Petition to Mayor Mamdani About the Proposed 200-Unit Shelter Near Canarsie Middle School

1,166

The Issue

November 12, 2026

The Honorable Zohran Mamdani
Mayor of the City of New York

Commissioner Erin Dalton
NYC Department of Social Services

Administrator Reesa Henderson
NYC Department of Homeless Services

RE: Community Petition Opposing Proposed 200-Bed Shelter at 913 East 108th Street, Canarsie, Brooklyn

Dear Mayor Mamdani, Commissioner Dalton, and Administrator Henderson:

We, the undersigned residents of Canarsie, Brooklyn, strongly oppose the proposed 200-bed single adult men's homeless shelter at 913 East 108th Street, near the Science and Medicine Middle School (K366). We demand that the City reconsider this location, disclose the records behind its decision, and work with residents to identify an alternative.

For over a year, our community has sought answers about development along East 108th Street. Despite repeated petitions, public meetings, and formal correspondence, residents did not receive confirmation of the shelter plans until November 2, 2026.

City procurement records raise serious questions about this timeline. A Department of Homeless Services contract listing Midway Living Inc. as the vendor, titled Midway Living Services at SA East 108 K 2026, carries an award amount of $61,545,104 and a contract term beginning October 1, 2026, more than a month before residents were notified. The contract (E-PIN 07122P0012065) is listed as In Progress, without a confirmed registration date. While the start date does not establish that the contract was executed, the City must explain when the shelter was planned and why residents were not informed sooner.

Our concerns and efforts are documented:


When did the City decide to pursue a shelter at 913 East 108th Street, and why were residents not informed despite months of documented inquiries?

We recognize the City's responsibility to provide safe, dignified shelter for New Yorkers experiencing homelessness. That responsibility must be accompanied by transparent decision-making and meaningful community consultation, particularly when a facility is proposed near a public school.

We demand the following:

1. Reconsider the proposed location.
Reject the current siting proposal and evaluate alternatives with residents, school leadership, community organizations, and elected officials. Suspend final commitments pending review.

2. Disclose the shelter-siting and procurement records.
Release the Midway Living contract, site-selection analysis, procurement documents, relevant building approvals, and environmental assessments. Explain when the site and operator were selected, why the contract lists an October 1 start date, and whether it has been executed or registered. Confirm its connection to 913 East 108th Street. Clarify any relationship to the separate developments at 937 and 945–951 East 108th Street, including the status of the April Stop Work Order and May zoning challenge, and whether the proposed shelter complies with applicable fair-use and equitable siting principles.

3. Establish clear shelter-siting standards near schools.
Require advance community consultation, school-proximity assessments, and transparent site-selection criteria before shelter locations are finalized.

4. Prioritize affordable housing and community investment.
Evaluate opportunities for affordable housing serving Canarsie's working families and invest in longstanding community needs, including infrastructure, youth programming, and a community center.

5. Ensure independent procurement oversight.
Request a review of the proposed agreement, including applicable ethics disclosures and potential conflicts of interest. Public records identify Midway Living CEO Milton Schwartz as Deputy Mayor of the Village of Wesley Hills. These dual roles do not establish wrongdoing but warrant appropriate review of the procurement process.

6. Meet directly with Canarsie residents.
We request that Mayor Mamdani and senior DSS/DHS leadership attend a public meeting with residents, school representatives, Community Board 18, and elected officials to answer questions and consider alternatives.

Canarsie deserves affordable housing, stronger infrastructure, and meaningful investment. Above all, residents deserve a voice in decisions affecting their neighborhood.

A proposed $61.5 million contract with a listed start date preceding community notification demands a clear explanation. After nearly a year of unanswered questions, residents deserve transparency, accountability, and a meaningful role in determining what happens next.

Mayor Mamdani, we urge your administration to reconsider this proposal and work with Canarsie residents toward a responsible alternative.

We request a written response within five business days, including a timeline for releasing the requested records and meeting with community members.

Respectfully,

The Undersigned Residents of Canarsie, Brooklyn

CC:

Hon. Kathy Hochul, Governor of New York State
Hon. Hakeem Jeffries, U.S. House Minority Leader
Hon. Charles E. Schumer, United States Senator
Hon. Kirsten Gillibrand, United States Senator
Hon. Letitia James, New York State Attorney General
Hon. Jumaane D. Williams, NYC Public Advocate
Hon. Mark Levine, NYC Comptroller
Hon. Antonio Reynoso, Brooklyn Borough President
Hon. Roxanne J. Persaud, NYS Senator
Hon. Nikki Lucas, NYS Assemblymember
Hon. Mercedes Narcisse, NYC Councilmember
Hon. Chris Banks, NYC Councilmember
NYC Department of Investigation
NYC Mayor's Office of Contract Services
NYC Conflicts of Interest Board

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates