. The Assessment states that all drainage basins in the project area ultimately flow into the Rio Grande (p. 28). The soils and watershed analysis (pp. 28–30) still never discusses herbicide carried by runoff.
No buffer distance is stated. The protection is a set of "exclusion areas" around playas, drainages and rivers, shown only on maps in a separate 17 MB appendix (Design Feature 31, p. 24). The text gives no distance from the river or the gorge rim. Meanwhile, rare plant habitat "along the Rio Grande Gorge rim" is described as lying inside the treatment area (pp. 57, 60).
Fish were dismissed because the river is outside the boundary. Rio Grande chub, Rio Grande sucker and Rio Grande cutthroat trout were dropped from analysis because aquatic habitat is "not present in the project area" (pp. 45–48). That ignores what can wash out of the project area and into the river.
The Assessment contradicts itself on riparian areas. It states that no riparian areas occur in the project area (p. 47). Elsewhere it lists riparian and ephemeral playa wetland acreage inside the treatment units and adds design features to protect them (pp. 14–15, 24).
There is no water monitoring plan. The Assessment's monitoring commitments cover vegetation, weeds, rare plants and wildlife (for example, p. 21). None of them involves testing water.
No results from past treatments are shown. The Assessment says monitoring has found no increase in weeds in treated areas (p. 29), but presents no data, maps or reports to back it up. It also contradicts itself: elsewhere it states that a temporary increase in noxious and invasive weeds is expected (p.
12). New Mexico's water protections are not mentioned. The Assessment never mentions the Outstanding National Resource Water designation, New Mexico's surface water quality standards, acequias or downstream water users.
The public process is out of date. Scoping was done internally in November 2017 (p. 9). The only formal comment period ran August 5 to September 5, 2020. The revised Assessment was posted October 18, 2024 "until finalized" (p. 73), and the Decision Record and Finding of No Significant Impact are dated April 23, 2025.
A no-herbicide option was analyzed. Alternative D treats sagebrush with mechanical methods and prescribed fire instead of chemicals (p. 26), so a path forward without herbicide has already been analyzed.
Effects on the soil are admitted to be unknown. The Assessment states that little information exists on the effects of herbicide on biological soil crusts, which hold desert soils in place (p. 29).
The Taos Field Office has paused aerial spraying before. In 2023 the Taos Field Office declined a proposal for aerial insecticide spraying in the Rio Chama watershed. It said additional environmental analysis and outreach were needed and should be done in an open and transparent way. The same standard should apply here.
How tebuthiuron is treated elsewhere, and what EPA itself found
Not approved in the European Union. Tebuthiuron has not been approved for use in the EU since 2002, when Commission Regulation (EC) No 2076/2002 listed it among active substances that would not be included for use. It remains "not approved" under the EU's current pesticide law, Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009. To be fair to the record, the 2002 decision was not a finding that tebuthiuron is unsafe: it was removed because it was not supported through the EU's safety review. Under EU law, a pesticide may be used only after its safety has been affirmatively demonstrated, and tebuthiuron never has been.
The EU's drinking water limit. The EU Drinking Water Directive (EU) 2020/2184 sets a precautionary limit of 0.1 micrograms per liter for any single pesticide in drinking water, regardless of its toxicity. The United States has no enforceable federal drinking water standard for tebuthiuron. EPA has only a non-binding lifetime health advisory of 500 micrograms per liter, 5,000 times higher than the EU limit.
Very persistent and highly leachable. The University of Hertfordshire's Pesticide Properties Database, used by European regulators, gives tebuthiuron a typical soil half-life of 400 days ("very persistent"), high water solubility (2,500 mg/L), and a leaching index of 5.36 ("high leachability"), and flags it as a potential groundwater contaminant.
EPA's own findings. In its 1994 reregistration fact sheet, EPA stated that tebuthiuron "is persistent and mobile and can leach to ground water," that its main route of dissipation is mobility, and that transport to surface water through runoff is also likely. EPA found that rangeland use exceeds its high level of concern for nontarget land and aquatic plants, and that all registered uses pose a significant risk to off-site endangered plant species. That finding bears directly on the rare plants the Assessment identifies along the gorge rim. EPA's required groundwater label warning focuses on shallow water tables (30 feet or less), and the Assessment relies on groundwater being 250–1,000 feet deep. But depth to groundwater does nothing to protect against surface runoff into drainages, springs in the gorge, and the river itself, which is exactly the pathway EPA identified and the Assessment never analyzes. The Assessment's groundwater figure also comes from a 2007 county map, not site-specific measurements.
