Actualización de la peticiónCampaign for a third option in any future Scottish referendum

A New Times Poll Shows Support for Third Option

Red Paper Collective
May 11, 2021

The campaign for a third option in a future independence referendum has been boosted by a new poll suggesting that a “devo max” deal would win popular support.

Supporters of a multi-option ballot have said that two questions should be put to voters, the first asking if they want constitutional change and the second asking what type of change they would prefer.

YouGov replicated this for The Times last week and found that 52 per cent of people said they would want to change the powers of self-government in Scotland, with 26 per cent opposed, 18 per cent unsure and 4 per cent not voting.

Asked which type of change they would prefer, 42 per cent of all respondents said increased powers for the Scottish parliament, 36 per cent said independence, 14 per cent did not know and 9 per cent said that they would not vote.

James Mitchell, a professor of public policy at Edinburgh University, said a “substantial body of people are currently being ignored in debate on Scotland’s constitutional status” and that a third option on the ballot paper would help to alleviate that.

“This poll provides a more nuanced picture of public opinion and should help enrich debate,” Mitchell said. “What is abundantly clear is that there is a strong appetite for change but that the current binary choice forces many people to choose an option they might not really want.”

When the three options were put to voters as one question by YouGov in March, a devo max proposal was the least popular of the three choices. The same survey found that 51 per cent of people would prefer a two-way referendum.

Neil Findlay, a former Labour MSP who has campaigned for any future referendum to have three questions, said the new poll “shows the Scottish people would look very favourably on a third option of devo max”. He added: “There now needs to be a thorough and comprehensive piece of work done setting out what this means in practical terms.”

Alex Salmond wanted a “full devolution” option on the 2014 ballot but that was rejected by David Cameron as prime minister. Senior SNP and Scottish government strategists now believe that the concept of greater devolved powers is too ill defined and that a truly federal UK would need significant constitutional changes in England. They are therefore unwilling to countenance a third option.

Gordon Brown, the former Labour prime minister, said yesterday that he was confident there would be two options: UK-wide reform or independence.