The Phoenix VA Police Has Two Bosses and "One" Real One | The Puppet Master

DATELINE | THE REAL BOSS: The org chart at the Phoenix VA Police lists a Chief and a Deputy Chief of Police. One position is missing: “The Underboss” (and it’s not the new Deputy Chief). That is the person who really runs the department — the one with a sustained Title VII racial discrimination finding and a sustained sexual-nature misconduct finding — not the Chief of Police.
Even Tony Soprano knew better than to sit in the boss’s chair. Too much visual attention. He stayed the underboss and still ran the family. This compromised official appears to have done the same. The strings are short, tight, and still in his hands — badge and all.
THE PUPPET MASTER OF THE CARL T. HAYDEN VA MEDICAL CENTER
Forget the official chart. If you want to know who still shapes hiring, promotions, and who gets labeled a problem, look at the (now) Law Enforcement Specialist — Joshua Fister — a former supervisor who spent nearly two decades learning everyone in a position of power at the Phoenix VA Hospital to leverage protection, and who still participates in screening applicants and potential new officers.
Charm, Friends, and the Merit System: Protection for a Substantiated Racial and Sexual Harasser
Some people survive a list of accusations because they’re popular, charming, and already inside the building. Bill Clinton had a list. He kept the office — but he was voted in by the people. Fister has substantiated findings of Racial discrimination and Sexual harassment (a two-for-one combo piece meal). He kept the badge. He was never voted in — just protected by friends and the government merit system.
Welcome to the Phoenix VA Police Department, where the chain of command is decorative, the findings are treated as optional, and the real power still runs through the guy who violated the Civil Rights Act of 1964 by discriminating against a Black subordinate.
THE RECEIPTS: WHAT THE AGENCY ACTUALLY FOUND
You already know the story. In case you forgot (or it's your first time learning of this):
- Title VII Racial Hostile Work Environment: He violated the Civil Rights Act of 1964 by creating a racially hostile work environment for a Black officer. See OEDCA Final Agency Decision 200P-644-2022-147530, October 13, 2023.
- Sexual Nature Misconduct: He engaged in conduct of a sexual nature in the workplace (HPP 6210, September 20, 2023). Associate Director Stacey Scherpf signed off on the finding while she still had oversight of the police department, before the OSP transition. See Harassment Prevention Program Case No. 6210 — involving inappropriate sexual nature conduct, including "Simulated Masturbation" in the workplace.
- Current Chiefs’ Awareness: The current Chief of Police and the Deputy Chief of Police are — allegedly — aware of the racial discrimination finding. Fister remains in the department with a gun, badge, and arrest authority.
- NOTE: We say “allegedly” because an August 22, 2025 recorded video (currently available in the department’s Microsoft Teams files) shows the Chief of Police Alan Barone discussing a federal discrimination lawsuit involving Fister that was based on the Final Agency Decision sustaining a finding of racial discrimination — with Fister’s friend and supervisor Richard Kennedy also logged on. The discussion framed that case as “Dismissed with Prejudice.”
- CONVENIENTLY LEFT OUT THE DISCUSSION: the Agency’s own substantiated finding of racial discrimination and the settlement that led to the dismissal. A dismissal with prejudice after settlement is standard procedure — it closes the case. It does not mean the underlying claims lacked factual support. Apparently those details weren’t worth mentioning to the new and older officers (the ones who knew the truth).
- NOTE: We say “allegedly” because an August 22, 2025 recorded video (currently available in the department’s Microsoft Teams files) shows the Chief of Police Alan Barone discussing a federal discrimination lawsuit involving Fister that was based on the Final Agency Decision sustaining a finding of racial discrimination — with Fister’s friend and supervisor Richard Kennedy also logged on. The discussion framed that case as “Dismissed with Prejudice.”
CLINTON HAD A LIST, BUT FISTER'S LIST LET HIM KEEP THE BADGE.
Public officials have their lists of scandals. Bill Clinton had one (Oh boy...did he have one). He kept the office — but he was voted in by the people. He never carried a gun and badge as a law enforcement officer. Even if he had wanted someone arrested, it still would have gone through a process. Fister still does. Popularity and charm beat the file in this department.
No Committee. No Vote. Just the Badge.
He kept the badge. He was never voted in — just protected by friends and the government merit system. Fister has statutory power of arrest. No committee. No vote.
Fister can take someone’s liberty on the spot.
- NOT EVEN OL’ “I DIDN’T INHALE” BILL HAD THIS TYPE OF POWER.
Just the badge his agency left on Fister after his employer sustained BOTH racial and sexual harassment findings.
Do you really want to shake the hands of somebody who has "Bill Clinton energy" that the agency already found pretended to spit into his hand and Simulate Masturbation in the workplace? Because that’s the exact same hand reaching out for a handshake with you.
