

PETITION FOR THE REMOVAL OF JONATHAN FRANKLIN AS PITTSBORO TOWN MANAGER
The Issue
Town of Pittsboro, North Carolina
To: Mayor Kyle Shipp and the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners
Subject: Formal Request for the Removal of Town Manager Jonathan Franklin Regarding Concerns About Public Property Sales, Fiscal Responsibility, and Administrative Accountability
We, the undersigned residents, taxpayers, business owners, and concerned members of the Pittsboro community, formally petition the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners to remove Jonathan Franklin from his position as Town Manager.
Our request arises from concerns regarding the administration and disposition of Town-owned property, financial management, transparency, and potential failures of administrative oversight.
We believe the following matters warrant serious scrutiny and a public response.
1. The 2023 Sale of Town-Owned Property on Midway Street
On July 24, 2023, the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners approved a resolution authorizing the sale of Town-owned property on Midway Street through a negotiated-offer and statutory upset-bid process.
The transaction, identified by concerned residents as involving 31 Midway Street, reportedly involved an offer from a private individual.
We understand that no competing upset bids were received and that neighboring property owners were not directly informed that the property was available for purchase.
North Carolina General Statute § 160A-269 permits this method of sale and requires publication of the proposed offer. It does not expressly require individual notification of adjoining property owners.
However, meeting minimum legal-notification requirements does not necessarily mean the Town has provided the community with the most effective opportunity to participate.
We question whether the procedures employed adequately promoted transparency, fair competition, and the protection of public assets.
We request the publication records, initial offer, property appraisal or valuation, documentation of any competing bids, final sale documents, and a full explanation of the Town Manager's involvement in the transaction.
2. The 2025 Proposed Sale of 21.1 Acres of Town-Owned Parkland
On June 9, 2025, Town Manager Jonathan Franklin presented a proposed $1.2 million sale of approximately 21.1 acres of Town-owned land along Moncure Pittsboro Road to CPF LLC.
According to Franklin's memorandum, he initiated discussions with Chatham Park Investors concerning potential interest in the property. The initial discussions resulted in a $1 million offer for approximately 20 acres, later negotiated to $1.2 million for 21.1 acres.
The Town used a broker's price opinion in evaluating the property and proceeded through the statutory negotiated-offer and upset-bid process rather than a conventional public auction.
In a July 14, 2025 memorandum, Franklin reported that no upset bids had been received. That same day, the Board approved the proposed conveyance to CPF LLC by a unanimous vote.
The Town's stated rationale included concerns about the property's suitability for a baseball complex because of development costs and environmental factors.
Nevertheless, we believe the public deserves a thorough explanation of how the decision to dispose of this land was reached, what other public uses were considered, and whether the Town obtained the greatest reasonable benefit from the transaction.
We request a review of the valuation methodology, marketing and public-notification procedures, potential restrictions or conditions affecting the property, and any alternative development proposals considered before the sale was authorized.
3. Financial Oversight and the FY 2023–2024 Audit Findings
The Town's response to its FY 2023–2024 financial audit identified four Financial Performance Indicators of Concern under the North Carolina Local Government Commission's monitoring process.
These included:
An appropriation of fund balance accompanied by a negative change in fund balance during the fiscal year.
A Water and Sewer Capital Assets Condition Ratio of 0.41.
Two indicators involving expenditures exceeding the legal budget ordinance.
The Town explained that the latter two findings resulted from audit adjustments related to its Town Hall rental lease, including the reclassification of payments into budget categories where appropriations had not been established.
The Town also identified proposed corrective measures, including improved review of lease agreements and timely budget amendments.
While these findings do not independently establish irresponsible spending or personal misconduct by the Town Manager, they raise legitimate questions about financial controls, budget oversight, and the implementation of corrective actions.
The public deserves assurance that expenditures are properly authorized, accurately recorded, and consistently monitored.
We request an independent examination of the identified findings, their causes, the implementation of corrective measures, and the adequacy of financial oversight under the Town Manager's administration.
4. Administrative Oversight, Transparency, and Public Accountability
The Town Manager is responsible for administering municipal operations, implementing Board policies, and overseeing the responsible management of public resources.
The concerns surrounding these property transactions and financial matters raise questions about administrative judgment, transparency, and whether sufficient safeguards have been maintained.
We believe these concerns warrant a review of potential negligence or failures of oversight, without presuming that unlawful conduct has been established.
The Board of Commissioners also bears responsibility for decisions it approves and for ensuring that the administration of Town government remains accountable to the public.
OUR FORMAL REQUEST
We call upon the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners to:
Remove Jonathan Franklin from his position as Town Manager, in accordance with applicable legal and contractual requirements.
Commission an independent review of the 2023 Midway Street transaction, the 2025 Moncure Pittsboro Road property transaction, and other relevant Town-owned property dispositions.
Conduct a comprehensive review of financial management, including the FY 2023–2024 audit findings, spending decisions, budget compliance, and the implementation of recommended corrective actions.
Release relevant public records, including sale advertisements, bidding documents, property valuations, expenditure records, and transaction approvals, consistent with applicable law.
Establish stronger transparency and oversight policies, including more effective public notification of proposed property sales, independent valuation practices where appropriate, and improved financial reporting.
Address this petition at a public Board meeting, provide an explanation of the Board's response, and identify what corrective actions will be taken.
PUBLIC TRUST REQUIRES PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY
Town-owned property belongs to the community. Public funds must be administered for the benefit of the people who provide them.
When questions arise concerning the sale of public assets, financial oversight, or the conduct of municipal administration, those questions deserve answers supported by documentation and independent examination.
The issues identified in this petition do not constitute a finding of wrongdoing. They do, however, provide specific grounds for demanding greater transparency and accountability.
We, the undersigned, believe that these concerns have undermined our confidence in the current Town Manager's administration and that a change in leadership is warranted.
We therefore petition the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners to remove Jonathan Franklin as Town Manager and take the necessary steps to restore public confidence in the administration of our town.
Public property deserves public accountability.
Supporting Public Records
July 24, 2023 Board Meeting Minutes: Midway Street Property
June 9, 2025: Franklin Memorandum on Moncure Pittsboro Road Parkland
July 14, 2025: Parkland Sale Memorandum
July 14, 2025 Board Meeting Minutes
January 13, 2025: FY 2023–2024 Financial Audit Response

35
The Issue
Town of Pittsboro, North Carolina
To: Mayor Kyle Shipp and the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners
Subject: Formal Request for the Removal of Town Manager Jonathan Franklin Regarding Concerns About Public Property Sales, Fiscal Responsibility, and Administrative Accountability
We, the undersigned residents, taxpayers, business owners, and concerned members of the Pittsboro community, formally petition the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners to remove Jonathan Franklin from his position as Town Manager.
Our request arises from concerns regarding the administration and disposition of Town-owned property, financial management, transparency, and potential failures of administrative oversight.
We believe the following matters warrant serious scrutiny and a public response.
1. The 2023 Sale of Town-Owned Property on Midway Street
On July 24, 2023, the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners approved a resolution authorizing the sale of Town-owned property on Midway Street through a negotiated-offer and statutory upset-bid process.
The transaction, identified by concerned residents as involving 31 Midway Street, reportedly involved an offer from a private individual.
We understand that no competing upset bids were received and that neighboring property owners were not directly informed that the property was available for purchase.
North Carolina General Statute § 160A-269 permits this method of sale and requires publication of the proposed offer. It does not expressly require individual notification of adjoining property owners.
However, meeting minimum legal-notification requirements does not necessarily mean the Town has provided the community with the most effective opportunity to participate.
We question whether the procedures employed adequately promoted transparency, fair competition, and the protection of public assets.
We request the publication records, initial offer, property appraisal or valuation, documentation of any competing bids, final sale documents, and a full explanation of the Town Manager's involvement in the transaction.
2. The 2025 Proposed Sale of 21.1 Acres of Town-Owned Parkland
On June 9, 2025, Town Manager Jonathan Franklin presented a proposed $1.2 million sale of approximately 21.1 acres of Town-owned land along Moncure Pittsboro Road to CPF LLC.
According to Franklin's memorandum, he initiated discussions with Chatham Park Investors concerning potential interest in the property. The initial discussions resulted in a $1 million offer for approximately 20 acres, later negotiated to $1.2 million for 21.1 acres.
The Town used a broker's price opinion in evaluating the property and proceeded through the statutory negotiated-offer and upset-bid process rather than a conventional public auction.
In a July 14, 2025 memorandum, Franklin reported that no upset bids had been received. That same day, the Board approved the proposed conveyance to CPF LLC by a unanimous vote.
The Town's stated rationale included concerns about the property's suitability for a baseball complex because of development costs and environmental factors.
Nevertheless, we believe the public deserves a thorough explanation of how the decision to dispose of this land was reached, what other public uses were considered, and whether the Town obtained the greatest reasonable benefit from the transaction.
We request a review of the valuation methodology, marketing and public-notification procedures, potential restrictions or conditions affecting the property, and any alternative development proposals considered before the sale was authorized.
3. Financial Oversight and the FY 2023–2024 Audit Findings
The Town's response to its FY 2023–2024 financial audit identified four Financial Performance Indicators of Concern under the North Carolina Local Government Commission's monitoring process.
These included:
An appropriation of fund balance accompanied by a negative change in fund balance during the fiscal year.
A Water and Sewer Capital Assets Condition Ratio of 0.41.
Two indicators involving expenditures exceeding the legal budget ordinance.
The Town explained that the latter two findings resulted from audit adjustments related to its Town Hall rental lease, including the reclassification of payments into budget categories where appropriations had not been established.
The Town also identified proposed corrective measures, including improved review of lease agreements and timely budget amendments.
While these findings do not independently establish irresponsible spending or personal misconduct by the Town Manager, they raise legitimate questions about financial controls, budget oversight, and the implementation of corrective actions.
The public deserves assurance that expenditures are properly authorized, accurately recorded, and consistently monitored.
We request an independent examination of the identified findings, their causes, the implementation of corrective measures, and the adequacy of financial oversight under the Town Manager's administration.
4. Administrative Oversight, Transparency, and Public Accountability
The Town Manager is responsible for administering municipal operations, implementing Board policies, and overseeing the responsible management of public resources.
The concerns surrounding these property transactions and financial matters raise questions about administrative judgment, transparency, and whether sufficient safeguards have been maintained.
We believe these concerns warrant a review of potential negligence or failures of oversight, without presuming that unlawful conduct has been established.
The Board of Commissioners also bears responsibility for decisions it approves and for ensuring that the administration of Town government remains accountable to the public.
OUR FORMAL REQUEST
We call upon the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners to:
Remove Jonathan Franklin from his position as Town Manager, in accordance with applicable legal and contractual requirements.
Commission an independent review of the 2023 Midway Street transaction, the 2025 Moncure Pittsboro Road property transaction, and other relevant Town-owned property dispositions.
Conduct a comprehensive review of financial management, including the FY 2023–2024 audit findings, spending decisions, budget compliance, and the implementation of recommended corrective actions.
Release relevant public records, including sale advertisements, bidding documents, property valuations, expenditure records, and transaction approvals, consistent with applicable law.
Establish stronger transparency and oversight policies, including more effective public notification of proposed property sales, independent valuation practices where appropriate, and improved financial reporting.
Address this petition at a public Board meeting, provide an explanation of the Board's response, and identify what corrective actions will be taken.
PUBLIC TRUST REQUIRES PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY
Town-owned property belongs to the community. Public funds must be administered for the benefit of the people who provide them.
When questions arise concerning the sale of public assets, financial oversight, or the conduct of municipal administration, those questions deserve answers supported by documentation and independent examination.
The issues identified in this petition do not constitute a finding of wrongdoing. They do, however, provide specific grounds for demanding greater transparency and accountability.
We, the undersigned, believe that these concerns have undermined our confidence in the current Town Manager's administration and that a change in leadership is warranted.
We therefore petition the Pittsboro Board of Commissioners to remove Jonathan Franklin as Town Manager and take the necessary steps to restore public confidence in the administration of our town.
Public property deserves public accountability.
Supporting Public Records
July 24, 2023 Board Meeting Minutes: Midway Street Property
June 9, 2025: Franklin Memorandum on Moncure Pittsboro Road Parkland
July 14, 2025: Parkland Sale Memorandum
July 14, 2025 Board Meeting Minutes
January 13, 2025: FY 2023–2024 Financial Audit Response

The Decision Makers



Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 18, 2026