Remove Kelli Underwood from AFL commentary team

Recent signers:
Sharon Mills and 14 others have signed recently.

The issue

For years, I've been passionate about AFL and tuning into various games with enthusiasm. As a long-time fan, the commentary adds so much to the experience. Unfortunately, Kelli Underwood's commentary often detracts from the enjoyment due to her frequent mistakes and lack of depth in understanding the sport. Despite her years in the role, these errors persist, causing frustration among viewers like myself.

A commentator's job is not just to provide a play-by-play but to enrich the viewer's understanding and love for the game. Audiences rely on commentators to offer insightful analysis, correctly interpret the intricacies of plays, and to captivate us with their narrative skills. Kelli often struggles in these areas, which significantly impacts the overall quality and professionalism of AFL broadcasts.

It's important to point out that criticism here is aimed at the performance, not the person. It's about ensuring that AFL commentary maintains the high standards expected by committed fans and escalates the game's broadcasting quality. Individuals filling these roles should be evaluated and selected based on their evident capability to enhance viewers' experience.

We believe it's time for the AFL and broadcasters to reconsider Kelli Underwood's position on the commentary team. Bringing in a commentator with a profound understanding of the game and the ability to engage audiences effectively would not only improve broadcasts but also honor the passion of AFL fans who deserve the best experience.

Sign this petition to urge the AFL to review and act towards enhancing the quality of AFL commentary for the benefit of all fans.

16

Recent signers:
Sharon Mills and 14 others have signed recently.

The issue

For years, I've been passionate about AFL and tuning into various games with enthusiasm. As a long-time fan, the commentary adds so much to the experience. Unfortunately, Kelli Underwood's commentary often detracts from the enjoyment due to her frequent mistakes and lack of depth in understanding the sport. Despite her years in the role, these errors persist, causing frustration among viewers like myself.

A commentator's job is not just to provide a play-by-play but to enrich the viewer's understanding and love for the game. Audiences rely on commentators to offer insightful analysis, correctly interpret the intricacies of plays, and to captivate us with their narrative skills. Kelli often struggles in these areas, which significantly impacts the overall quality and professionalism of AFL broadcasts.

It's important to point out that criticism here is aimed at the performance, not the person. It's about ensuring that AFL commentary maintains the high standards expected by committed fans and escalates the game's broadcasting quality. Individuals filling these roles should be evaluated and selected based on their evident capability to enhance viewers' experience.

We believe it's time for the AFL and broadcasters to reconsider Kelli Underwood's position on the commentary team. Bringing in a commentator with a profound understanding of the game and the ability to engage audiences effectively would not only improve broadcasts but also honor the passion of AFL fans who deserve the best experience.

Sign this petition to urge the AFL to review and act towards enhancing the quality of AFL commentary for the benefit of all fans.

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on 23 June 2025