Overhaul NHS infant feeding policy to support women and babies

843

Let’s get to 1000 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

We're asking the Health Secretary for an NHS infant feeding framework built on women's autonomy and choice: honest information about breastfeeding challenges, balanced advice on formula, combination feeding as a valid option, and women's mental and physical health taken into account. 

Our petition began by calling for an end to the guilt and shame surrounding infant feeding, and for women to receive balanced information and support. Our new report, Admission of Failure?, shows the problem goes further than information: more newborns are being admitted to hospital, and nobody is checking whether NHS feeding policy plays a part. The petition is now part of Told in Time, our campaign for every woman to get the full facts on feeding before her baby arrives.

At present, NHS infant feeding care is working for no one. Women across the UK are being denied accurate, evidence-based infant feeding information. That leaves them poorly equipped for the struggles of breastfeeding, and feeling guilt and shame when they need to use infant formula, as most will go on to do. Healthcare providers are hamstrung, unable to provide optimal, individualised care.

Women are also rarely told, before they need it, why breastfeeding can be difficult or the signs that a baby isn’t getting enough milk. In England, the rate of newborns admitted to hospital with jaundice in their first two weeks has more than tripled since 2008. The NHS does not record how these babies were fed, so it cannot tell whether its own policy is playing a part.

We’re asking for four changes, so every woman is told in time:

  1. Bring infant feeding in line with informed consent.  Every woman should receive balanced, proactive information about breastfeeding, formula and combination feeding before birth, including benefits, risks and reasonable alternatives. NICE guidance should support this for all women, and decisions should reflect each woman's circumstances, health and wishes.
  2. Measure what matters. Judge infant-feeding care by maternal and infant health outcomes, not breastfeeding rates alone. Investigate rising neonatal admissions across all four UK nations, including whether inadequate milk intake contributes, and ensure feeding method and weight loss are recorded consistently.
  3. An urgent, independent review of infant feeding policy. Commission an urgent, independent review of infant feeding policy, free from institutional and commercial conflicts of interest. Until it reports, suspend further requirements for Baby Friendly Initiative accreditation and pause targets to reduce formula supplementation.
  4. Protect families from formula marketing. Implement the Competition and Markets Authority's recommendations, including stronger controls on follow-on formula marketing. Ensure every woman receives impartial, brand-free NHS information about formula, including that the cheapest meets her baby's needs just as well as the dearest.

Set Up to Fail, our report with women’s health platform The Lowdown, showed the extent of the problem. 75% of women surveyed felt guilt and shame using infant formula and more than half felt unprepared for the reality of their infant feeding journeys. Just 5% said the NHS prepared them “well”. Only 4% of women said the information they received about infant feeding was completely balanced, fact-based, and presented all feeding options fairly. One woman was told formula is the equivalent of “greasy fried chicken”.

This is harming maternal mental health. Of women who tried breastfeeding, 49% said the challenges affected how they felt as a mother and 48% said they made them feel low or anxious after the birth. Only 6% of women support the current NHS approach, in which formula feeding is only discussed if a woman raises it, while 84% say all feeding options should be discussed with parents proactively.

Our new report, Admission of Failure, sets out the evidence behind Told in Time. BBC Radio 4’s File on 4 investigates newborn hospital admissions and NHS infant feeding policy on 10 November 2026. Now is the chance to make your voice heard and make sure ALL infant feeding options are discussed with women freely and fairly, before their babies arrive, so they can make the choices that are right for them and their families.

After all, they are the ones who know their own circumstances best.

“No one told me that it might not work, that it might be excruciatingly painful, that I might have bleeding nipples for weeks, that he might not gain weight, that I would never sleep. I ended up with pnd [postnatal depression]. It was horrific. The shame of formula feeding was so awful.”  Amy*, Exclusive Breastfeeding then Exclusive Formula Feeding, Wales

“Our biggest challenge was a severe tongue tie. The midwives could see it as it was so severe but the first nhs appointment to cut it was 5 weeks away… The latch issue lead to multiple mastitis episodes on the first two weeks that required antibiotics. All could have been avoided with instant diagnosis and procedure.”  Emily*, Exclusive Breastfeeding, England

“We were explicitly told by the midwife that under the NHS they cannot promote formula-feeding or discuss it with [you]...I felt extreme shame for having to bottle feed my 2nd child, so much so that I couldn't do it for the first couple of days, my husband had to feed her when we started formula feeding, as I would cry uncontrollably and couldn't even face watching as I was so ashamed.” Esme*, Combination Feeding, England

  “When I raised concerns about my breastfeeding journey, I was told blandly to “just keep trying”. I ended up hiring a private lactation consultant but it was too late. More unbiased information is needed on formula feeding. It is a lifeline for some babies and it is incredibly hard to accept when your feeding journey doesn’t go the way you planned. The scaremongering and demonisation of formula deeply impacted my mental health.” Rhona*, Combination Feeding, Scotland

“They told us all about breastfeeding but when I asked about formula feeding and combi feeding I was told they weren't allowed to tell us anything about it.”  Laura*, Combination Feeding, England

“There is no doubt in my mind that we were set up to fail. We were told to breastfeed - made to think this was the only thing an educated person would do, but when it came to help with breastfeeding, they all just shrugged and said - we don't know how to help you.” Dora*, Exclusive Breastfeeding then Exclusive Formula Feeding, Scotland

“a lactation consultant told me that feeding my son formula was like feeding him a greasy fried chicken dinner, and that feeding him breastmilk was like feeding him a nutritious salad. It made me feel so much shame, and pushed me to attempt to breastfeed far longer than was optimal for mine and my baby’s health.” Imogen*, Breastfeeding, Expressing and Formula Feeding.

avatar of the starter
Feed @feedukorgPetition StarterThe independent charity that puts women and familes at the heart of infant feeding; bottles, boobs or tubes.

The Decision Makers

Wes Streeting
Secretary of State for Health and Social Care

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates