Investigate Alexandra Ignatova’s Judging at 2026 Skate America

431

Let’s get to 500 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

Demand an Independent Investigation Into Alexandra Ignatova’s Judging at 2026 Skate America

To International Skating Union (ISU), ISU Officials Assessment Commission, and U.S. Figure Skating

We, the undersigned figure skating fans and supporters of fair competition, call for an independent investigation into the judging and technical evaluation of Alexandra Ignatova’s performance at the 2026 Skate America Grand Prix, held November 13–15, 2026, in Everett, Washington.

We recognize and respect Ami Nakai’s outstanding performance and well-deserved victory. This petition does not seek to diminish her achievement or the accomplishments of any other competitor.

However, we believe that Alexandra Ignatova’s free-skating score of 139.66 points raises legitimate questions about the consistency, fairness, and transparency of the judging process.

Why We Are Concerned

According to the official ISU judging protocols:

Alexandra Ignatova received 75.31 technical points, compared with Rino Matsuike’s 73.24.
Despite Ignatova’s higher technical score, she received only 64.35 program component points, compared with Matsuike’s 68.09.
Consequently, Ignatova finished third in the free skate with 139.66 points, behind Matsuike’s 141.33.
Ignatova’s quadruple Lutz and two triple toe loops received quarter-rotation calls, which affected their execution scores.
Ignatova’s overall second-place finish does not eliminate legitimate questions about the evaluation of her free-skating performance.
Although figure skating judging necessarily involves some subjectivity, subjectivity must never become an excuse for inconsistent standards, unexplained scoring disparities, or potential bias.

Athletes dedicate years of their lives to mastering extraordinarily difficult skills. They deserve confidence that their performances are evaluated fairly, regardless of nationality, reputation, or competitive history.

What We Demand

1. An independent investigation

We call upon the ISU Officials Assessment Commission and relevant disciplinary authorities to conduct a comprehensive review of the judges’ marks and technical panel decisions from the women’s free-skating competition.

2. A technical review of Ignatova’s performance

We request an expert examination of available video footage, especially the quarter-rotation calls on her quadruple Lutz and triple toe loops, together with the grades of execution and awarded step-sequence level.

3. An examination of judging consistency

We request an assessment of whether the program component scores and execution marks were applied consistently across competitors, including whether any individual judges demonstrated statistically unusual marking patterns or possible bias.

4. Correction of scoring errors where permitted

If the investigation establishes mathematical or other correctable errors under the applicable ISU regulations, we request appropriate corrections to the official scores and results.

We also call for stronger independent review mechanisms when substantial technical or judging errors are demonstrated but cannot be corrected under current rules.

5. Accountability and disciplinary measures

If any judge or technical official is found, through a fair investigation, to have engaged in deliberate bias, serious misconduct, manipulation, or repeated significant violations of judging standards, we demand meaningful disciplinary consequences.

Such consequences should include suspension, removal from future ISU judging assignments, or permanent disqualification from judging where justified and authorized by ISU regulations.

6. Transparency and public accountability

We request that the ISU publish a meaningful summary of its findings, explain any identified scoring irregularities, and outline the measures taken to prevent similar concerns in future international competitions.

Fair Judging Is Essential to the Future of Figure Skating

This petition is not an accusation that misconduct has already been proven. It is a demand that legitimate concerns be examined independently and transparently.

The credibility of figure skating depends upon athletes and fans trusting the integrity of competition.

No athlete should be disadvantaged by inconsistent evaluation, and no official should be above accountability.

We urge the ISU to demonstrate its commitment to fairness through a transparent investigation and appropriate action based on the evidence.

Sign this petition if you believe Alexandra Ignatova — and every figure skater — deserves fair, consistent, and accountable judging.

Fair judging. Equal standards. Real accountability.

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates