

Prohibit the proposed increase in mineral extraction at Gale Common, North Yorkshire
The Issue
A planning application has been submitted to North Yorkshire County Council by a company called EPUK Investments Ltd. (EPUKI), proposing an increase in mineral extraction at a site called Gale Common. The Gale Common site is located approximately 3 miles to the south-west of Eggborough Power Station, approximately 700 metres to the east of the village of Cridling Stubbs, and immediately south of the M62 Motorway.
Gale Common is a facility for the processing and long-term storage of pulverised fuel ash (PFA), also known as fly or flue ash, from Ferrybridge and Eggborough power stations. The PFA is received in slurry form via underground pipelines, is formed into hills, and then landscaped.
The site has been developed in three phases – I, II and III. Stage I was completed in 1994, reaching a height of 69 metres, and has since been restored and landscaped. Stages II and III are not yet complete, however the closure of both Eggborough and Ferrybridge power stations means the site no longer receives any PFA.
Permission for development of the site to dispose of the PFA was originally granted in 1963, with a maximum timeframe for completion of disposal activities and subsequent full restoration of the site to a landscape in keeping with the natural surroundings.
PFA has a range of uses in the construction industry, such as in road construction, building embankments and the manufacture of blocks, tiles and slabs.
Currently, up to 30,000 tonnes of PFA can be extracted from the stockpiles per year, and sold on to the customers in the construction industry. However, the planning application proposes a development of the facilities at the site, allowing for up to 1 million tonnes of PFA to be extracted per year, for a period of 25 years. The extraction will take place from Stages II and III, leaving the completed Stage I as it is.
The plan is to transport the PFA by HGV via one of two proposed routes: the first option is east to Whitley via Cobcroft Lane; the second, west to the A1 via Stubbs Lane. However, there may be a third route in the future: the agreement which the site owners intend to operate under stipulates an exception to the agreed route for “local traffic”. Whilst they don’t currently have the facility to accept PFA in its “wet” form, with Plasmor Limited (a privately owned concrete block and concrete block paving manufacturer supplying a comprehensive range) located on the outskirts of the local town of Knottingley, an agreement may be made to sell to them in the future, which would create a third route: HGV traffic turning left out of the site and using Cobcroft Lane to the junction just outside Cridling Stubbs, before turning right along Northfield Lane into Knottingley.
Under the current permission, operational hours run from 07:00 to 17:00 Monday to Friday and 07:00 to 12:00 on Saturday.
30,000 tonnes to 1,000,000 is obviously a dramatic increase, and this will be reflected in the site's working hours and amount of HGVs on the road: in excess of 250 wagon loads of ash per day, for at least 25 to 30 years, with the new application proposing to extend working hours to 05:00 to 21:00 every day, seven days a week. It should also be noted that the site is only currently worked during summer months, whereas the new application would extend this to 12 months of the year.
As a community we strongly desire the application’s rejection, as there are major concerns about this plan going ahead:
The health and safety concerns:
· The inhalation of PFA particles could result in illness and death in residents and site workers: PFA can contain substances that cause major health problems in humans - such constituents that are found at various concentrations in PFA include arsenic, cadmium, chromium, cobalt, copper, lead, lithium, mercury, molybdenum, selenium, thallium, silica, boron and uranium. Even though reusing PFA minimises health effects in humans, health problems can still occur when coal ash is recycled. Specifically, workers drilling or cutting encapsulated coal ash increase their risk of inhaling coal ash dust. In addition, when unencapsulated coal ash is scattered on snowy streets in the winter, the loose ash can come in contact with ditches on the side of the road. As a result, the toxins from coal ash can ‘leach’ into the water streams polluting aboveground waterways and eventually contaminating underground water supplies (drinking water). Therefore, both forms of recycled coal ash (encapsulated and unencapsulated) can cause serious health issues in humans.
· Such a dramatic increase in vehicles raising the likelihood of road accidents, with the fact that said vehicles are HGVs increasing the likelihood that an accident would be fatal: the first route option (Whitley via Cobcroft Lane) uses a road that people have already deemed incredibly dangerous, and a primary school sits on this road, so if the plan is approved, the danger to the school’s children will be even greater than it was before; also, in regards to the first route option, the road surface is poor, the road is barely wide enough to allow two vehicles of the size proposed to pass each other, there is a blind bend towards Whitley and there are no footpaths to allow pedestrians to take refuge from fast moving vehicles (the road is subject to the national speed limit along the majority of the route); in regard to the potential third option (Plasmor Limited via left on Cobcroft Lane, before turning right along Northfield Lane into Knottingley), as well as being windy and narrow in general, Northfield Lane narrows significantly at the entrance to Knottingley, creating a road traffic hazard were large vehicles to use this route.
· The air pollution caused by the HGVs resulting in pollution related illness and death.
· The light pollution created by the site and vehicles operating at the times proposed and the effects this will have on the health of the area’s residents.
· Such a dramatic increase in vehicles will limit - if not eliminate - the access of walkers and cyclists, which will have negative effects on both the physical and mental health of residents.
· The dramatic increase in vehicles on the roads, slowing down emergency services in a rural area where response times are already relatively slow - this in combination with either of the two circumstances above could prove fatal.
The environmental concerns:
· The carbon footprint of such a high number of vehicles operating for such an extended period of time, especially when those vehicles are as polluting as HGVs.
· The air pollution of such a high number of vehicles operating for such an extended period of time, especially when those vehicles are as polluting as HGVs.
· The effects that the air pollution will have on the health of the area’s flora and fauna.
· The inhalation of PFA particles could result in illness and death in of flora and fauna.
· The light pollution created by the site and vehicles operating at the times proposed, and the effects this will have on the health of the area’s flora and fauna.
· Such a dramatic increase in vehicles will limit - if not eliminate - the access of walkers and cyclists, which will have negative effect on the environment, as where people could have walked or cycled somewhere, they will be forced to use their cars.
· The disturbance to wildlife that the physical presence of both the vehicles and the workers will cause.
· The noise and vibrations generated by the stream of HGVs disturbing the animals of the area.
· Long-term negative effects on the Green Belt.
· The hills created by the PFA have become a natural part of the landscape, and due the limited activity on the site, the flora and fauna have been allowed to flourish. As such, the removal of these hills will destroy what has essentially become a rewilded area.
Animals in the area include: deer; bats; owls; foxes; badgers; rabbits; donkeys and goats (from a sanctuary that is quite literally next door to the site); sheep (owned by a local farmer that graze, again, next door to the site); horses (owned by a local stable).
The quality of life/miscellaneous concerns:
· The destruction of scenery by the constant stream of HGVs and/or the fact that the hills - which have become an integral part of the landscape - are being removed.
· The destruction of the peace and quiet via noise pollution, and the effects this will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· The effects that light pollution will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· Residents already feel the effects of activity on the site, both noise related and visual, but at least these are limited mainly to weekday daytimes during summer, when the hours of daylight cover the full working period. Were the application granted as submitted, those impacts would extend to weekends, when parishioners are most likely to be using the gardens and other outside space that they value so highly and also into the hours of darkness, which would require floodlighting to facilitate operations and therefore add light pollution to the list of impacts felt by residents.
· The elimination of access for both walkers and cyclists on roads that are frequented by both groups, and the effects this will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· Road congestion (affecting both the access of residents and anyone who is passing through the area), and the effects this will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· The increase in vehicles on the area’s roads resulting in resident’s vehicles consistently needing cleaning – this is already an issue due to the HGVs working at Gale Common and the quarry at Darrington.
· Permission for development of the site to dispose of PFA from local coal fired power stations was originally granted in 1963, with a maximum timeframe for completion of disposal activities and subsequent full restoration of the site to a landscape in keeping with the natural surroundings. The planning application reneges on this promise, which creates a precedent of moving the goal posts, leaving residents to wonder if in the future something else will be forced upon them again.
· The amalgamation of environmental, health, and other concerns lowering the value of people’s homes.
Even if the removal of the PFA was non-negotiable, there are other more environmentally friendly ways it could be transported – there is access to railway and waterway, and the pipeline used to channel the PFA in, could be utilised to remove it again.
The meeting at which the application’s outcome will be decided will take place on Thursday, 30th July.
The plans can be viewed at https://onlineplanningregister.northyorks.gov.uk/register/PlanAppSrch.aspx using the planning application reference number NY/2019/0091/ENV.
Objections can be emailed to the planning control department at planning.control@northyorks.gov.uk (if you wish, you can also copy in Selby and Ainsty’s MP Nigel Adams at nigel.adams.mp@parliament.uk) - you must cite the planning application reference number NY/2019/0091/ENV in your email.
