Petition update

Suspicious Honey Alert

Simon Mulvany
Melbourne, Australia

Sep 3, 2018 — 

Wow!  The Beekeeper and Honey-eater world has gone from amber to red alert.


ABC and Fairfax have published a joint-investigation of Capilano accused of selling fake honey.


ABC: Capilano, Australia's biggest honey producer, and supermarkets accused of selling 'fake' honey


Capilano, supermarkets accused of selling fake honey


All this is happening while big company Capilano Honey Ltd is suing me in the Supreme Court of Victoria.


It’s a “Permanent Injunction” legal attack to try and remove what I have said publicly and not allow me to say anything like this again.


I don’t want to be in Court.  I am the “defendant”.


I simply tried to speak up for the bees and the community in Australia.


Kind donations helped me pay lawyers to prepare the first part of a legal defence.


Supreme Court Judge Dixon has warned me that without paid lawyers I am “swimming with sharks without a shark cage” (his words!)


Yep that’s for sure.  I’m in unfamiliar dangerous waters.


Having my own professional lawyers helps me fight back. This costs money.



Please support me to keep funding a legal team and expert witnesses.


Judge Dixon says I will not get a JURY TRIAL if I do not have lawyers. And I want a JURY of common sense people in the community to decide this case.


Please share 








Friday 20 July, I represented myself against big company Capilano Honey Ltd in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

I don’t have lawyers so did the best I could alone in the directions hearing and am allowed now to put in an updated defence by 24 August.


Judge Dixon warned me how ruinous litigation can be.


He didn’t need to tell me.  I don’t want to be in Court.  I am the “defendant”.  I did not start this legal case.


I simply tried to speak up for beekeepers and honey eaters in Australia.


Capilano Honey is suing me to try and remove what I have said publicly and not allow me to say anything like this again.  “Permanent injunction” in legal speak.


But I am not going away.  I want to speak and not be stopped from speaking for the bees and the community.


Judge Dixon warned me that without paid lawyers I am “swimming with sharks without a shark cage” (his words!)


He is right.  This case has been running for 2 years.  I am doing the best I can and finally got permission on 30 May to have the case transferred from NSW to my home State of Victoria.


Capilano Honey is based in Brisbane, Queensland butstarted this whole case in Sydney NSW.  As you can imagine there has been a whole bunch of highly paid Sydney lawyers stacked up against me.


Capilano said they would suffer all the inconvenience if the case was transferred to where I live in Melbourne VIC and I “will not suffer any inconvenience or additional cost by the proceedings remaining in Sydney”. The NSW Judge decided to totally reject that and said: “The uncontested evidence is that Mr Mulvany is the sole parent of an eight-year old child, the child’s mother being deceased. I do not understand how it could seriously be contended that it would not cause “inconvenience” for him to have to travel to Sydney for court.”  She also said: “I do not understand why the interests of an unrepresented defendant and a young child should weigh less in the balance than the convenience of Sydney lawyers.”


You can read the NSW judgment HERE:


So I got the case transferred!  It’s a big win for me.  But there are lots of challenges to keep defending myself.  It’s all getting more complex and I need a shark cage and some shark repellent.  This costs money.


Please share 


Keep fighting for people power!

Politicians and rich CEOs shouldn't make all the decisions. Today we ask you to help keep free and independent. Our job as a public benefit company is to help petitions like this one fight back and get heard. If everyone who saw this chipped in monthly we'd secure's future today. Help us hold the powerful to account. Can you spare a minute to become a member today?

I'll power Change with $5 monthlyPayment method


Please enter a comment.

We were unable to post your comment. Please try again.