

Release The Schumacher Cut Of Batman Forever
The Issue
It’s been over 30 years since Batman Forever was first released on June 16, 1995. It has been such a fan favorite, when fans of the movie have grown up watching it either on VHS, Laserdisc, DVD, Blu-ray, 4K and digital. We too are fans of the movie, but as we grew older, we knew something off while watching it. It’s not to say the theatrical version is bad; it’s a great movie but it is a flawed film, and we believe that there is another version of Batman Forever that can improve the overall experience.
The History Behind It

In the beginning, after director Tim Burton’s Batman movie became a phenomenon during its release in the summer of 1989, Warner Bros granted him creative freedom to make the sequel Batman Returns and was allowed to do whatever he wanted to do with it. When it made its debut on June 19, 1992, it received major backlash from parents who complained about the film being too dark and too sexual for children, especially the Penguin for giving them nightmares. McDonald’s also received similar complaints for doing a Happy Meal tie-in, until they cancelled it as the film wasn’t made for children. So Warner Bros decided to reinvent the franchise by having Tim Burton stepping down as director but remaining as producer and giving Joel Schumacher the director’s chair for handling the reigns of the franchise. Schumacher was known as a fashion designer and then went to become a director who has directed a number of films before becoming the director of Batman Forever and Batman and Robin as he is known for directing St. Elmo’s Fire, The Lost Boys, Flatliners, Falling Down and directing two films based on the works of John Grisham such as The Client and A Time To Kill. He changed the look of the movie to make it brighter, poppier and colorful, and he cast his own actor to portray Batman, Val Kilmer after Michael Keaton dropped out of reprising his role as Schumacher casted Kilmer as he was impressed by his performance in Tombstone. After casting his own Batman, Schumacher would cast his actors to play Two-Face and The Riddler (Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey), and cast Chris O’Donnell as Robin while casting Nicole Kidman as Dr. Chase Meridian. Casting was completed and the production has begun filming.
The WorkPrint

After production wrapped and before any reshoots or additional photography were made, the film’s WorkPrint was first assembled around November of 1994 and was previewed by Warner Bros. Test audiences were not impressed as they were never interested in a character-driven movie as it was too dark and too complex for a summer blockbuster. So the film had to be changed from being a darker and psychologically complex character-driven movie into a film that is suitable for a family-friendly audience.
The Original Opening

The film originally opens at Arkham Asylum during a thunderstorm as Dr. Burton visits Two-Face in his cell before learning that he has escaped and leaves a message on the wall that reads “THE BAT MUST DIE!” That sets up for being darker than the film’s theatrical opening.

Then we are introduce to Bruce Wayne as he watches the news on Two-Faces escape, then we see him talking to his executives before paying a visit at Wayne Tech where we get our first introduction of Edward Nygma.

After meeting Nygma, he goes to his office and enters into a capsule that transports him to the BatCave and then he suits up as Batman as it plays out in the theatrical version. Later, he has a confrontation with Two-Face in the helicopter as Two-Face tells him that he is a killer. Two-Face escapes, and Batman jumps out of the helicopter and receives flashes from his past about the death of his parents while we hear Two-Face’s voice “You’re a killer too!” It sets up the beginning of Batman’s guilt, and it becomes the main focus of the film that wasn’t explored much in the theatrical version.
Bruce Wayne’s Character Arc

We find Val Kilmer’s performance in the movie very underrated as he was the first actor to dive deeper into the psychological aspects of Bruce Wayne and Batman. He got pushed aside by Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey taking center stage, as his scenes were deleted in the theatrical version of the film.

The most important deleted scenes that needs to be restored is where Bruce Wayne gets shot in the head, while Chase Meridian gets captured by Two-Face and Riddler, Bruce wakes up and has amnesia that he has no memory that he’s Batman. Alfred takes Bruce to the BatCave, which is now in ruins, and leads him to the secret passage of the cave where he first fell into the cave as a child. Bruce explores it, and finds his father’s red diary and learns the truth that he is not responsible for the death of his parents. The Giant Bat appears as Bruce stands up to confront his fears, and now realizes why he became Batman in the first place. He and the Bat are in sync as Bruce spreads his arms and comes out of the cave and tells Alfred that he is Batman. This is the missing key element of the movie, and it must be restored.
Dick Grayson’s Original Training

In the theatrical version of the film, everyone knows the infamous Laundry Fu scene, where Dick trains himself by using socks and other clothing. In the original version, Bruce sees Dick training by hitting a picture of Two-Face on a wooden martial arts training tree in the gym as Bruce tries to reason with him about killing Two-Face. Dick rejects him and tells him that he has nothing to teach him. Bruce kicks it with his powerful strength, Dick turns and sees what Bruce has done, and Bruce tells him “Don’t be too sure.” Dick leaves the gym.

One scene that features Dick Grayson after Alfred tells him that one day Robin will fly again. He leaves him alone in his bedroom, Dick pulls out a newspaper as he looks at a picture of Two-Face and he begins to crumble the newspaper which sets up his revenge to kill him on the death of his parents.

Another scene deleted in the film is where Batman saves Dick from the Neon Gang as he lets out his emotions and blames him for not saving his family. Batman says “If Bruce Wayne could’ve given his life for your family, he would have.” Dick continues to hit him, and then he kneels down in tears as Batman consoles him if there’s anything he needs, he will.

The Origin Of Claw Island
After Riddler teams up with Two-Face, Nygma begins to build his own island with a crew doing construction work for him to make his plans come to fruition by sucking Gotham’s brainwaves. Not featured in the finished film, but it establishes his plans very well and we get to learn more about how Nygma got himself island for his lair.

Jim Carrey’s Dark Performance
Jim Carrey does an excellent job with his performance but there are some darker moments where he’s actually scary besides his usual Jim Carrey antics. One in particular is where Nygma kills his own boss as he returns to his workplace and takes down some pictures of Bruce Wayne and smashes one picture of him while Nygma says “You’re right, there are TOO MANY QUESTIONS, MR. WAYNE!” And then he goes to the security camera and says “Here’s a good one? Why hasn’t anybody, put you in your place?” Blocks the camera as the screen goes black. Another moment is where Nygma cuts his hair to look like Bruce Wayne, which shows his obsession with Bruce Wayne and being more like a stalker.

After invading Wayne Manor, Chase is tied up on a sofa as Riddler comes down with his jacket, while Chase tells him that Batman will come for her. Riddler replies he’s counting on it. Chase tells him “There’s a reason we only use a fraction of our brains. You’re cutting neural pathways faster than your consciousness can incorporate them. You’re frying your mind.” Riddler calls it a major buzz kill and injects a needle into her neck and says “Nap time, gorgeous” and then she passes out.

ADR
If anyone doesn’t know what ADR means, it’s Automated Dialogue Replacement where actors come in during post production to loop their dialogue for what they performed on set and to enhance the sound of their voice. In the finished film, Tommy Lee Jones’ performance was heavily dubbed by making more larger than life and of course trying to be another version of Jack Nicholson’s Joker besides trying to upstage Jim Carrey and see who can overact the other. In the original version, there’s no ADR as his performance despite being over the top is a bit more grounded in reality and a bit more serious than what we saw in the finished.

Chase Meridian
Nicole Kidman’s performance isn’t exactly how she was portrayed in the film. We know she plays out as a woman who wants to sleep with Batman, but in the original version of the movie as well as the shooting script by Akiva Goldsman and the Batchlers (Janet Scott and Lee) she is supposed to be Bruce’s guide as she helps him to open up his past and reason with him that he is not guilty for the death of his parents.

The Original Ending
Unlike the theatrical version, where Batman and Robin are running towards the camera à la 60s Batman TV show. In the original script, it features Alfred taking Chase home while she sees the BatSignal in the sky and asks “Does it ever end, Alfred?” Alfred replies “No, Dr. Meridian. Not in this lifetime.” And we see Batman and Robin standing on top of the gargoyle watching over Gotham as they are teaming up as the Dynamic Duo. Also, as a homage to the ending of Batman 89.

Not Released In This Lifetime
Back in 2005, Joel Schumacher had expressed interest in releasing his Director’s Cut of the film, but it was later scrapped and Warner Bros ended releasing 7 deleted scenes that featured on the 2 Disc Special Edition DVD and later releases. On June 22, 2020, Schumacher passed away due to his battle with cancer which was unfortunate and sad to us as he never got a chance of recutting Batman Forever. After his passing, Warner Bros almost released it as a tribute to Schumacher until David Zaslav got a hold of the studio known as Warner Bros. Discovery. Three years later, on June 7th, filmmaker Kevin Smith has obtained a copy of the Workprint and did a review alongside with filmmaker Joe Black who acquired it and give it to Smith as he calls it the superior version of the film. On July 1st, he secretly screened it at Smodcastle Cinemas and a number of fans got to watch it and it has earned positive reviews.
One of the fans who saw the Workprint was Justin Esquivel (Epic Film Guys/The Burton Batcave) and LoySauce and they’ve had a done a breakdown and a review on their experience on seeing the Workprint. Last year, Cinefile Video Store announced another screening was being held on May 29th, which unfortunately got cancelled as Warner Bros had filed a cease and desist. Although it did get screened unannounced but in an unknown location.
A Time To Call
We call upon Mr. David Ellison of Skydance and Jeremy Latcham of DC Studios as both Paramount Pictures and Warner Bros have now been merged, and we want to see the Schumacher Cut of Batman Forever as it was originally intended by director Joel Schumacher and writer Akiva Goldsman and Janet Scott and Lee Batchler as Justin Esquivel from Epic Film Guys perfectly describes: The Schumacher Cut of Batman Forever presents a deeper, psychologically-complex character arc for Kilmer’s Bruce Wayne that is sorely missing from the OG cut. It’s a darker, more Batman centered film.


Akiva Goldsman is lobbying for the Schumacher Cut to get released and executive producer Michael Uslan knows the fandom has a stronger interest in seeing an alternative version of the film. The Schumacher Cut deserves to be properly restored and remastered in 4K Dolby Vision (No DNR or A I should be included), and the whole world deserves to see it in theaters and available on DVD, Blu Ray, 4K and digital (iTunes, HBO Max etc.) It needs to be seen. It’s not about restoring the SchumacherVerse, it’s about honoring the memory of Joel Schumacher and Val Kilmer (passed away on April 1, 2025) so we the fans can see it as a special tribute. We’ve been asking for this cut for a long time, and now it’s time to let the fans see this cut that no one has ever seen before.

Sign this petition and express your passion in a positive manner to ask Warner Bros, Paramount, Mr. Ellison of Skydance and Mr. Latcham of DC Studios to #ReleaseTheSchumacherCut of #BatmanForever. Thank you.

124
The Issue
It’s been over 30 years since Batman Forever was first released on June 16, 1995. It has been such a fan favorite, when fans of the movie have grown up watching it either on VHS, Laserdisc, DVD, Blu-ray, 4K and digital. We too are fans of the movie, but as we grew older, we knew something off while watching it. It’s not to say the theatrical version is bad; it’s a great movie but it is a flawed film, and we believe that there is another version of Batman Forever that can improve the overall experience.
The History Behind It

In the beginning, after director Tim Burton’s Batman movie became a phenomenon during its release in the summer of 1989, Warner Bros granted him creative freedom to make the sequel Batman Returns and was allowed to do whatever he wanted to do with it. When it made its debut on June 19, 1992, it received major backlash from parents who complained about the film being too dark and too sexual for children, especially the Penguin for giving them nightmares. McDonald’s also received similar complaints for doing a Happy Meal tie-in, until they cancelled it as the film wasn’t made for children. So Warner Bros decided to reinvent the franchise by having Tim Burton stepping down as director but remaining as producer and giving Joel Schumacher the director’s chair for handling the reigns of the franchise. Schumacher was known as a fashion designer and then went to become a director who has directed a number of films before becoming the director of Batman Forever and Batman and Robin as he is known for directing St. Elmo’s Fire, The Lost Boys, Flatliners, Falling Down and directing two films based on the works of John Grisham such as The Client and A Time To Kill. He changed the look of the movie to make it brighter, poppier and colorful, and he cast his own actor to portray Batman, Val Kilmer after Michael Keaton dropped out of reprising his role as Schumacher casted Kilmer as he was impressed by his performance in Tombstone. After casting his own Batman, Schumacher would cast his actors to play Two-Face and The Riddler (Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey), and cast Chris O’Donnell as Robin while casting Nicole Kidman as Dr. Chase Meridian. Casting was completed and the production has begun filming.
The WorkPrint

After production wrapped and before any reshoots or additional photography were made, the film’s WorkPrint was first assembled around November of 1994 and was previewed by Warner Bros. Test audiences were not impressed as they were never interested in a character-driven movie as it was too dark and too complex for a summer blockbuster. So the film had to be changed from being a darker and psychologically complex character-driven movie into a film that is suitable for a family-friendly audience.
The Original Opening

The film originally opens at Arkham Asylum during a thunderstorm as Dr. Burton visits Two-Face in his cell before learning that he has escaped and leaves a message on the wall that reads “THE BAT MUST DIE!” That sets up for being darker than the film’s theatrical opening.

