

Keep the Roadless Rule and Stop Wasting Tax Dollars on Tongass Logging Roads
The Issue
The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) is moving to repeal the Roadless Rule, a 2001 policy that blocks new roads and logging on protected national forest land. The USDA says the change would help firefighters and cut red tape. But in Alaska’s Tongass National Forest, history suggests taxpayers would foot the bill for logging projects that never pay off.
The numbers are hard to ignore. A 2019 report from the watchdog group Taxpayers for Common Sense found the Forest Service spent more than $600 million preparing timber sales between 1999 and 2018 and got back only 5.4% of it. A single mile of logging road can cost about $200,000, according to an estimate from a spokesperson for Viking Lumber.
Opening roadless areas has been tried before. During the 2020 to 2023 exemption, not one timber sale took place in the Tongass’s roadless areas, KTOO reports. Retired Forest Service economist Susan Alexander told the station that earlier rollbacks led to costly sale preparations that never sold.
Even the timber industry doubts this is a fix. Tessa Axelson, executive director of the Alaska Forest Association, said the change would add some timber supply but not enough to solve the industry’s deeper problems.
Southeast Alaska’s economy has also changed. Timber supports fewer than 300 jobs in the region, while tourism supports more than 8,000. Visitors come to see old, intact forest, according to University of Alaska Southeast forest ecologist Logan Berner.
No matter someone’s politics, spending public money on roads to timber sales nobody buys is a bad deal. The USDA should keep the Roadless Rule in place and put federal dollars where they deliver real results.
Sign the petition to tell the USDA to keep the Roadless Rule and stop paying for roads to nowhere, before the repeal is finalized next year.

311
The Issue
The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) is moving to repeal the Roadless Rule, a 2001 policy that blocks new roads and logging on protected national forest land. The USDA says the change would help firefighters and cut red tape. But in Alaska’s Tongass National Forest, history suggests taxpayers would foot the bill for logging projects that never pay off.
The numbers are hard to ignore. A 2019 report from the watchdog group Taxpayers for Common Sense found the Forest Service spent more than $600 million preparing timber sales between 1999 and 2018 and got back only 5.4% of it. A single mile of logging road can cost about $200,000, according to an estimate from a spokesperson for Viking Lumber.
Opening roadless areas has been tried before. During the 2020 to 2023 exemption, not one timber sale took place in the Tongass’s roadless areas, KTOO reports. Retired Forest Service economist Susan Alexander told the station that earlier rollbacks led to costly sale preparations that never sold.
Even the timber industry doubts this is a fix. Tessa Axelson, executive director of the Alaska Forest Association, said the change would add some timber supply but not enough to solve the industry’s deeper problems.
Southeast Alaska’s economy has also changed. Timber supports fewer than 300 jobs in the region, while tourism supports more than 8,000. Visitors come to see old, intact forest, according to University of Alaska Southeast forest ecologist Logan Berner.
No matter someone’s politics, spending public money on roads to timber sales nobody buys is a bad deal. The USDA should keep the Roadless Rule in place and put federal dollars where they deliver real results.
Sign the petition to tell the USDA to keep the Roadless Rule and stop paying for roads to nowhere, before the repeal is finalized next year.

The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 10, 2026