Petition Closed
The Issue
A planning application has been submitted to North Yorkshire County Council by a company called EPUK Investments Ltd. (EPUKI), proposing an increase in mineral extraction at a site called Gale Common. The Gale Common site is located approximately 3 miles to the south-west of Eggborough Power Station, approximately 700 metres to the east of the village of Cridling Stubbs, and immediately south of the M62 Motorway.
Gale Common is a facility for the processing and long-term storage of pulverised fuel ash (PFA), also known as fly or flue ash, from Ferrybridge and Eggborough power stations. The PFA is received in slurry form via underground pipelines, is formed into hills, and then landscaped.
The site has been developed in three phases – I, II and III. Stage I was completed in 1994, reaching a height of 69 metres, and has since been restored and landscaped. Stages II and III are not yet complete, however the closure of both Eggborough and Ferrybridge power stations means the site no longer receives any PFA.
Permission for development of the site to dispose of the PFA was originally granted in 1963, with a maximum timeframe for completion of disposal activities and subsequent full restoration of the site to a landscape in keeping with the natural surroundings.
PFA has a range of uses in the construction industry, such as in road construction, building embankments and the manufacture of blocks, tiles and slabs.
Currently, up to 30,000 tonnes of PFA can be extracted from the stockpiles per year, and sold on to the customers in the construction industry. However, the planning application proposes a development of the facilities at the site, allowing for up to 1 million tonnes of PFA to be extracted per year, for a period of 25 years. The extraction will take place from Stages II and III, leaving the completed Stage I as it is.
The plan is to transport the PFA by HGV via one of two proposed routes: the first option is east to Whitley via Cobcroft Lane; the second, west to the A1 via Stubbs Lane. However, there may be a third route in the future: the agreement which the site owners intend to operate under stipulates an exception to the agreed route for “local traffic”. Whilst they don’t currently have the facility to accept PFA in its “wet” form, with Plasmor Limited (a privately owned concrete block and concrete block paving manufacturer supplying a comprehensive range) located on the outskirts of the local town of Knottingley, an agreement may be made to sell to them in the future, which would create a third route: HGV traffic turning left out of the site and using Cobcroft Lane to the junction just outside Cridling Stubbs, before turning right along Northfield Lane into Knottingley.
Under the current permission, operational hours run from 07:00 to 17:00 Monday to Friday and 07:00 to 12:00 on Saturday.
30,000 tonnes to 1,000,000 is obviously a dramatic increase, and this will be reflected in the site's working hours and amount of HGVs on the road: in excess of 250 wagon loads of ash per day, for at least 25 to 30 years, with the new application proposing to extend working hours to 05:00 to 21:00 every day, seven days a week. It should also be noted that the site is only currently worked during summer months, whereas the new application would extend this to 12 months of the year.
As a community we strongly desire the application’s rejection, as there are major concerns about this plan going ahead:
The health and safety concerns:
· The inhalation of PFA particles could result in illness and death in residents and site workers: PFA can contain substances that cause major health problems in humans - such constituents that are found at various concentrations in PFA include arsenic, cadmium, chromium, cobalt, copper, lead, lithium, mercury, molybdenum, selenium, thallium, silica, boron and uranium. Even though reusing PFA minimises health effects in humans, health problems can still occur when coal ash is recycled. Specifically, workers drilling or cutting encapsulated coal ash increase their risk of inhaling coal ash dust. In addition, when unencapsulated coal ash is scattered on snowy streets in the winter, the loose ash can come in contact with ditches on the side of the road. As a result, the toxins from coal ash can ‘leach’ into the water streams polluting aboveground waterways and eventually contaminating underground water supplies (drinking water). Therefore, both forms of recycled coal ash (encapsulated and unencapsulated) can cause serious health issues in humans.
· Such a dramatic increase in vehicles raising the likelihood of road accidents, with the fact that said vehicles are HGVs increasing the likelihood that an accident would be fatal: the first route option (Whitley via Cobcroft Lane) uses a road that people have already deemed incredibly dangerous, and a primary school sits on this road, so if the plan is approved, the danger to the school’s children will be even greater than it was before; also, in regards to the first route option, the road surface is poor, the road is barely wide enough to allow two vehicles of the size proposed to pass each other, there is a blind bend towards Whitley and there are no footpaths to allow pedestrians to take refuge from fast moving vehicles (the road is subject to the national speed limit along the majority of the route); in regard to the potential third option (Plasmor Limited via left on Cobcroft Lane, before turning right along Northfield Lane into Knottingley), as well as being windy and narrow in general, Northfield Lane narrows significantly at the entrance to Knottingley, creating a road traffic hazard were large vehicles to use this route.
· The air pollution caused by the HGVs resulting in pollution related illness and death.
· The light pollution created by the site and vehicles operating at the times proposed and the effects this will have on the health of the area’s residents.
· Such a dramatic increase in vehicles will limit - if not eliminate - the access of walkers and cyclists, which will have negative effects on both the physical and mental health of residents.
· The dramatic increase in vehicles on the roads, slowing down emergency services in a rural area where response times are already relatively slow - this in combination with either of the two circumstances above could prove fatal.
The environmental concerns:
· The carbon footprint of such a high number of vehicles operating for such an extended period of time, especially when those vehicles are as polluting as HGVs.
· The air pollution of such a high number of vehicles operating for such an extended period of time, especially when those vehicles are as polluting as HGVs.
· The effects that the air pollution will have on the health of the area’s flora and fauna.
· The inhalation of PFA particles could result in illness and death in of flora and fauna.
· The light pollution created by the site and vehicles operating at the times proposed, and the effects this will have on the health of the area’s flora and fauna.
· Such a dramatic increase in vehicles will limit - if not eliminate - the access of walkers and cyclists, which will have negative effect on the environment, as where people could have walked or cycled somewhere, they will be forced to use their cars.
· The disturbance to wildlife that the physical presence of both the vehicles and the workers will cause.
· The noise and vibrations generated by the stream of HGVs disturbing the animals of the area.
· Long-term negative effects on the Green Belt.
· The hills created by the PFA have become a natural part of the landscape, and due the limited activity on the site, the flora and fauna have been allowed to flourish. As such, the removal of these hills will destroy what has essentially become a rewilded area.
Animals in the area include: deer; bats; owls; foxes; badgers; rabbits; donkeys and goats (from a sanctuary that is quite literally next door to the site); sheep (owned by a local farmer that graze, again, next door to the site); horses (owned by a local stable).
The quality of life/miscellaneous concerns:
· The destruction of scenery by the constant stream of HGVs and/or the fact that the hills - which have become an integral part of the landscape - are being removed.
· The destruction of the peace and quiet via noise pollution, and the effects this will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· The effects that light pollution will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· Residents already feel the effects of activity on the site, both noise related and visual, but at least these are limited mainly to weekday daytimes during summer, when the hours of daylight cover the full working period. Were the application granted as submitted, those impacts would extend to weekends, when parishioners are most likely to be using the gardens and other outside space that they value so highly and also into the hours of darkness, which would require floodlighting to facilitate operations and therefore add light pollution to the list of impacts felt by residents.
· The elimination of access for both walkers and cyclists on roads that are frequented by both groups, and the effects this will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· Road congestion (affecting both the access of residents and anyone who is passing through the area), and the effects this will have on the quality of life of the residents.
· The increase in vehicles on the area’s roads resulting in resident’s vehicles consistently needing cleaning – this is already an issue due to the HGVs working at Gale Common and the quarry at Darrington.
· Permission for development of the site to dispose of PFA from local coal fired power stations was originally granted in 1963, with a maximum timeframe for completion of disposal activities and subsequent full restoration of the site to a landscape in keeping with the natural surroundings. The planning application reneges on this promise, which creates a precedent of moving the goal posts, leaving residents to wonder if in the future something else will be forced upon them again.
· The amalgamation of environmental, health, and other concerns lowering the value of people’s homes.
Even if the removal of the PFA was non-negotiable, there are other more environmentally friendly ways it could be transported – there is access to railway and waterway, and the pipeline used to channel the PFA in, could be utilised to remove it again.
The meeting at which the application’s outcome will be decided will take place on Thursday, 30th July.
The plans can be viewed at https://onlineplanningregister.northyorks.gov.uk/register/PlanAppSrch.aspx using the planning application reference number NY/2019/0091/ENV.
Objections can be emailed to the planning control department at planning.control@northyorks.gov.uk (if you wish, you can also copy in Selby and Ainsty’s MP Nigel Adams at nigel.adams.mp@parliament.uk) - you must cite the planning application reference number NY/2019/0091/ENV in your email.
The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 27 August 2019