Eve of Poll Disappointment in Scottish Elections


However much progressives might have wanted the Scottish election campaign in 2021 to have been about the broken nature of the British state and how it underpins inequality in wealth and power, it has not. Instead, we have had a surrogate binary referendum on a choice that is no choice. We have been a choice between a neo liberal British elite using antiquated and undemocratic state machinery to secure continued dominance through centralised state power and in Scotland in the shape of the SNP, a wannabe elite, comprador capitalists, every bit as committed to neo-liberal norms. They want to ensure that Scotland will remain ensnared by the neo-liberal rules of EU and global capital, rather than developing Scotland’s own industrial capacity.
If it seems harsh to compare the SNP economic project to the elevation of a small local elite in developing countries acting mainly in the interests of foreign capitalists, in return for a cut of the profits, then consider the realities of their political time in power.
For example, how much Scottish steel is in the new Forth Bridge? It cost £1.5 billion to build and the steel in that was £ 790 million worth. The answer is none. Instead, we imported it from China, Poland and Spain. And why was this? Partly at least because EU directives, the same EU the SNP is committed to re-join, has rules on public contracting designed to ensure that global capital and not local economic development determine access to contracts. Incidentally, many of the EU rules have now been carried over into British law through the Boris Johnston’s Internal Market Act because he and the SNP share a commitment to the dominance of the free market.
Again, if you think that is unfair and that, as they often plead, that given the powers of independence the SNP would change the face of Scotland then ask this: what have they done to expose and challenge the ownership of public services in Scotland? Who owns ‘Scottish’ Power, for example? Iberdrola, a Spanish-registered firm does. Who owns Iberdrola? The largest shareholders are the Emir of Qatar and BlackRock, the world’s biggest investment company. In other words, Scottish Power is controlled by external investors primarily interested in maximising profits - rather than serving the needs of consumers in Scotland and of our productive economy.
Of course, it is not just energy, virtually all public services including transport, telecommunications, and postal deliveries, are currently in private hands. Dominant shareholders are investment companies driven to maximise profits by the demands of their investors. Their indifference to British and Scottish workers is only too plain to see in how they treat them with British Gas using fire and re-hire tactics and and British Telecom using compulsory redundancies right in the middle of the misery of the Covid pandemic.
That is why in Scotland we should have been discussing how we can transform the British state to make sure power goes back in the hands of the people. That means that we must have a third option in any future referendum that gives the option of decentralising power to the people, not just changing an old elite for a new one with the same global investors pulling the strings.
Vince Mills is joint secretary of Radical Options for Scotland and Europe