Justice for Nolan Xavier Wells: We Are Asking for Answers, Not Assumptions!

43

Let’s get to 50 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

JUSTICE FOR NOLAN WELLS
Petition to the United States Department of Justice and Federal Bureau of Investigation for an Independent Federal Review

To: The United States Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General, Civil Rights Division, and Federal Bureau of Investigation

Re: The Death of Nolan Xavier Wells

We, the undersigned, respectfully call upon the United States Department of Justice and Federal Bureau of Investigation to conduct a thorough, independent federal review of the circumstances surrounding the disappearance and death of 18-year-old Nolan Xavier Wells in Mississippi.

This petition does not ask federal authorities to presume that a crime occurred, identify a suspect without evidence, or disregard evidence already collected by Mississippi authorities.

We ask something much more fundamental:

Determine, independently and comprehensively, what happened to Nolan Wells.

Nolan disappeared on July 4, 2026, during an outing to Horn Island, Mississippi. His body was recovered two days later.

A Jackson County grand jury subsequently reviewed the investigation, issuing 132 subpoenas and considering testimony or statements from 43 witnesses, along with physical evidence, cellphone information, forensic reports, photographs, videos and GPS data. The grand jury returned no indictments and reported that the circumstances in which Nolan’s body was recovered were consistent with drowning.

We acknowledge those findings.

But a decision not to indict does not resolve every unanswered question surrounding Nolan’s death.

Most importantly, the medical evidence itself has not conclusively established Nolan’s cause and manner of death.

WHY AN INDEPENDENT FEDERAL REVIEW IS WARRANTED
1. The Mississippi State Medical Examiner classified Nolan’s cause and manner of death as undetermined.

The state’s own autopsy did not conclusively determine that Nolan died by accidental drowning. The state medical examiner classified both his cause and manner of death as undetermined because the circumstances surrounding his death remained unknown.

That distinction matters.

A finding that a body’s condition is “consistent with drowning” is not necessarily the same as a medical determination establishing how the person entered the water, whether the person was conscious when entering the water, whether another injury contributed to the death, or whether the death was accidental.

2. The family’s independent forensic pathologist also reached an undetermined conclusion.

An independent autopsy performed by forensic pathologist Dr. Roger Mitchell similarly classified Nolan’s cause and manner of death as undetermined.

Thus, two separate forensic examinations did not conclusively establish the cause and manner of Nolan’s death.

That unresolved medical determination alone warrants continued scrutiny.

3. Nolan sustained injuries that remain important to understanding what happened.

The state autopsy documented two dark red-purple subcutaneous scalp contusions on the back of Nolan’s head.

The existence of an injury does not by itself establish criminal conduct.

But when an 18-year-old disappears and is subsequently found dead, unexplained injuries deserve a complete forensic accounting: When were they sustained? How were they sustained? Were they consistent with an accidental fall? Did they occur before or after death? Did they impair Nolan’s ability to protect himself in the water? Did they contribute in any way to his death?

The public deserves scientifically supported answers.

4. Critical questions remain about Nolan’s final hours.

The central question is not simply whether Nolan’s body was found in water.

The questions are:

How did Nolan enter the water?

When did he enter the water?

Was he conscious when he entered the water?

Was he injured before entering the water?

Was he physically capable of protecting himself?

What happened between the last confirmed interaction with Nolan and the discovery of his body?

Until those questions can be answered as fully as the available evidence permits, the circumstances surrounding his death remain unresolved.

5. Digital evidence deserves comprehensive independent examination.

Nolan’s cellphone did not remain with him when he disappeared.

The family’s digital forensic examiner subsequently analyzed cellphone location information, communications and other digital artifacts. Public reporting indicates that deleted or unsent Snapchat material was recovered or identified during that examination.

The examiner appropriately stated that he could not determine criminal intent from deletion activity alone.

We agree that deletion, standing alone, proves neither homicide nor wrongdoing.

But the complete digital record—including GPS/location data, device-access information, communications, application records, photographs, videos, metadata and relevant communications from other individuals present—should be independently examined and synchronized into a comprehensive timeline.

Federal investigators possess sophisticated digital-forensic capabilities that can assist in determining whether additional evidence exists.

6. A grand jury’s decision not to indict does not prevent additional investigation.

A “no true bill” is not a trial verdict establishing every fact surrounding Nolan’s death.

Mississippi authorities themselves have acknowledged that there is no statute of limitations for homicide and that the matter can be presented again if credible evidence emerges indicating that Nolan’s death was non-accidental.

An independent federal review therefore does not disregard the grand jury.

It provides another layer of review in a case where the medical cause and manner of death remain undetermined.

7. Federal review has already been formally requested by members of Congress.

On August 12, 2026, members of the Congressional Black Caucus formally requested that the U.S. Department of Justice and FBI undertake an independent federal review of Nolan’s disappearance and death, provide appropriate federal investigative assistance, and determine whether a basis exists for a federal investigation, including under applicable federal civil-rights laws.

That request did not presume the outcome of the investigation.

Neither does this petition.

We ask federal authorities to follow the evidence wherever it leads.

8. The Wells family deserves transparency and confidence in the process.

The death of a child is devastating under any circumstances.

When the official medical determination remains “undetermined,” a family should not be expected simply to accept unanswered questions that available forensic science may be capable of addressing.

An independent federal review can either identify evidence requiring further investigation or provide additional independent support for the conclusion that no criminal conduct occurred.

Both outcomes serve justice.

OUR REQUEST

We, the Chicago Assocation of Black Social Workers,  therefore respectfully request that the United States Department of Justice and Federal Bureau of Investigation:

*Conduct an independent federal review of Nolan Xavier Wells’s disappearance and death.

*Obtain and independently examine the complete investigative record, including unredacted law-enforcement reports, witness interviews, photographs, video, forensic reports, search-and-rescue records, boat information and other relevant physical evidence.

*Conduct an independent forensic review of both autopsies, including the documented injuries to Nolan’s head and any other injuries identified during examination.

*Review the complete digital evidence, including Nolan’s cellphone extraction, GPS/location records, relevant social-media communications, metadata and other available digital evidence necessary to reconstruct the timeline.

*Reconstruct Nolan’s final known movements and interactions using witness accounts, digital records, vessel movements and other available evidence.

*Determine whether additional witness interviews or forensic examinations are warranted.

*Determine whether the facts provide a basis for investigation under any applicable federal criminal or civil-rights law.

*Provide the Wells family with appropriate information regarding the status and ultimate disposition of the federal review, consistent with federal law and legitimate investigative restrictions.


THIS REQUEST IS ABOUT TRUTH, NOT PREJUDGMENT
We recognize that misinformation and unsupported allegations can harm innocent people.

Justice requires that those concerns be taken seriously as well.

We, the Chicago Association of Black Social Workers,  therefore do not ask DOJ to presume that Nolan was murdered, presume that his death was racially motivated, or presume that any particular individual committed a crime.  But neither should an unexplained death be converted into certainty where the forensic evidence itself remains classified as undetermined.  The standard should be evidence. If the evidence establishes that Nolan’s death was a tragic accident, his family deserves confidence in that conclusion. If additional investigation reveals evidence of criminal conduct, his family deserves accountability. And if questions remain, his family deserves an honest acknowledgment of what can—and cannot—be established.

NOLAN DESERVES ANSWERS
Nolan Xavier Wells was eighteen years old.

His life should not be reduced to speculation on social media, political arguments, competing narratives, or unanswered questions. His family deserves the fullest accounting that modern forensic science and law enforcement can provide.

We, the Chicago Association of Black Social Workers,  therefore call upon the United States Department of Justice and Federal Bureau of Investigation to independently review the disappearance and death of Nolan Xavier Wells and determine, based solely upon the evidence, whether additional federal investigation is warranted.

Justice does not require us to know the answer before we investigate.

Justice requires us to be willing to find it.

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates