

Stop arbitrary application of negative CIFAS markers
The Issue
My husband, a dedicated volunteer for a charitable organisation, became embroiled in an unexpected financial predicament. The organisation he was associated with applied for funding through the National Lottery Community Fund (NLCF). Sadly, this resulted in a CIFAS marker being placed on his personal record without prior notification. This marker has had devastating consequences, leading to the closure of both his personal and business bank accounts, despite no clear evidence of fraud.
CIFAS markers are intended to flag fraudulent activities, yet the process lacks transparency and clear guidelines for disputing and challenging these markers when they are wrongly applied. In cases where no explicit fraud is identified, assigning such markers becomes not only punitive but excessive.
The implications are profound and multifaceted, affecting one’s personal and professional life in profound ways. Financial institutions and organizations, such as the National Lottery Community Fund, should not be allowed to wield such power arbitrarily. The current system offers little recourse for those unjustly marked, enabling potentially damaging decisions to be made with little oversight and no clear path to resolution.
This petition calls for a comprehensive review and overhaul of the CIFAS marker application process, demanding transparency and accountability. We propose a structured and fair system where individuals can contest the application of markers, particularly in cases without verified fraud.
The government and financial oversight bodies must institute clear, accessible, and efficient mechanisms for individuals to challenge CIFAS markers. This includes establishing an independent review panel, clear communication of decisions and reasons, and a straightforward appeal process.
Join us in urging the responsible parties to consider the severe implications of their current practices and enact immediate changes. Sign this petition to bring attention to the urgent need for reform in the application of CIFAS markers to ensure justice, fairness, and transparency for all.
1
The Issue
My husband, a dedicated volunteer for a charitable organisation, became embroiled in an unexpected financial predicament. The organisation he was associated with applied for funding through the National Lottery Community Fund (NLCF). Sadly, this resulted in a CIFAS marker being placed on his personal record without prior notification. This marker has had devastating consequences, leading to the closure of both his personal and business bank accounts, despite no clear evidence of fraud.
CIFAS markers are intended to flag fraudulent activities, yet the process lacks transparency and clear guidelines for disputing and challenging these markers when they are wrongly applied. In cases where no explicit fraud is identified, assigning such markers becomes not only punitive but excessive.
The implications are profound and multifaceted, affecting one’s personal and professional life in profound ways. Financial institutions and organizations, such as the National Lottery Community Fund, should not be allowed to wield such power arbitrarily. The current system offers little recourse for those unjustly marked, enabling potentially damaging decisions to be made with little oversight and no clear path to resolution.
This petition calls for a comprehensive review and overhaul of the CIFAS marker application process, demanding transparency and accountability. We propose a structured and fair system where individuals can contest the application of markers, particularly in cases without verified fraud.
The government and financial oversight bodies must institute clear, accessible, and efficient mechanisms for individuals to challenge CIFAS markers. This includes establishing an independent review panel, clear communication of decisions and reasons, and a straightforward appeal process.
Join us in urging the responsible parties to consider the severe implications of their current practices and enact immediate changes. Sign this petition to bring attention to the urgent need for reform in the application of CIFAS markers to ensure justice, fairness, and transparency for all.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 25 September 2025