Then we are introduce to Bruce Wayne as he watches the news on Two-Faces escape, then we see him talking to his executives before paying a visit at Wayne Tech where we get our first introduction of Edward Nygma.

After meeting Nygma, he goes to his office and enters into a capsule that transports him to the BatCave and then he suits up as Batman as it plays out in the theatrical version. Later, he has a confrontation with Two-Face in the helicopter as Two-Face tells him that he is a killer. Two-Face escapes, and Batman jumps out of the helicopter and receives flashes from his past about the death of his parents while we hear Two-Face’s voice “You’re a killer too!” It sets up the beginning of Batman’s guilt, and it becomes the main focus of the film that wasn’t explored much in the theatrical version.
Bruce Wayne’s Character Arc

We find Val Kilmer’s performance in the movie very underrated as he was the first actor to dive deeper into the psychological aspects of Bruce Wayne and Batman. He got pushed aside by Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey taking center stage, as his scenes were deleted in the theatrical version of the film.

The most important deleted scenes that needs to be restored is where Bruce Wayne gets shot in the head, while Chase Meridian gets captured by Two-Face and Riddler, Bruce wakes up and has amnesia that he has no memory that he’s Batman. Alfred takes Bruce to the BatCave, which is now in ruins, and leads him to the secret passage of the cave where he first fell into the cave as a child. Bruce explores it, and finds his father’s red diary and learns the truth that he is not responsible for the death of his parents. The Giant Bat appears as Bruce stands up to confront his fears, and now realizes why he became Batman in the first place. He and the Bat are in sync as Bruce spreads his arms and comes out of the cave and tells Alfred that he is Batman. This is the missing key element of the movie, and it must be restored.
Dick Grayson’s Original Training

In the theatrical version of the film, everyone knows the infamous Laundry Fu scene, where Dick trains himself by using socks and other clothing. In the original version, Bruce sees Dick training by hitting a picture of Two-Face on a wooden martial arts training tree in the gym as Bruce tries to reason with him about killing Two-Face. Dick rejects him and tells him that he has nothing to teach him. Bruce kicks it with his powerful strength, Dick turns and sees what Bruce has done, and Bruce tells him “Don’t be too sure.” Dick leaves the gym.

One scene that features Dick Grayson after Alfred tells him that one day Robin will fly again. He leaves him alone in his bedroom, Dick pulls out a newspaper as he looks at a picture of Two-Face and he begins to crumble the newspaper which sets up his revenge to kill him on the death of his parents.

Another scene deleted in the film is where Batman saves Dick from the Neon Gang as he lets out his emotions and blames him for not saving his family. Batman says “If Bruce Wayne could’ve given his life for your family, he would have.” Dick continues to hit him, and then he kneels down in tears as Batman consoles him if there’s anything he needs, he will.

The Origin Of Claw Island
After Riddler teams up with Two-Face, Nygma begins to build his own island with a crew doing construction work for him to make his plans come to fruition by sucking Gotham’s brainwaves. Not featured in the finished film, but it establishes his plans very well and we get to learn more about how Nygma got himself island for his lair.

Jim Carrey’s Dark Performance
Jim Carrey does an excellent job with his performance but there are some darker moments where he’s actually scary besides his usual Jim Carrey antics. One in particular is where Nygma kills his own boss as he returns to his workplace and takes down some pictures of Bruce Wayne and smashes one picture of him while Nygma says “You’re right, there are TOO MANY QUESTIONS, MR. WAYNE!” And then he goes to the security camera and says “Here’s a good one? Why hasn’t anybody, put you in your place?” Blocks the camera as the screen goes black. Another moment is where Nygma cuts his hair to look like Bruce Wayne, which shows his obsession with Bruce Wayne and being more like a stalker.

After invading Wayne Manor, Chase is tied up on a sofa as Riddler comes down with his jacket, while Chase tells him that Batman will come for her. Riddler replies he’s counting on it. Chase tells him “There’s a reason we only use a fraction of our brains. You’re cutting neural pathways faster than your consciousness can incorporate them. You’re frying your mind.” Riddler calls it a major buzz kill and injects a needle into her neck and says “Nap time, gorgeous” and then she passes out.

ADR
If anyone doesn’t know what ADR means, it’s Automated Dialogue Replacement where actors come in during post production to loop their dialogue for what they performed on set and to enhance the sound of their voice. In the finished film, Tommy Lee Jones’ performance was heavily dubbed by making more larger than life and of course trying to be another version of Jack Nicholson’s Joker besides trying to upstage Jim Carrey and see who can overact the other. In the original version, there’s no ADR as his performance despite being over the top is a bit more grounded in reality and a bit more serious than what we saw in the finished.

Chase Meridian
Nicole Kidman’s performance isn’t exactly how she was portrayed in the film. We know she plays out as a woman who wants to sleep with Batman, but in the original version of the movie as well as the shooting script by Akiva Goldsman and the Batchlers (Janet Scott and Lee) she is supposed to be Bruce’s guide as she helps him to open up his past and reason with him that he is not guilty for the death of his parents.

The Original Ending
Unlike the theatrical version, where Batman and Robin are running towards the camera à la 60s Batman TV show. In the original script, it features Alfred taking Chase home while she sees the BatSignal in the sky and asks “Does it ever end, Alfred?” Alfred replies “No, Dr. Meridian. Not in this lifetime.” And we see Batman and Robin standing on top of the gargoyle watching over Gotham as they are teaming up as the Dynamic Duo. Also, as a homage to the ending of Batman 89.

Not Released In This Lifetime
Back in 2005, Joel Schumacher had expressed interest in releasing his Director’s Cut of the film, but it was later scrapped and Warner Bros ended releasing 7 deleted scenes that featured on the 2 Disc Special Edition DVD and later releases. On June 22, 2020, Schumacher passed away due to his battle with cancer which was unfortunate and sad to us as he never got a chance of recutting Batman Forever. After his passing, Warner Bros almost released it as a tribute to Schumacher until David Zaslav got a hold of the studio known as Warner Bros. Discovery. Three years later, on June 7th, filmmaker Kevin Smith has obtained a copy of the Workprint and did a review alongside with filmmaker Joe Black who acquired it and give it to Smith as he calls it the superior version of the film. On July 1st, he secretly screened it at Smodcastle Cinemas and a number of fans got to watch it and it has earned positive reviews.
One of the fans who saw the Workprint was Justin Esquivel (Epic Film Guys/The Burton Batcave) and LoySauce and they’ve had a done a breakdown and a review on their experience on seeing the Workprint. Last year, Cinefile Video Store announced another screening was being held on May 29th, which unfortunately got cancelled as Warner Bros had filed a cease and desist. Although it did get screened unannounced but in an unknown location.
A Time To Call
We call upon Mr. David Ellison of Skydance and Jeremy Latcham of DC Studios as both Paramount Pictures and Warner Bros have now been merged, and we want to see the Schumacher Cut of Batman Forever as it was originally intended by director Joel Schumacher and writer Akiva Goldsman and Janet Scott and Lee Batchler as Justin Esquivel from Epic Film Guys perfectly describes: The Schumacher Cut of Batman Forever presents a deeper, psychologically-complex character arc for Kilmer’s Bruce Wayne that is sorely missing from the OG cut. It’s a darker, more Batman centered film.


Akiva Goldsman is lobbying for the Schumacher Cut to get released and executive producer Michael Uslan knows the fandom has a stronger interest in seeing an alternative version of the film. The Schumacher Cut deserves to be properly restored and remastered in 4K Dolby Vision (No DNR or A I should be included), and the whole world deserves to see it in theaters and available on DVD, Blu Ray, 4K and digital (iTunes, HBO Max etc.) It needs to be seen. It’s not about restoring the SchumacherVerse, it’s about honoring the memory of Joel Schumacher and Val Kilmer (passed away on April 1, 2025) so we the fans can see it as a special tribute. We’ve been asking for this cut for a long time, and now it’s time to let the fans see this cut that no one has ever seen before.

Sign this petition and express your passion in a positive manner to ask Warner Bros, Paramount, Mr. Ellison of Skydance and Mr. Latcham of DC Studios to #ReleaseTheSchumacherCut of #BatmanForever. Thank you.

Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 18, 2026
