Petition to Review and Withdraw the Film Marketed as Ramayana

2

Let’s get to 5 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

Petition to Review and Withdraw the Film Marketed as Ramayana
To:
The Central Board of Film Certification
The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India
The producers, distributors, and exhibitors of the film
Relevant cultural and religious authorities

Subject: Petition requesting an immediate review and temporary withdrawal of the film marketed as Ramayana because of alleged distortions of sacred characters, events, and teachings

We, the undersigned devotees, citizens, scholars, cultural representatives, and members of the Sanatana Dharma community from India and around the world, respectfully submit this petition regarding the film marketed as Ramayana.

Detailed blog: https://timeless-wisdom-6u1oogg.gamma.site/ramayana-appeal 

For Hindus, the Ramayana is not merely entertainment or a source of fictional characters. It is a sacred and living tradition that teaches the relationship between Dharma and Adharma, the duties of a ruler, the meaning of sacrifice, the dignity of Mata Sita, and the conduct represented by Bhagwan Shri Ram, Maryada Purushottam.

We recognize the importance of artistic freedom and the long history of diverse Ramayana traditions. However, a production that uses the title and central religious figures of the Ramayana has a responsibility to distinguish clearly between the traditional epic and an invented reinterpretation. We are concerned that the film substantially alters the moral structure of the story while presenting itself to the public as the Ramayana.

Grounds for this petition
1. The portrayal of Ravana omits the conduct that defines his fall
The Ramayana describes Ravana as a powerful, learned, and devoted figure, but also as a ruler who repeatedly violated Dharma. His scholarship and devotion do not cancel his wrongdoing.

Among the actions and characteristics associated with Ravana in the Valmiki (and 300 other versions of) Ramayana and related traditions are:

Terrorizing sages and obstructing their sacrifices and religious practices.
Abducting Sita through deception and against her will.
Pursuing and coercing women.
Seizing Lanka and the Pushpaka Vimana from his half-brother Kubera.
Subjugating celestial and earthly beings through force.
Rejecting wise counsel, including advice from Vibhishana and others.
Allowing arrogance, desire, and abuse of power to govern his actions.
Receiving warnings and curses connected with his misconduct toward women.
The moral force of the Ramayana depends on presenting these actions honestly. If Ravana is portrayed primarily as a benevolent protector, reformer, or misunderstood hero while his Adharma is omitted or minimized, viewers may receive a fundamentally altered understanding of why he falls and why Bhagwan Shri Ram’s victory restores Dharma.

2. The central conflict between Dharma and Adharma is weakened
The Ramayana is not simply a political conflict between two kingdoms or communities. Its central concern is the restoration of Dharma after the abuse of power, deception, violence, and disregard for moral duty.

We are concerned that the film reframes Ravana and his forces through a modern political narrative that is not adequately identified as a fictional interpretation. Such a presentation risks turning a sacred moral teaching into a dispute in which Adharma is portrayed as righteousness and the actions of Bhagwan Shri Ram are treated as morally equivalent to Ravana’s conduct.

Ravana’s learning, power, devotion, and administrative abilities are important parts of his character. However, the traditional narrative also teaches that these qualities cannot substitute for Dharma. Knowledge without self-control, power without responsibility, and devotion without righteous conduct lead to destruction.

3. Important episodes appear to be altered or misrepresented
We request a scholarly review of the film’s treatment of the following episodes:

Shurpanakha’s encounter
In the Valmiki (and 300 other versions of) Ramayana, Shurpanakha approaches Rama with romantic intent and later attacks Sita. Lakshmana then punishes her. This event is connected to the chain of events that culminates in Sita’s abduction.

If the episode is shown as an unprovoked attack by Rama and Lakshmana, the sequence changes the moral and narrative context of the story. Any adaptation should clearly identify such a departure from the source tradition.

Sita’s abduction
The abduction of Sita is traditionally connected with Ravana’s desire, deception, arrogance, and misuse of power. Recasting the abduction as an act arising from noble motives substantially changes the moral meaning of one of the epic’s central events.

Ravana’s past actions
The film should not omit the conduct that explains Ravana’s status as an antagonist, including his persecution of sages, seizure of Kubera’s possessions, coercive behavior, and refusal to correct his wrongdoing despite repeated warnings.

Ahilya’s redemption
The meeting between Rama and Ahilya is an important expression of Rama’s compassion and spiritual significance. Its omission may remove a meaningful part of Rama’s character and mission.

Parashurama’s encounter
The encounter between Parashurama and Rama after the breaking of Shiva’s bow is significant in several Ramayana traditions. Its treatment should be reviewed for accuracy and context.

The drought of Janakpuri
Some later Ramayana traditions describe Ravana’s violence against sages and the consequences associated with the blood of those sages being taken to Janakpuri. Because this episode is not uniform across all textual traditions, it should not be presented as a universally accepted part of the Valmiki (and 300 other versions of) Ramayana without proper qualification. We request that the film’s treatment of this tradition be reviewed by qualified scholars.

4. Bhagwan Shri Ram is diminished
The Rama of Valmiki (and 300 other versions of) is compassionate, courageous, emotionally responsive, and resolute. He experiences grief at the death of his father, anguish after Sita’s abduction, love for his brothers and devotees, and righteous anger against Adharma. His adherence to Dharma does not make him emotionless or passive.

We are concerned that the film reduces Rama’s emotional and moral depth. His relationships with figures such as Ahilya, Guha, Kevat, Vibhishana, Hanuman, and the vanara community are important expressions of humility, compassion, and universal regard.

5. Mata Sita’s strength should be represented faithfully
Mata Sita’s strength in the Ramayana is moral, spiritual, and inner. During her captivity, she resists Ravana’s threats and advances with unwavering dignity and conviction.

A physical action-oriented portrayal may replace rather than communicate the distinctive strength attributed to Sita in the traditional narrative. Her courage lies in her refusal to surrender Dharma, even under extreme pressure. That dimension deserves careful and respectful representation.

6. The film may mislead children and younger audiences
Many children and young viewers may encounter the Ramayana first through cinema. They may assume that the film is a faithful account of the traditional epic, even when it contains substantial inventions or reversals.

We are particularly concerned if viewers leave believing that Ravana’s conduct was exemplary or that his actions were morally equivalent to Rama’s. A film may present a fictional adaptation, but it should not blur the distinction between established tradition and newly invented characterization.

7. Scholarly and cultural consultation is necessary
The Ramayana exists in many languages and traditions, including the Valmiki Ramayana, Ramcharitmanas, Kamban’s Tamil Ramavataram, and numerous regional and oral retellings. These traditions contain differences, and no responsible petition should claim that every detail is identical in all versions.

At the same time, many traditions preserve the central moral structure in which Rama represents Dharma and Ravana’s arrogance, desire, and abuse of power lead to his destruction. We therefore request consultation with:

Sanskrit scholars and specialists in the Valmiki (and 300 other versions of) Ramayana.
Scholars of regional Ramayana traditions.
Hindu acharyas and recognized religious institutions.
Experts in Indian history, literature, and cultural studies.
Child-development and media-literacy specialists.
8. Transparency regarding funding and public communication
Because the production uses the name and religious significance of the Ramayana, we request lawful transparency regarding:

The producers, investors, and major financial contributors.
Ultimate beneficial ownership where disclosure is required by law.
Any foreign investment or overseas institutional participation.
Compliance with applicable financial and media regulations.
The extent to which promotional material presents the film as a faithful adaptation or a fictional reinterpretation.
These requests are made for public accountability and should not be treated as accusations of unlawful conduct unless supported by evidence.

Our demands
We respectfully request that the authorities and relevant parties:

Order an immediate independent review of the film by qualified Ramayana scholars and representatives of recognized Hindu institutions.
Temporarily suspend the film’s public exhibition and promotion until the review is completed, if the competent authority determines that the film materially misrepresents sacred figures or violates applicable certification standards.
Require a prominent disclaimer stating whether the film is a faithful adaptation of the Valmiki (and 300 other versions of) Ramayana, a synthesis of later traditions, or a fictional reinterpretation.
Publish an accessible list of major departures from the source traditions used by the filmmakers.
Review the portrayal of Ravana, Rama, Sita, Shurpanakha, and other central figures, including the omission or alteration of events that establish the moral structure of the epic.
Ensure that promotional material does not present invented events or characterizations as scriptural fact.
Examine complaints regarding the removal or suppression of peaceful criticism on social media platforms, while recognizing that such complaints must be assessed through evidence and the relevant platform procedures.
Encourage educational programs and reliable translations of the Valmiki (and 300 other versions of) Ramayana and other major traditions so that young people can distinguish the original texts from cinematic adaptations.
Ensure lawful transparency concerning production funding and ownership, without making unsupported allegations against any individual or organization.
Invite the filmmakers to engage in a public scholarly discussion about their sources, creative choices, and departures from the traditional narrative.
Respect for artistic freedom
This petition does not deny the existence of diverse Ramayana traditions or demand that every artistic work reproduce every verse of the Valmiki (and 300 other versions of)  Ramayana. We accept that filmmakers may create reinterpretations.

Our request is for honesty, cultural sensitivity, and informed viewing. If the film is a fictional retelling, it should be identified clearly as such. If it is marketed as the Ramayana, it should not reverse the central moral relationship between Rama and Ravana while omitting the conduct that explains Ravana’s fall.

Prayer
We therefore respectfully request the competent authorities to:

Review the film immediately.
Suspend or withdraw it if the review establishes serious and misleading distortion of a sacred narrative under applicable law.
Require clear disclosures and corrections where appropriate.
Protect the right of devotees and citizens to express peaceful criticism.
Promote responsible representation of Sanatana Dharma and its sacred traditions.
The Ramayana has endured because it teaches that power, scholarship, wealth, and devotion cannot replace Dharma. Its lasting message is that arrogance, coercion, and abuse of power ultimately destroy the one who embraces them, while righteousness must be upheld even at personal cost.

We submit this petition peacefully and respectfully, in devotion to Bhagwan Shri Ram, Mata Sita, Hanumanji, and the sacred traditions of Sanatana Dharma.

Detailed blog: https://timeless-wisdom-6u1oogg.gamma.site/ramayana-appeal 

Submitted by:
Name: Sumedha Arvind Patwardhan
Location: Newark, California, United States
On behalf of concerned devotees and supporters of Sanatana Dharma worldwide

Signature: ____________________
Date: ____________________
Email or contact address: ____________________

Supporters:
Name | City/Country | Email | Signature | Date

avatar of the starter
sue patsPetition Starter

Petition Updates