

Request for Action: Combatting Discrimination and Bias at NeurIPS 2024
The Issue
ACSIC Letter to Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS) Board, 2024 Organizing Committee, and NeurIPS Community
Dear NeurIPS Board 2024, 2024 Organizing Committee, and NeurIPS Community,
We are writing to express serious concerns regarding statements made by Dr. Rosalind Picard from the MIT Media Lab during her keynote talk at the 38th NeurIPS annual conference [1]. As stated in the statement by the NeurIPS Board and 2024 Organizing Committee, Dr. Picard’s remarks were in “direct violation of [the NeurIPS] Code of Conduct”, “needlessly singled out Chinese scholars and perpetuated harmful stereotypes”. [2] We thank the Board and Organizing Committee for acknowledging how this incident undermines the core values of diversity, inclusion, and respect within the NeurIPS community. We write to reaffirm our shared commitment in the principles and values outlined in the NeurIPS Code of Conduct, to provide further context of how these remarks fail to foster an inclusive environment, and to help ensure that we prevent incidents like this from happening again in the future.
During the 2024 NeurIPS Conference, Dr. Picard singled out Chinese scholars when discussing academic dishonesty. When an attendee expressed concerns about this during Q&A, Dr. Picard’s response further raised concerns that her words feed into harmful and unfounded stereotypes and racial bias against scholars of Chinese origin. This is in complete contradiction of the focus of this talk — ethics and integrity, and undermines the values of the NeurIPS community.
NeurIPS has a long and respected history of fostering a community that is rich in diversity and collaboration. Researchers, students, and professionals of Chinese origin, among many others, made valuable contributions to the community and society. We must work towards creating an environment that fosters an inclusive environment and, as mentioned in the NeurIPS statement, “strive to uphold the highest standards of mutual respect across our diverse community”. [2] This is all the more crucial as the Asian American community has experienced years of anti-Asian hate with 1 in 2 Asian American feeling unsafe in the U.S., and nearly 80% of Asian Americans not feeling that they belong and are accepted, particularly the younger generation [3]. While we are disappointed with this incident at the conference, particularly for our young students, we also see this as an opportunity for reflection and recommitment to our values.
In furtherance of our shared values and principles, we request the following recommendations to the NeurIPS Board :
- Publicly criticize the biased and offensive comments made by Dr. Picard, acknowledging the harm caused to broader Chinese Students and Scholars communities.
- Take proactive steps in creating a welcoming environment for Chinese American and immigrant scholars and the broader NeurIPS community, including working with professors and students who have been harmed.
- Provide transparency from the Board regarding the actions planned to take in response to this incident.
- Develop and implement concrete measures to prevent similar incidents in the future. This could include but is not limited to training for both explicit and implicit racial bias, better communication of the NeurIPS Code of Conduct, and establishing clear guidelines and vetting of presentations for future conferences.
We believe these steps are essential for NeurIPS to demonstrate its commitment to the values of inclusion and respect. We believe that NeurIPS can rebuild trust and remain a welcoming platform for all members. We hope that this is helpful, and look forward to a response from the Board.
Thank you for your attention to this critical matter, and we hope we can work together in fostering a more inclusive environment in the future.
Sincerely,
Association of Chinese Scholars in Computing (ACSIC)
Tsinghua Alumni Academia Club of North America
Canadian Association of Chinese Professors (CACP)
Xidian University Alumni Association of America
USTC Initiative Foundation (USTCIF)
[1] https://x.com/meigustas/status/1867994351584055531
[2] https://neurips.cc/Conferences/2024/StatementOnInclusivity
[3] https://www.taaf.org/news/staatus-index-23-press-release
2,444
The Issue
ACSIC Letter to Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS) Board, 2024 Organizing Committee, and NeurIPS Community
Dear NeurIPS Board 2024, 2024 Organizing Committee, and NeurIPS Community,
We are writing to express serious concerns regarding statements made by Dr. Rosalind Picard from the MIT Media Lab during her keynote talk at the 38th NeurIPS annual conference [1]. As stated in the statement by the NeurIPS Board and 2024 Organizing Committee, Dr. Picard’s remarks were in “direct violation of [the NeurIPS] Code of Conduct”, “needlessly singled out Chinese scholars and perpetuated harmful stereotypes”. [2] We thank the Board and Organizing Committee for acknowledging how this incident undermines the core values of diversity, inclusion, and respect within the NeurIPS community. We write to reaffirm our shared commitment in the principles and values outlined in the NeurIPS Code of Conduct, to provide further context of how these remarks fail to foster an inclusive environment, and to help ensure that we prevent incidents like this from happening again in the future.
During the 2024 NeurIPS Conference, Dr. Picard singled out Chinese scholars when discussing academic dishonesty. When an attendee expressed concerns about this during Q&A, Dr. Picard’s response further raised concerns that her words feed into harmful and unfounded stereotypes and racial bias against scholars of Chinese origin. This is in complete contradiction of the focus of this talk — ethics and integrity, and undermines the values of the NeurIPS community.
NeurIPS has a long and respected history of fostering a community that is rich in diversity and collaboration. Researchers, students, and professionals of Chinese origin, among many others, made valuable contributions to the community and society. We must work towards creating an environment that fosters an inclusive environment and, as mentioned in the NeurIPS statement, “strive to uphold the highest standards of mutual respect across our diverse community”. [2] This is all the more crucial as the Asian American community has experienced years of anti-Asian hate with 1 in 2 Asian American feeling unsafe in the U.S., and nearly 80% of Asian Americans not feeling that they belong and are accepted, particularly the younger generation [3]. While we are disappointed with this incident at the conference, particularly for our young students, we also see this as an opportunity for reflection and recommitment to our values.
In furtherance of our shared values and principles, we request the following recommendations to the NeurIPS Board :
- Publicly criticize the biased and offensive comments made by Dr. Picard, acknowledging the harm caused to broader Chinese Students and Scholars communities.
- Take proactive steps in creating a welcoming environment for Chinese American and immigrant scholars and the broader NeurIPS community, including working with professors and students who have been harmed.
- Provide transparency from the Board regarding the actions planned to take in response to this incident.
- Develop and implement concrete measures to prevent similar incidents in the future. This could include but is not limited to training for both explicit and implicit racial bias, better communication of the NeurIPS Code of Conduct, and establishing clear guidelines and vetting of presentations for future conferences.
We believe these steps are essential for NeurIPS to demonstrate its commitment to the values of inclusion and respect. We believe that NeurIPS can rebuild trust and remain a welcoming platform for all members. We hope that this is helpful, and look forward to a response from the Board.
Thank you for your attention to this critical matter, and we hope we can work together in fostering a more inclusive environment in the future.
Sincerely,
Association of Chinese Scholars in Computing (ACSIC)
Tsinghua Alumni Academia Club of North America
Canadian Association of Chinese Professors (CACP)
Xidian University Alumni Association of America
USTC Initiative Foundation (USTCIF)
[1] https://x.com/meigustas/status/1867994351584055531
[2] https://neurips.cc/Conferences/2024/StatementOnInclusivity
[3] https://www.taaf.org/news/staatus-index-23-press-release
The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on December 16, 2024