Irrigation water. Canada's interim water quality guideline for tebuthiuron in irrigation water is 0.27 micrograms per liter. That benchmark matters for acequias and other users who take water downstream of treated land.
The European Union keeps tebuthiuron off the market altogether, and EPA's own records describe it as persistent, mobile and a risk to nontarget plants. A herbicide like that should not be dropped above an Outstanding National Resource Water without water testing, a runoff analysis and full public disclosure.
What residents have experienced
Information is hard to find. The Taos Field Office's website does not clearly show which projects are open for public comment, where to submit comments, or when and where public forums will be held.
There was no comment on the revised plan. The 2020 draft had a public comment period. The Assessment describes no new comment period or public meeting for the revised version approved in April 2025.
The notice did not reach the public. BLM's announcement of the November drop was titled "Thinning Treatments Planned to Strengthen Public Land Resilience and Wildfire Preparedness in Northern Taos County." The title says nothing about herbicide. Only the body explains that aircraft would drop tebuthiuron pellets on about 2,929 acres over roughly three days sometime in the first two weeks of November. It says treated areas would stay open to the public, and that pellets would not be applied "near waterways," without saying how near. It also says signs would be posted at nearby informational kiosks. Residents checked the Field Office's news page on November 2 and found no notice. They first saw the announcement on November 4, and it was not posted at the Wild Rivers Visitor Center.
The dates are withheld. Residents asked Eric Valencia of the Taos Field Office in person for the planned dates of the aerial herbicide drop. He would not give exact dates, only a general window. A window is not sufficient. People who live, graze livestock, haul water, hike and raft here need to know the actual days aircraft will be dropping herbicide so they can protect their families, animals and water.
BLM's own state law enforcement was not informed. One day before the proposed two-week application window began, the lead BLM law enforcement ranger for the area did not know the herbicide drop was planned. The Assessment commits BLM to posting signs where tebuthiuron will be applied, and BLM's announcement prohibited recreational drone use in the treatment area during the drop. The officer responsible for public safety on these lands cannot enforce those measures, or answer visitors' questions about a drop he has not been told about. If BLM did not inform its own ranger, it has not informed the public.
Legal basis
This petition is made under the First Amendment right to petition the government and the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. §§ 555(e), 706). It invokes the National Environmental Policy Act, the Federal Land Policy and Management Act, the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act, the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act, and New Mexico water quality standards (20.6.4 NMAC), to the extent each applies. This petition does not itself suspend any agency decision.
Sources
Upcoming herbicide airdrops keep residents on edge — Taos News, Oct. 2026
Protesters take herbicide objections to Taos BLM office — Taos News, Nov. 2026
Thinning Treatments Planned to Strengthen Public Land Resilience — BLM announcement, Oct. 21, 2026
2026 Cones TEB Treatment map — BLM
Cones Fire Project on BLM ePlanning
Tebuthiuron R.E.D. Facts — U.S. EPA, 1994
Tebuthiuron water quality guidelines — Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment
Tebuthiuron Ecological Risk Assessment — BLM, 2005
Tebuthiuron — EU ban since 2002
Contact:
Sacred Earth Alliance
sacredearthalliancetaos@gmail.com

1,290
The Issue
Petition: Halt the Aerial Herbicide Drop Above the Rio Grande Until BLM Completes the Analysis
Rio Grande del Norte National Monument, Cones Fire Project (DOI-BLM-NM-F020-2025-0001-EA) ·
A note on donations to Change.org: Please do not donate through Change.org. Sacred Earth Alliance is in the process of finding a fiscal sponsor. Until then, we gratefully accept donations directly. Donations are not tax-deductible at this time.
To donate, email sacredearthalliancetaos@gmail.com.
Who this petition is addressed to
Decision-makers (the ones who can act):
BLM Taos Field Office, Field Manager, and the Rio Grande del Norte National Monument Manager
BLM Farmington District Manager (the Taos Field Office reports to this office)
BLM New Mexico State Director
Copied, with a request that they intervene (federal):
New Mexico's two U.S. Senators
The U.S. Representative for New Mexico's 3rd Congressional District (Taos and Rio Arriba counties)
Copied, with a request that they intervene (state and local):
Governor of New Mexico
The New Mexico state senators and state representatives for every district in Taos and Rio Arriba counties
New Mexico State Land Office (Commissioner of Public Lands). 13,899 acres of the project area are State Trust Land.
