
Stop mortgage lenders from coercing borrowers into consent to share tax data for marketing
The Issue
Stop Mortgage Lenders From Forcing Borrowers to Consent to Share Tax Return Information for Marketing to Get a Home Loan.
To: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), and the Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization (MISMO)
Your federal tax return is among the most deeply personal, sensitive financial records you own. It reveals everything about your life—your income, your family structure, your charitable giving, your medical deductions, and your financial vulnerabilities. Because tax records are so extraordinarily private, federal law strictly guards them. When you share that information with a mortgage lender, its use must be restricted to one narrow, legitimate purpose: verifying your ability to repay your home loan.
Under no circumstances should a homebuyer be forced to allow their confidential tax records to be widely shared, mined, or exploited for purposes completely unrelated to their mortgage.
Yet that is exactly what happens every single day across the American mortgage industry.
When homebuyers apply for a mortgage, federal law (Section 2202 of the Taxpayer First Act) requires lenders to get "express permission" before sharing IRS tax transcripts with third parties. To comply with the law, the Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization (MISMO) drafted sample consent language that most lenders and secondary-market investors (like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) adopted.
That industry-standard form reads verbatim:
"I understand, acknowledge, and agree that the Lender and Other Loan Participants can obtain, use and
share tax return information for purposes of (i) providing an offer; (ii) originating, maintaining,
managing, monitoring, servicing, selling, insuring, and securitizing a loan; (iii) marketing; or (iv) as
otherwise permitted by applicable laws, including state and federal privacy and data security laws. The
Lender includes the Lender’s affiliates, agents, service providers and any of aforementioned parties’
successors and assigns. The Other Loan Participants includes any actual or potential owners of a loan
resulting from your loan application, or acquirers of any beneficial or other interest in the loan, any
mortgage insurer, guarantor, any servicers or service providers for these parties and any of
aforementioned parties’ successors and assigns."
Look closely at item (iii): "marketing."
Lenders present this form as an all-or-nothing ultimatum. If you refuse to sign away your tax privacy for marketing purposes, your mortgage application stops dead in its tracks. You cannot cross out the marketing clause, and you cannot opt out.
This is coercion, not consent. "Express permission" is meaningless when a family is forced to choose between surrendering their most private IRS records to corporate marketing departments or losing the home they want to buy.
Tax data is not a commodity to be passed around for cross-selling financial products or third-party promotions. Its use by lenders must be strictly confined to originating and servicing the specific loan the borrower applied for—period.
We call on the CFPB, FHFA, and MISMO to take immediate action to protect American homebuyers:
- Ban Mandatory Marketing Consent: Prohibit mortgage lenders from requiring borrowers to consent to marketing or internal marketing analysis as a condition of applying for, processing, or receiving a mortgage.
- Enforce Strict Purpose Limitations: Mandate that tax return information obtained during a mortgage application be used exclusively for verifying eligibility, underwriting, servicing, and required secondary-market transfers for that specific loan.
- Separate Optional Marketing: Require that any request to use borrower data for marketing be placed on a completely separate, voluntary opt-in form that has zero impact on loan approval or processing.
Specifically:
We are asking the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) to classify mandatory, bundled marketing consent as an "Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Act or Practice" (UDAAP) under Dodd-Frank Act.
We are asking Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) to issue a directive ordering Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to strip "(iii) marketing" from their acceptable consent templates.
We are asking the Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization (MISMO) to revise their published consent to share tax return template form and remove "(iii) marketing" clause.
Sign this petition to demand that federal regulators close this privacy loophole and ensure that homebuyers never again have to surrender their confidential IRS tax records just to get a mortgage.
29
The Issue
Stop Mortgage Lenders From Forcing Borrowers to Consent to Share Tax Return Information for Marketing to Get a Home Loan.
To: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), and the Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization (MISMO)
Your federal tax return is among the most deeply personal, sensitive financial records you own. It reveals everything about your life—your income, your family structure, your charitable giving, your medical deductions, and your financial vulnerabilities. Because tax records are so extraordinarily private, federal law strictly guards them. When you share that information with a mortgage lender, its use must be restricted to one narrow, legitimate purpose: verifying your ability to repay your home loan.
Under no circumstances should a homebuyer be forced to allow their confidential tax records to be widely shared, mined, or exploited for purposes completely unrelated to their mortgage.
Yet that is exactly what happens every single day across the American mortgage industry.
When homebuyers apply for a mortgage, federal law (Section 2202 of the Taxpayer First Act) requires lenders to get "express permission" before sharing IRS tax transcripts with third parties. To comply with the law, the Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization (MISMO) drafted sample consent language that most lenders and secondary-market investors (like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) adopted.
That industry-standard form reads verbatim:
"I understand, acknowledge, and agree that the Lender and Other Loan Participants can obtain, use and
share tax return information for purposes of (i) providing an offer; (ii) originating, maintaining,
managing, monitoring, servicing, selling, insuring, and securitizing a loan; (iii) marketing; or (iv) as
otherwise permitted by applicable laws, including state and federal privacy and data security laws. The
Lender includes the Lender’s affiliates, agents, service providers and any of aforementioned parties’
successors and assigns. The Other Loan Participants includes any actual or potential owners of a loan
resulting from your loan application, or acquirers of any beneficial or other interest in the loan, any
mortgage insurer, guarantor, any servicers or service providers for these parties and any of
aforementioned parties’ successors and assigns."
Look closely at item (iii): "marketing."
Lenders present this form as an all-or-nothing ultimatum. If you refuse to sign away your tax privacy for marketing purposes, your mortgage application stops dead in its tracks. You cannot cross out the marketing clause, and you cannot opt out.
This is coercion, not consent. "Express permission" is meaningless when a family is forced to choose between surrendering their most private IRS records to corporate marketing departments or losing the home they want to buy.
Tax data is not a commodity to be passed around for cross-selling financial products or third-party promotions. Its use by lenders must be strictly confined to originating and servicing the specific loan the borrower applied for—period.
We call on the CFPB, FHFA, and MISMO to take immediate action to protect American homebuyers:
- Ban Mandatory Marketing Consent: Prohibit mortgage lenders from requiring borrowers to consent to marketing or internal marketing analysis as a condition of applying for, processing, or receiving a mortgage.
- Enforce Strict Purpose Limitations: Mandate that tax return information obtained during a mortgage application be used exclusively for verifying eligibility, underwriting, servicing, and required secondary-market transfers for that specific loan.
- Separate Optional Marketing: Require that any request to use borrower data for marketing be placed on a completely separate, voluntary opt-in form that has zero impact on loan approval or processing.
Specifically:
We are asking the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) to classify mandatory, bundled marketing consent as an "Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Act or Practice" (UDAAP) under Dodd-Frank Act.
We are asking Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) to issue a directive ordering Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to strip "(iii) marketing" from their acceptable consent templates.
We are asking the Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization (MISMO) to revise their published consent to share tax return template form and remove "(iii) marketing" clause.
Sign this petition to demand that federal regulators close this privacy loophole and ensure that homebuyers never again have to surrender their confidential IRS tax records just to get a mortgage.
The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 13, 2026