THREE YEARS OF SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY AFTER THE FINDINGS
The 2023 findings of RACIAL DISCRIMINATION and SEXUAL HARASSMENT did not end his supervisory role (or, shocking enough, his law enforcement career). He kept it for nearly three years, including temporary Acting Chief of Police assignments in August 2025 and early 2026 — racking up EEO and harassment investigations. In late August 2026 the Supervisory Police Officer position he had held for over a decade was apparently eliminated, and he was moved into a non-supervisory position as a GS-11, Series 1801, Law Enforcement Specialist.
He remains HIGHLY INFLUENTIAL in the department with a gun, badge, and arrest authority — backed by years of personal loyalty and command-level deference from Kennedy. Appointing a substantiated harasser as Acting Chief of Police made the department a PERMANENT liability.
THE GATEKEEPER WHO STILL SCREENS APPLICANTS
He no longer holds the formal supervisory title. He still walks the same campus. According to sources familiar with department operations, he still participates in onboarding and screening prospective police officers — assisting with equipment, transporting candidates, joining them at the range, and weighing in on hiring discussions.
Upcoming Criminal Investigator (1811) Position Hiring Panel
In fact, according to reports received from inside the facility, Fister is slated to sit on an upcoming hiring panel (with a highly qualified Black applicant) for a Criminal Investigator (1811) position the week of November 23 — giving an official with sustained racial discrimination and sexual harassment findings a direct vote over who gets selected for federal investigative roles.
- We remember what happened the last time he sat on an 1811 interview for a Black officer.
Filtering Out the Ones Who Might Complain
His continued participation in the process raises questions about whether it creates an opportunity to identify officers who might later file an EEO complaint or a harassment claim — specifically against him.
Whodini Asked: Friends… How Many of Us Have Them?
When this power structure also runs through a close friend (Richard Kennedy) who is now a senior supervisor — who is also Fister’s supervisor — the ability to identify and filter out potential “problems” becomes structural.
It is difficult to call that arrangement proper. It is easier to call it what it is: a friend supervising a substantiated harasser who still has access and influence.
COWBOY HATS. HAWAIIAN SHIRTS. GUN OUT FOR EVERYONE TO SEE
The Phoenix VA Police Standards of Conduct (Chapter I, Section C) require officers to project a favorable image of law enforcement through appearance and competent performance of duty. VA Handbook 0730, Section 12 requires physical security specialists to wear business attire appropriate to their duties. Cowboy hats and boots do not qualify. Neither do Hawaiian shirts. Yet here we are — because Fister can wear his costumes because management lets him.
Are these violations (?):
- Failure to project a favorable image of law enforcement through appearance and competent performance of duty (Chapter I, Section C – Standards of Conduct).
- Physical security specialists are required to wear business attire appropriate to their duties (VA Handbook 0730, Section 12).
Dressing like John Wayne on Mondays, Magnum P.I. on Tuesdays While on Duty
This is the NEW and APPROVED standard under Reginald G. A. Neal’s OSP vision: a Law Enforcement Specialist with a sustained Title VII racial discrimination finding on his record, walking the campus in cowboy boots and a cowboy hat on some days, a Hawaiian shirt on others like Magnum, P.I., gun visible, federal arrest authority still in his pocket.
Reginald G.A. Neal, “Failure at the Front Gate: Examining VA Police and Security Deficiencies,” June 24, 2026:
- “We can enforce standards and discipline across all facilities.”
Apparently it’s Halloween at the Phoenix VA on a regular work day — and Fister’s doing it as a federal law enforcement officer. This is Assistant Secretary Reginald G.A. Neal’s Vision of OSP Excellence.
QUESTION OF THE DAY
Does current Police leadership intend to run the Phoenix VA Police Department — or are they fine sitting there while a guy the agency already found racially discriminated and simulated masturbation in the workplace runs the department for them, makes the decisions for them, and continues to carry them in his arms like children?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Concerned Citizens AZ Investigative Team — Tony Soprano never sat in the boss’s chair. He let Junior take the title, the heat, and the indictments while he ran the family from the back. The face of the organization took the fall. The guy who actually ran things kept the power. Sound familiar? Except someone here chose to sit in the Acting Chief of Police chair and put the light on himself.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DAYS WITHOUT REQUIRED POSTINGS
1,423 days (3 years, 10 months, and 28 days) without the mandatory (“shall”) statutorily required postings on the facility's website of COMPLAINTS, INVESTIGATIONS, AND DISCIPLINARY ACTIONS involving PVAHCS officers — regarding the Cleland-Dole Act (38 U.S.C. § 902(e)(1)(A)(iv))
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
READER NOTICE
Concerned Citizens Media encourages readers to independently verify the information contained in this publication, including through public records, official sources, or AI-assisted research tools. For additional information or clarification, readers are encouraged to contact appropriate Department of Veterans Affairs officials or their local VA facility directly.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DISCLAIMER
Any attempt to retaliate against current or former VA employees, officers, contractors, or witnesses for engaging in Protected Whistleblower or EEO Activity related to the matters discussed herein may constitute a violation of federal law, including 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)–(9), Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and applicable VA anti‑retaliation policies. Documentation, reporting, or public discussion of substantiated misconduct, harassment, discrimination, or policy violations is protected activity.