

Increase reward money for unsolved Flora 4 murders
The Issue

Raise the Reward. Bring Justice for the Flora Four.
Four Young Girls Were Murdered. Their Family Has Waited Nearly a Decade for Answers.
In the small, close-knit town of Flora, Indiana, four innocent young girls lost their lives in one of the state's most heartbreaking unsolved crimes. On November 21, 2016, an intentionally set fire tore through their home, claiming the lives of four sisters:
- Keyana Davis (11)
- Keyara Phillips (9)
- Kerriele McDonald (7)
- Kionnie Welch (5)
Their mother, Gaylin Rose, survived with serious injuries, but the loss of her daughters has left an immeasurable void that no family should ever have to endure.
Nearly ten years later, no one has been arrested or convicted for this horrific crime.
Despite the magnitude of this tragedy, the publicly advertised reward for information leading to an arrest has remained at just $5,000.
Four children were murdered. Their lives mattered. Their family deserves justice, and this case deserves a reward that reflects the gravity of the crime and provides a meaningful incentive for someone with critical information to finally come forward.
Why We Are Asking for Change
Rewards have played a vital role in solving cold cases by encouraging witnesses who may have been reluctant or afraid to speak. Across the United States, major homicide investigations frequently carry rewards of tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Statistics reveal that offering substantial monetary rewards can significantly enhance the chances of solving cold cases. There are documented cases where increasing a reward has generated new leads that ultimately helped solve long-unsolved crimes. For instance, in a similar unsolved case in Alabama, a reward increase from $5,000 to $40,000 resulted in new information that ultimately helped bring the perpetrators to justice. While reward money alone cannot guarantee justice, it can be the catalyst that encourages someone with the missing piece of information to finally come forward.
Across the country, rewards in major homicide investigations often reach tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.
The Flora Four deserve that same level of commitment.
This petition calls upon public officials, law enforcement agencies, Crime Stoppers organizations, private donors, businesses, foundations, and community leaders to work together to substantially increase the reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible.
Every Victim Deserves Equal Justice
Many members of the public have questioned whether this case has received the same level of urgency, investigative attention, and national awareness afforded to other high-profile child homicide cases.
The victims were four young Black girls, and it is fair to ask whether every possible investigative avenue has received the attention it deserves. If investigators have examined the possibility that racial bias or another hate-based motive played any role, the public deserves confidence that every credible lead has been thoroughly investigated.
Regardless of motive, one truth cannot be disputed:
Four innocent children were murdered, and their family still deserves justice.
Justice should never depend on race, socioeconomic status, or the community in which a victim lived. Every child deserves the same commitment, the same urgency, and the same pursuit of truth.
We respectfully call upon:
- Indiana State Police
- The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
- The U.S. Department of Justice
- The Governor of Indiana
- Crime Stoppers organizations
- Private donors, businesses, and charitable foundations
- Community leaders and elected officials
to work together to substantially increase the reward and renew public attention to this case.
Our Requests
We respectfully ask that officials and community partners:
- Increase the reward to an amount that reflects the seriousness of this crime.
- Encourage public and private contributions to expand the reward fund.
- Renew statewide and national media attention to the Flora Four case.
- Continue pursuing every investigative lead until those responsible are identified and prosecuted.
- Reaffirm that every child—regardless of race, neighborhood, or socioeconomic status—deserves the same unwavering commitment to justice.
Sign and Share
Help us send a clear message that these lives mattered.
Please join us in demanding justice for the Flora Four by signing this petition. With your support, we can bring renewed attention to this tragic case, encourage new leads, and help provide long-overdue answers for the family and the community.
Justice for the Flora Four is not only about providing answers to one grieving family—it is about demonstrating that the murder of four children will never be forgotten and never be abandoned.
Raise the reward. Renew the investigation. Bring justice to the Flora Four.

41
The Issue

Raise the Reward. Bring Justice for the Flora Four.
Four Young Girls Were Murdered. Their Family Has Waited Nearly a Decade for Answers.
In the small, close-knit town of Flora, Indiana, four innocent young girls lost their lives in one of the state's most heartbreaking unsolved crimes. On November 21, 2016, an intentionally set fire tore through their home, claiming the lives of four sisters:
- Keyana Davis (11)
- Keyara Phillips (9)
- Kerriele McDonald (7)
- Kionnie Welch (5)
Their mother, Gaylin Rose, survived with serious injuries, but the loss of her daughters has left an immeasurable void that no family should ever have to endure.
Nearly ten years later, no one has been arrested or convicted for this horrific crime.
Despite the magnitude of this tragedy, the publicly advertised reward for information leading to an arrest has remained at just $5,000.
Four children were murdered. Their lives mattered. Their family deserves justice, and this case deserves a reward that reflects the gravity of the crime and provides a meaningful incentive for someone with critical information to finally come forward.
Why We Are Asking for Change
Rewards have played a vital role in solving cold cases by encouraging witnesses who may have been reluctant or afraid to speak. Across the United States, major homicide investigations frequently carry rewards of tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Statistics reveal that offering substantial monetary rewards can significantly enhance the chances of solving cold cases. There are documented cases where increasing a reward has generated new leads that ultimately helped solve long-unsolved crimes. For instance, in a similar unsolved case in Alabama, a reward increase from $5,000 to $40,000 resulted in new information that ultimately helped bring the perpetrators to justice. While reward money alone cannot guarantee justice, it can be the catalyst that encourages someone with the missing piece of information to finally come forward.
Across the country, rewards in major homicide investigations often reach tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.
The Flora Four deserve that same level of commitment.
This petition calls upon public officials, law enforcement agencies, Crime Stoppers organizations, private donors, businesses, foundations, and community leaders to work together to substantially increase the reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible.
Every Victim Deserves Equal Justice
Many members of the public have questioned whether this case has received the same level of urgency, investigative attention, and national awareness afforded to other high-profile child homicide cases.
The victims were four young Black girls, and it is fair to ask whether every possible investigative avenue has received the attention it deserves. If investigators have examined the possibility that racial bias or another hate-based motive played any role, the public deserves confidence that every credible lead has been thoroughly investigated.
Regardless of motive, one truth cannot be disputed:
Four innocent children were murdered, and their family still deserves justice.
Justice should never depend on race, socioeconomic status, or the community in which a victim lived. Every child deserves the same commitment, the same urgency, and the same pursuit of truth.
We respectfully call upon:
- Indiana State Police
- The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
- The U.S. Department of Justice
- The Governor of Indiana
- Crime Stoppers organizations
- Private donors, businesses, and charitable foundations
- Community leaders and elected officials
to work together to substantially increase the reward and renew public attention to this case.
Our Requests
We respectfully ask that officials and community partners:
- Increase the reward to an amount that reflects the seriousness of this crime.
- Encourage public and private contributions to expand the reward fund.
- Renew statewide and national media attention to the Flora Four case.
- Continue pursuing every investigative lead until those responsible are identified and prosecuted.
- Reaffirm that every child—regardless of race, neighborhood, or socioeconomic status—deserves the same unwavering commitment to justice.
Sign and Share
Help us send a clear message that these lives mattered.
Please join us in demanding justice for the Flora Four by signing this petition. With your support, we can bring renewed attention to this tragic case, encourage new leads, and help provide long-overdue answers for the family and the community.
Justice for the Flora Four is not only about providing answers to one grieving family—it is about demonstrating that the murder of four children will never be forgotten and never be abandoned.
Raise the reward. Renew the investigation. Bring justice to the Flora Four.

The Decision Makers

Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on July 28, 2026