Hold the NFL Accountable for Postseason Officiating Standards

The Issue

In the heart-stopping final drive of the 2025 AFC Divisional Round game between the Buffalo Bills and the Denver Broncos, the Bills faced multiple penalties, adding up to an alarming 55 yards against them in the critical final minutes. In stark contrast, the Denver Broncos had only one penalty against them after regulation, which was ultimately declined.

What makes this disparity even more disheartening is a blatant missed pass interference call that saw Broncos defender Ja'Quan McMillian wrestling the ball away from Bills WR Brandin Cooks on the ground, with no flag thrown. This incident is not isolated; it's a reflection of a disturbing pattern of biased officiating that many Buffalo fans have noticed in postseason games. 

The integrity of the game is at stake. Fans invest not just their money, but their trust and passion in supporting their teams, and such discrepancies drain the spirit of fair competition. It's essential for the credibility of the NFL that all teams, including the Buffalo Bills, get an equal and fair chance to compete without the shadow of biased officiating.

This petition aims to urge the National Football League to conduct a thorough investigation into postseason officiating involving not only the Buffalo Bills, but the entire league as well, along with implementing changes to ensure transparent and unbiased officiating.

We propose the following actionable solutions:

1. An independent review board to oversee officiating decisions in postseason games, ensuring accountability and transparency.
2. Mandatory training sessions for referees on bias awareness and impartiality, emphasizing the importance of fair play.
3. Allowing teams to challenge non-called penalties past regulation to ensure critical mistakes are addressed on-field.

By signing this petition, you're advocating for fairness, accountability, and the sanctity of competitive sports. Let's come together to demand a level playing field for all teams.

avatar of the starter
Connor FieldPetition StarterA generic person living in the Greater Buffalo metropolitan area.

1

The Issue

In the heart-stopping final drive of the 2025 AFC Divisional Round game between the Buffalo Bills and the Denver Broncos, the Bills faced multiple penalties, adding up to an alarming 55 yards against them in the critical final minutes. In stark contrast, the Denver Broncos had only one penalty against them after regulation, which was ultimately declined.

What makes this disparity even more disheartening is a blatant missed pass interference call that saw Broncos defender Ja'Quan McMillian wrestling the ball away from Bills WR Brandin Cooks on the ground, with no flag thrown. This incident is not isolated; it's a reflection of a disturbing pattern of biased officiating that many Buffalo fans have noticed in postseason games. 

The integrity of the game is at stake. Fans invest not just their money, but their trust and passion in supporting their teams, and such discrepancies drain the spirit of fair competition. It's essential for the credibility of the NFL that all teams, including the Buffalo Bills, get an equal and fair chance to compete without the shadow of biased officiating.

This petition aims to urge the National Football League to conduct a thorough investigation into postseason officiating involving not only the Buffalo Bills, but the entire league as well, along with implementing changes to ensure transparent and unbiased officiating.

We propose the following actionable solutions:

1. An independent review board to oversee officiating decisions in postseason games, ensuring accountability and transparency.
2. Mandatory training sessions for referees on bias awareness and impartiality, emphasizing the importance of fair play.
3. Allowing teams to challenge non-called penalties past regulation to ensure critical mistakes are addressed on-field.

By signing this petition, you're advocating for fairness, accountability, and the sanctity of competitive sports. Let's come together to demand a level playing field for all teams.

avatar of the starter
Connor FieldPetition StarterA generic person living in the Greater Buffalo metropolitan area.
Support now

1


The Decision Makers

Roger Goodell
Roger Goodell
National Football League Commissioner
Petition updates
Share this petition
Petition created on January 17, 2026