
Independent Investigation Into Corruption Within Derbyshire Police
The Issue
Why This Petition Exists
Across Derbyshire, members of the public have raised serious and sustained concerns regarding the conduct, decision making, complaint handling, investigative practices and safeguarding responsibilities of Derbyshire Police.
These concerns do not relate to isolated incidents or individual mistakes. Rather, they reflect recurring experiences reported by multiple members of the public across different cases over an extended period of time.
Many individuals report feeling that legitimate concerns have been ignored, dismissed, delayed, misrepresented or closed without adequate explanation or accountability.
Reported concerns include:
• Complaints being ignored, delayed, prematurely closed or inadequately addressed
• Investigations being conducted inconsistently with unexplained changes in process or decision making
• Contradictory accounts of events, evidence or procedural actions
• A lack of transparency that makes it difficult for the public to understand how decisions have been reached
• Potential conflicts of interest where the force is effectively responsible for assessing its own conduct
• Failures to provide meaningful responses to complaints with concerns being reframed or narrowed rather than substantively addressed
• Concerns that institutional reputation may at times be prioritised over accountability, transparency and public confidence
These issues raise important questions about whether existing oversight mechanisms are functioning effectively and whether members of the public can have confidence that concerns will be handled fairly, consistently and impartially.
Serious Concerns Regarding Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG)
Particular concern has been raised regarding the handling of cases involving VAWG, including:
• Stalking
• Harassment
• Coercive and controlling behaviour
• Domestic abuse
• Sexual violence
• Threatening and intimidating behaviour
• Technology facilitated abuse
These offences often involve patterns of behaviour that develop over time rather than isolated incidents. Effective investigation therefore depends on recognising cumulative conduct, identifying escalation risks, recording crimes accurately and taking victims' concerns seriously from the outset.
However, multiple members of the public have reported experiences that cause concern regarding whether these principles are being applied consistently.
Reported concerns include:
• Failure to record crimes in accordance with the National Crime Recording Standard
• Failure to recognise repeated incidents as part of wider patterns of stalking, coercive control or abuse
• Failure to investigate allegations proportionately or within reasonable timeframes
• Victims being advised that matters remain under investigation when cases have allegedly been closed or downgraded
• Significant delays that may prevent summary offences from reaching court within statutory time limits
• Delays in evidence gathering that may undermine opportunities to investigate allegations effectively
• Inconsistent application of legal thresholds, creating concerns regarding fairness and objectivity
• Safeguarding measures being directed towards victims rather than appropriate investigation of alleged offending behaviour
• Failure to communicate clearly with victims regarding decisions, actions and case progression
Where allegations involve stalking, coercive control, or domestic abuse, delays, failures in communication or failures in crime recording may have significant consequences for victim safety and public confidence.
Given the national importance placed on tackling violence against women and girls, these concerns warrant independent examination.
Concerns Regarding Disabled and Neurodivergent Victims
Particularly serious concerns have been raised regarding the experiences of disabled and neurodivergent individuals engaging with Derbyshire Police.
Neurodivergent people and disabled people may communicate distress differently, require reasonable adjustments, experience heightened vulnerability to abuse or face additional barriers when seeking assistance from public authorities.
Public bodies have legal and ethical obligations to ensure that disability, neurodivergence, mental health conditions, communication differences and accessibility needs do not become barriers to accessing justice.
However, reports from members of the public raise concerns that this may not always be occurring in practice.
Reported concerns include:
• Communication differences being treated as indicators of unreliability rather than recognised as disability related needs
• Distress responses being interpreted negatively rather than understood within the context of trauma, disability or neurodivergence
• Failure to provide reasonable adjustments necessary for effective participation in investigations and complaint processes
• Failure to provide intermediaries or communication support where individuals have been assessed as requiring them
• Victims being characterised as problematic, difficult or controlling after requesting adjustments or attempting to pursue concerns
• Vulnerabilities appearing to influence assessments of credibility or risk
• Safeguarding processes being used in ways that individuals perceive as punitive rather than supportive
• Failure to adequately recognise the heightened risk that disabled and neurodivergent individuals may face from coercive control, exploitation, stalking and abuse.
These concerns are especially significant because disabled women and neurodivergent women are recognised as being at increased risk of abuse, coercion, exploitation, harassment and victimisation.
Where systems fail to recognise disabilit related needs or communication differences, vulnerable individuals may be denied equal access to justice and protection.
An independent review should examine whether current policies, training and practices adequately protect disabled and neurodivergent individuals and comply with equality and safeguarding obligations.
Wider Concerns Regarding Accountability and Transparency
Members of the public have also reported concerns regarding:
• Delays or obstacles in obtaining information through Subject Access Requests
• Lack of clear explanations for key investigative decisions
• Difficulties obtaining accountability through complaints procedures
• Limited transparency when concerns are raised regarding officer conduct
• Decisions being insufficiently documented or explained
• Perceived inconsistencies between documented policies and lived experiences of complainants
• Concerns that internal review processes may not provide sufficient independence to maintain public confidence
Taken together, these concerns raise important questions about whether existing systems provide adequate transparency, accountability and protection against potential institutional failings.
What We Are Calling For
We are calling for a fully independent investigation led by a body with no operational or institutional ties to Derbyshire Police.
The investigation should examine:
• Whether systemic failures, maladministration, misconduct or cultural issues may have influenced decision making
• Whether complaint-handling processes are fair, effective and fit for purpose
• Whether victims and complainants, particularly disabled and neurodivergent individuals, receive fair and lawful treatment
• Whether violence against women and girls cases are being handled in accordance with national guidance and best practice
• Whether crime recording practices comply with national standards
• Whether safeguarding processes are being applied appropriately and consistently
• Whether accountability mechanisms are sufficient to identify and address failures
• Whether institutional structures create barriers to transparency or independent scrutiny
• Whether reforms are required to improve public confidence and prevent further harm
This petition does not presume the outcome of any investigation.
It seeks only to ensure that serious concerns raised by members of the public are examined independently, transparently and objectively.
Why This Matters
Policing depends upon public trust.
Members of the public must be able to trust that concerns will be:
• Listened to
• Recorded accurately
• Investigated fairly
• Evaluated objectively
• Communicated transparently
• Reviewed independently when necessary
When people feel ignored, dismissed, misrepresented, disbelieved or prevented from accessing justice, confidence in policing is undermined.
This is particularly concerning where the issues affect victims of stalking, coercive control, domestic abuse, sexual violence, harassment and other forms of violence against women and girls.
It is even more concerning where those affected are disabled, neurodivergent, or otherwise vulnerable and may already face significant barriers when seeking help.
No individual should be disadvantaged because they communicate differently, require reasonable adjustments, live with a disability or experience neurodivergence.
Independent scrutiny is essential not only for those who have already raised concerns, but for the wider public whose confidence depends on knowing that policing remains accountable, transparent and open to examination.
Why Independent Scrutiny Is Necessary
An independent investigation is not about assuming wrongdoing.
It is about establishing the facts.
If concerns are unfounded, an independent investigation can help restore confidence.
If concerns are substantiated, it can identify necessary reforms and ensure accountability.
Either outcome serves the public interest.
Public confidence cannot be maintained where serious and recurring concerns remain unexamined.
Transparency is not a threat to policing.
It is fundamental to public trust in policing.
What You Can Do
Sign this petition to support:
• Transparency
• Accountability
• Independent scrutiny
• Equal access to justice
• Protection of disabled and neurodivergent individuals
• Better responses to violence against women and girls
• Fair and lawful treatment of all members of the public
Every signature strengthens the call for an independent investigation into concerns that affect not only individual cases but confidence in policing across Derbyshire.
Public trust can only be maintained through transparency, accountability and independent scrutiny.

1,963
The Issue
Why This Petition Exists
Across Derbyshire, members of the public have raised serious and sustained concerns regarding the conduct, decision making, complaint handling, investigative practices and safeguarding responsibilities of Derbyshire Police.
These concerns do not relate to isolated incidents or individual mistakes. Rather, they reflect recurring experiences reported by multiple members of the public across different cases over an extended period of time.
Many individuals report feeling that legitimate concerns have been ignored, dismissed, delayed, misrepresented or closed without adequate explanation or accountability.
Reported concerns include:
• Complaints being ignored, delayed, prematurely closed or inadequately addressed
• Investigations being conducted inconsistently with unexplained changes in process or decision making
• Contradictory accounts of events, evidence or procedural actions
• A lack of transparency that makes it difficult for the public to understand how decisions have been reached
• Potential conflicts of interest where the force is effectively responsible for assessing its own conduct
• Failures to provide meaningful responses to complaints with concerns being reframed or narrowed rather than substantively addressed
• Concerns that institutional reputation may at times be prioritised over accountability, transparency and public confidence
These issues raise important questions about whether existing oversight mechanisms are functioning effectively and whether members of the public can have confidence that concerns will be handled fairly, consistently and impartially.
Serious Concerns Regarding Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG)
Particular concern has been raised regarding the handling of cases involving VAWG, including:
• Stalking
• Harassment
• Coercive and controlling behaviour
• Domestic abuse
• Sexual violence
• Threatening and intimidating behaviour
• Technology facilitated abuse
These offences often involve patterns of behaviour that develop over time rather than isolated incidents. Effective investigation therefore depends on recognising cumulative conduct, identifying escalation risks, recording crimes accurately and taking victims' concerns seriously from the outset.
However, multiple members of the public have reported experiences that cause concern regarding whether these principles are being applied consistently.
Reported concerns include:
• Failure to record crimes in accordance with the National Crime Recording Standard
• Failure to recognise repeated incidents as part of wider patterns of stalking, coercive control or abuse
• Failure to investigate allegations proportionately or within reasonable timeframes
• Victims being advised that matters remain under investigation when cases have allegedly been closed or downgraded
• Significant delays that may prevent summary offences from reaching court within statutory time limits
• Delays in evidence gathering that may undermine opportunities to investigate allegations effectively
• Inconsistent application of legal thresholds, creating concerns regarding fairness and objectivity
• Safeguarding measures being directed towards victims rather than appropriate investigation of alleged offending behaviour
• Failure to communicate clearly with victims regarding decisions, actions and case progression
Where allegations involve stalking, coercive control, or domestic abuse, delays, failures in communication or failures in crime recording may have significant consequences for victim safety and public confidence.
Given the national importance placed on tackling violence against women and girls, these concerns warrant independent examination.
Concerns Regarding Disabled and Neurodivergent Victims
Particularly serious concerns have been raised regarding the experiences of disabled and neurodivergent individuals engaging with Derbyshire Police.
Neurodivergent people and disabled people may communicate distress differently, require reasonable adjustments, experience heightened vulnerability to abuse or face additional barriers when seeking assistance from public authorities.
Public bodies have legal and ethical obligations to ensure that disability, neurodivergence, mental health conditions, communication differences and accessibility needs do not become barriers to accessing justice.
However, reports from members of the public raise concerns that this may not always be occurring in practice.
Reported concerns include:
• Communication differences being treated as indicators of unreliability rather than recognised as disability related needs
• Distress responses being interpreted negatively rather than understood within the context of trauma, disability or neurodivergence
• Failure to provide reasonable adjustments necessary for effective participation in investigations and complaint processes
• Failure to provide intermediaries or communication support where individuals have been assessed as requiring them
• Victims being characterised as problematic, difficult or controlling after requesting adjustments or attempting to pursue concerns
• Vulnerabilities appearing to influence assessments of credibility or risk
• Safeguarding processes being used in ways that individuals perceive as punitive rather than supportive
• Failure to adequately recognise the heightened risk that disabled and neurodivergent individuals may face from coercive control, exploitation, stalking and abuse.
These concerns are especially significant because disabled women and neurodivergent women are recognised as being at increased risk of abuse, coercion, exploitation, harassment and victimisation.
Where systems fail to recognise disabilit related needs or communication differences, vulnerable individuals may be denied equal access to justice and protection.
An independent review should examine whether current policies, training and practices adequately protect disabled and neurodivergent individuals and comply with equality and safeguarding obligations.
Wider Concerns Regarding Accountability and Transparency
Members of the public have also reported concerns regarding:
• Delays or obstacles in obtaining information through Subject Access Requests
• Lack of clear explanations for key investigative decisions
• Difficulties obtaining accountability through complaints procedures
• Limited transparency when concerns are raised regarding officer conduct
• Decisions being insufficiently documented or explained
• Perceived inconsistencies between documented policies and lived experiences of complainants
• Concerns that internal review processes may not provide sufficient independence to maintain public confidence
Taken together, these concerns raise important questions about whether existing systems provide adequate transparency, accountability and protection against potential institutional failings.
What We Are Calling For
We are calling for a fully independent investigation led by a body with no operational or institutional ties to Derbyshire Police.
The investigation should examine:
• Whether systemic failures, maladministration, misconduct or cultural issues may have influenced decision making
• Whether complaint-handling processes are fair, effective and fit for purpose
• Whether victims and complainants, particularly disabled and neurodivergent individuals, receive fair and lawful treatment
• Whether violence against women and girls cases are being handled in accordance with national guidance and best practice
• Whether crime recording practices comply with national standards
• Whether safeguarding processes are being applied appropriately and consistently
• Whether accountability mechanisms are sufficient to identify and address failures
• Whether institutional structures create barriers to transparency or independent scrutiny
• Whether reforms are required to improve public confidence and prevent further harm
This petition does not presume the outcome of any investigation.
It seeks only to ensure that serious concerns raised by members of the public are examined independently, transparently and objectively.
Why This Matters
Policing depends upon public trust.
Members of the public must be able to trust that concerns will be:
• Listened to
• Recorded accurately
• Investigated fairly
• Evaluated objectively
• Communicated transparently
• Reviewed independently when necessary
When people feel ignored, dismissed, misrepresented, disbelieved or prevented from accessing justice, confidence in policing is undermined.
This is particularly concerning where the issues affect victims of stalking, coercive control, domestic abuse, sexual violence, harassment and other forms of violence against women and girls.
It is even more concerning where those affected are disabled, neurodivergent, or otherwise vulnerable and may already face significant barriers when seeking help.
No individual should be disadvantaged because they communicate differently, require reasonable adjustments, live with a disability or experience neurodivergence.
Independent scrutiny is essential not only for those who have already raised concerns, but for the wider public whose confidence depends on knowing that policing remains accountable, transparent and open to examination.
Why Independent Scrutiny Is Necessary
An independent investigation is not about assuming wrongdoing.
It is about establishing the facts.
If concerns are unfounded, an independent investigation can help restore confidence.
If concerns are substantiated, it can identify necessary reforms and ensure accountability.
Either outcome serves the public interest.
Public confidence cannot be maintained where serious and recurring concerns remain unexamined.
Transparency is not a threat to policing.
It is fundamental to public trust in policing.
What You Can Do
Sign this petition to support:
• Transparency
• Accountability
• Independent scrutiny
• Equal access to justice
• Protection of disabled and neurodivergent individuals
• Better responses to violence against women and girls
• Fair and lawful treatment of all members of the public
Every signature strengthens the call for an independent investigation into concerns that affect not only individual cases but confidence in policing across Derbyshire.
Public trust can only be maintained through transparency, accountability and independent scrutiny.

The Decision Makers


Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 14 April 2026