New Mexico Environment Department, Surface Water Quality Bureau
New Mexico Department of Agriculture, Pesticide Compliance program
New Mexico Energy, Minerals and Natural Resources Department, Forestry Division, Rare and Endangered Plant Program. The Assessment identifies potential habitat for rare plants, including Taos milkvetch and clipped wild buckwheat, along the Rio Grande Gorge rim within the treatment area.
Taos County and Rio Arriba County Commissions
The Pueblos and Tribes BLM lists as consulted, including Taos Pueblo, Picuris Pueblo and Ohkay Owingeh
Our statement
We, the undersigned residents, river users, and neighbors of the Rio Grande del Norte National Monument, call on the Bureau of Land Management to postpone the aerial application of the herbicide tebuthiuron in the Cones Fire Project until BLM has given the public a complete, updated analysis (current as of November 2026), real data from its past herbicide treatments, and a fair chance to comment.
The project's Environmental Assessment allows BLM to drop tebuthiuron pellets from aircraft on up to 13,706 acres of sagebrush (the largest figure the Assessment gives) within the 106,634-acre project area above the Rio Grande Gorge. By BLM's own account, the herbicide works once rain carries it into the soil, it can stay active for two to four years, and the watersheds of the project area ultimately flow into the Rio Grande. Even so, the Assessment dismisses surface water quality without detailed analysis. It contains no runoff study, no water testing plan, no stated buffer distance from the river, and no data from the herbicide treatments BLM has already carried out on this landscape. The only formal public comment period the Assessment describes was in 2020, and residents were not given the dates of the drop.
The Cones Fire Project covers 106,634 acres. Across that whole area it authorizes tree and sagebrush thinning, prescribed fire and managed wildfire. Herbicide is limited to the sagebrush areas, but the Assessment gives three different figures for how much can be sprayed: 13,706 acres (70% of 19,580 sagebrush acres, Table 7, p. 21), 9,781 acres (p. 39), and 70% of the acreage outside the exclusion areas, roughly 6,850 acres (p. 17). In October 2026 BLM announced an aerial drop of about 2,929 acres north of Cerro Chiflo and east of Cerro de la Olla, for the first two weeks of November. BLM has not told the public how many acres have been sprayed under this project so far or how many remain. This petition addresses every future drop. We support responsible wildfire management and restoration with regenerative solutions that do not have long lasting detriment to the watershed and wildlife inhabitants. Sagebrush is a native plant, and a native plant community should not be chemically suppressed without full disclosure of the impacts, the objectives and the results.
The Rio Grande beside the project area is a federal Wild and Scenic River. Since 2022 the State of New Mexico has also protected this stretch, from the Colorado state line to the Rio Pueblo de Taos, as an Outstanding National Resource Water, the state's highest level of water quality protection. A decision to drop herbicide above it deserves more than the single table entry that dismisses water quality from detailed analysis (Table 2, p. 11).
What we are asking for
Tell us the dates of the next herbicide drop, now. We demand that BLM publicly state the exact dates (or date window) of the next aerial tebuthiuron application, which treatment units and acres will be treated, and which aircraft contractor will apply it. When residents asked in person, Eric Valencia of the Taos Field Office would give only a general window, not exact dates, and that is not sufficient. The Assessment itself states that the public will be informed with signage in areas where tebuthiuron will be applied, before aerial application and shortly after (p. 70). Post the dates at least 30 days ahead on the BLM website, at trailhead kiosks, at the Wild Rivers Visitor Center, in the Taos News, and to all BLM field and law enforcement staff, and give the same notice for every future drop.
State how many acres will be sprayed. Resolve the Assessment's conflicting figures (13,706, 9,781 and roughly 6,850 acres) and publish one authorized total. Publish the acres already treated under this project, with dates and maps, and the acres and locations still planned.
Pause the herbicide drop. Do not apply tebuthiuron in the Cones Fire Project until the steps below are done and the public has been given the dates.
Show the results of past herbicide drops. The Assessment reports 10,004 acres of past sagebrush treatments in the project area, including 2,500 acres of chemical treatment (p. 27), and cites BLM monitoring reports, but presents none of the underlying data. BLM's October 2026 announcement claims past tebuthiuron treatments produced 75% less bare ground and 120% more perennial grass cover than untreated plots, yet the underlying data have not been released. Make the data public so independent ecologists can review it. Release, for every past tebuthiuron treatment in the Taos Field Office:maps showing where and when herbicide was applied, with topography and drainages
the pre- and post-treatment monitoring data, including the 2012–2015 Farmington tebuthiuron monitoring report and the AIM plot data BLM relies on
whether the treatments actually reduced fire fuels and improved plant diversity
whether invasive weeds such as cheatgrass came in afterward, and what BLM did about them.
Release any water testing, and commit to new testing. Disclose any sampling ever done for tebuthiuron in the Rio Grande, its side drainages, springs, stock tanks or wells near past treatment areas. Identify the distance from every treatment unit to wells, springs, recharge areas and the gorge rim. The Assessment's groundwater depth comes from a 2007 county map, so verify it at each treatment site, including springs in the gorge. If none exists, say so, and commit to baseline sampling, using laboratory methods able to detect 0.1 micrograms per liter (the EU limit for any single pesticide in drinking water), before application and to sampling after rain and snowmelt events afterward, with results made public.
Analyze runoff properly in a revised Environmental Assessment. The revised analysis should cover rain and spring snowmelt moving herbicide toward the river during the two-to-four-year period it stays active; the actual distance between treatment areas and the gorge rim, as well as the landscape slope analysis; the river's Outstanding National Resource Water status; effects on fish, acequias and downstream water users; and a fixed, mapped no-application buffer along the rim and every drainage.
Account for repeated and combined herbicide use. Analyze the cumulative effects of successive tebuthiuron drops on the same landscape, each active in the soil for two to four years, together with other herbicide treatments in the Taos Field Office, such as the drone application of the herbicide imazapic for cheatgrass on Cerro de la Olla. Analyze effects on pollinators, birds, small mammals and soil organisms as well as on water.
Disclose the objectives of the treatments.
State plainly whether increasing livestock forage or benefiting grazing permits is among the purposes of the herbicide treatments, alongside wildfire risk reduction. The Assessment describes reduced forage for livestock as a baseline problem (p. 28) and cites a study finding that tebuthiuron increased forage production (p. 40).
Reopen public comment and hold a public meeting in Taos. The Assessment describes one formal comment period, August 5 to September 5, 2020. It says the project was "again available" on BLM's website from October 18, 2024 "until finalized," but describes no new comment period and no public meeting before the April 2025 decision.
Work with the Taos community on non-herbicide, regenerative alternatives. We ask BLM to form a working group with local residents, acequia associations, grazing permittees, the Pueblos, conservation organizations, and soil and restoration specialists, and to develop sagebrush and fuels treatments together that do not rely on chemical herbicides. BLM has already analyzed a no-herbicide option (Alternative D: mechanical treatment and prescribed fire), so a non-chemical path is available under the existing analysis. The working group should evaluate approaches such as mosaic mowing and hand thinning, prescribed fire, managed grazing, native seed collection and reseeding, and protection of biological soil crusts. It should also set shared goals for fire risk reduction, plant diversity, soil health and water quality, and monitor results together in the field, with the data made public. The Assessment says the project team was formed under CFRP grant funding (p. 72). In New Mexico, CFRP is the Collaborative Forest Restoration Program, a federal program designed around community collaboration. The people who live alongside this landscape should help shape how it is restored.
Finish the required consultations first. Complete cultural resource surveys and Section 106 consultation with the Pueblos and Tribes before any treatment. The Assessment says about 76,634 acres still need an approved cultural resource survey before treatment (p. 23), and that Section 106 consultation is not covered by the Assessment and still needs to be completed (p. 67).
Fix how the Taos Field Office communicates with the public. Keep one clearly marked webpage listing every project open for comment, where and how to submit comments, deadlines, and the dates of public meetings.
Respond in writing. Provide a written, reasoned response to each request in this petition, consistent with the Administrative Procedure Act's requirement that an agency give prompt notice and a brief statement of grounds when it denies a written request (5 U.S.C. § 555(e)). The response should identify the authority and evidence for continuing each future treatment, and the administrative review or appeal options available to the public.
Why the current Assessment is not enough
These points come from BLM's own final Environmental Assessment (April 2025). Page numbers are the document's printed page numbers.
The Assessment does not agree with itself on how much land can be sprayed. It gives 13,706 acres (Table 7, p. 21), 9,781 acres (p. 39), and 70% of the area outside the exclusions, about 6,850 acres (p. 17). The public cannot evaluate a plan whose size is not consistently stated.
Water quality was dismissed, not analyzed. Surface Water Quality is listed under "Issues Not Analyzed in Detail" (Table 2, p. 11). The only reasons given are that BLM will follow the EPA label precautions, that exclusion areas are mapped in an appendix, and that groundwater is 250–1,000 feet deep.
The herbicide needs rain, and it stays. The Assessment says tebuthiuron becomes effective when sufficient rainfall moves it into the root zone, and that it has a two-to-four-year residual on dry sites (p. 17). It never examines where that water goes next.
Everything drains to the Rio Grande. The Assessment states that all drainage basins in the project area ultimately flow into the Rio Grande (p. 28). The soils and watershed analysis (pp. 28–30) still never discusses herbicide carried by runoff.
No buffer distance is stated. The protection is a set of "exclusion areas" around playas, drainages and rivers, shown only on maps in a separate 17 MB appendix (Design Feature 31, p. 24). The text gives no distance from the river or the gorge rim. Meanwhile, rare plant habitat "along the Rio Grande Gorge rim" is described as lying inside the treatment area (pp. 57, 60).
Fish were dismissed because the river is outside the boundary. Rio Grande chub, Rio Grande sucker and Rio Grande cutthroat trout were dropped from analysis because aquatic habitat is "not present in the project area" (pp. 45–48). That ignores what can wash out of the project area and into the river.
The Assessment contradicts itself on riparian areas. It states that no riparian areas occur in the project area (p. 47). Elsewhere it lists riparian and ephemeral playa wetland acreage inside the treatment units and adds design features to protect them (pp. 14–15, 24).
There is no water monitoring plan. The Assessment's monitoring commitments cover vegetation, weeds, rare plants and wildlife (for example, p. 21). None of them involves testing water.
No results from past treatments are shown. The Assessment says monitoring has found no increase in weeds in treated areas (p. 29), but presents no data, maps or reports to back it up. It also contradicts itself: elsewhere it states that a temporary increase in noxious and invasive weeds is expected (p.
12). New Mexico's water protections are not mentioned. The Assessment never mentions the Outstanding National Resource Water designation, New Mexico's surface water quality standards, acequias or downstream water users.
The public process is out of date. Scoping was done internally in November 2017 (p. 9). The only formal comment period ran August 5 to September 5, 2020. The revised Assessment was posted October 18, 2024 "until finalized" (p. 73), and the Decision Record and Finding of No Significant Impact are dated April 23, 2025.
A no-herbicide option was analyzed. Alternative D treats sagebrush with mechanical methods and prescribed fire instead of chemicals (p. 26), so a path forward without herbicide has already been analyzed.
Effects on the soil are admitted to be unknown. The Assessment states that little information exists on the effects of herbicide on biological soil crusts, which hold desert soils in place (p. 29).
The Taos Field Office has paused aerial spraying before. In 2023 the Taos Field Office declined a proposal for aerial insecticide spraying in the Rio Chama watershed. It said additional environmental analysis and outreach were needed and should be done in an open and transparent way. The same standard should apply here.
How tebuthiuron is treated elsewhere, and what EPA itself found
Not approved in the European Union. Tebuthiuron has not been approved for use in the EU since 2002, when Commission Regulation (EC) No 2076/2002 listed it among active substances that would not be included for use. It remains "not approved" under the EU's current pesticide law, Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009. To be fair to the record, the 2002 decision was not a finding that tebuthiuron is unsafe: it was removed because it was not supported through the EU's safety review. Under EU law, a pesticide may be used only after its safety has been affirmatively demonstrated, and tebuthiuron never has been.
The EU's drinking water limit. The EU Drinking Water Directive (EU) 2020/2184 sets a precautionary limit of 0.1 micrograms per liter for any single pesticide in drinking water, regardless of its toxicity. The United States has no enforceable federal drinking water standard for tebuthiuron. EPA has only a non-binding lifetime health advisory of 500 micrograms per liter, 5,000 times higher than the EU limit.
Very persistent and highly leachable. The University of Hertfordshire's Pesticide Properties Database, used by European regulators, gives tebuthiuron a typical soil half-life of 400 days ("very persistent"), high water solubility (2,500 mg/L), and a leaching index of 5.36 ("high leachability"), and flags it as a potential groundwater contaminant.
EPA's own findings. In its 1994 reregistration fact sheet, EPA stated that tebuthiuron "is persistent and mobile and can leach to ground water," that its main route of dissipation is mobility, and that transport to surface water through runoff is also likely. EPA found that rangeland use exceeds its high level of concern for nontarget land and aquatic plants, and that all registered uses pose a significant risk to off-site endangered plant species. That finding bears directly on the rare plants the Assessment identifies along the gorge rim. EPA's required groundwater label warning focuses on shallow water tables (30 feet or less), and the Assessment relies on groundwater being 250–1,000 feet deep. But depth to groundwater does nothing to protect against surface runoff into drainages, springs in the gorge, and the river itself, which is exactly the pathway EPA identified and the Assessment never analyzes. The Assessment's groundwater figure also comes from a 2007 county map, not site-specific measurements.
Irrigation water. Canada's interim water quality guideline for tebuthiuron in irrigation water is 0.27 micrograms per liter. That benchmark matters for acequias and other users who take water downstream of treated land.
The European Union keeps tebuthiuron off the market altogether, and EPA's own records describe it as persistent, mobile and a risk to nontarget plants. A herbicide like that should not be dropped above an Outstanding National Resource Water without water testing, a runoff analysis and full public disclosure.
What residents have experienced
Information is hard to find. The Taos Field Office's website does not clearly show which projects are open for public comment, where to submit comments, or when and where public forums will be held.
There was no comment on the revised plan. The 2020 draft had a public comment period. The Assessment describes no new comment period or public meeting for the revised version approved in April 2025.
The notice did not reach the public. BLM's announcement of the November drop was titled "Thinning Treatments Planned to Strengthen Public Land Resilience and Wildfire Preparedness in Northern Taos County." The title says nothing about herbicide. Only the body explains that aircraft would drop tebuthiuron pellets on about 2,929 acres over roughly three days sometime in the first two weeks of November. It says treated areas would stay open to the public, and that pellets would not be applied "near waterways," without saying how near. It also says signs would be posted at nearby informational kiosks. Residents checked the Field Office's news page on November 2 and found no notice. They first saw the announcement on November 4, and it was not posted at the Wild Rivers Visitor Center.
The dates are withheld. Residents asked Eric Valencia of the Taos Field Office in person for the planned dates of the aerial herbicide drop. He would not give exact dates, only a general window. A window is not sufficient. People who live, graze livestock, haul water, hike and raft here need to know the actual days aircraft will be dropping herbicide so they can protect their families, animals and water.
BLM's own state law enforcement was not informed. One day before the proposed two-week application window began, the lead BLM law enforcement ranger for the area did not know the herbicide drop was planned. The Assessment commits BLM to posting signs where tebuthiuron will be applied, and BLM's announcement prohibited recreational drone use in the treatment area during the drop. The officer responsible for public safety on these lands cannot enforce those measures, or answer visitors' questions about a drop he has not been told about. If BLM did not inform its own ranger, it has not informed the public.
Legal basis
This petition is made under the First Amendment right to petition the government and the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. §§ 555(e), 706). It invokes the National Environmental Policy Act, the Federal Land Policy and Management Act, the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act, the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act, and New Mexico water quality standards (20.6.4 NMAC), to the extent each applies. This petition does not itself suspend any agency decision.
Sources
Upcoming herbicide airdrops keep residents on edge — Taos News, Oct. 2026
Protesters take herbicide objections to Taos BLM office — Taos News, Nov. 2026
Thinning Treatments Planned to Strengthen Public Land Resilience — BLM announcement, Oct. 21, 2026
2026 Cones TEB Treatment map — BLM
Cones Fire Project on BLM ePlanning
Tebuthiuron R.E.D. Facts — U.S. EPA, 1994
Tebuthiuron water quality guidelines — Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment
Tebuthiuron Ecological Risk Assessment — BLM, 2005
Tebuthiuron — EU ban since 2002
Contact:
Sacred Earth Alliance
sacredearthalliancetaos@gmail.com

The Decision Makers


Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on October 28, 2026