Alex KingRotherfield, ENG, United Kingdom
Aug 4, 2019

Hello everybody,

I hope you’re all having a lovely Sunday. I wanted to spend a little of mine updating you on a couple of things.

First: the status of the petition.

Surprisingly, Google have yet to contact me with a response of any kind after I handed over our signatures outside their office in London at the end of May. I’ve been mulling over what this means for the voices of over 130,000 people (customers, no less!) and what our next steps should be. Please do contact me with your thoughts, reflections or ideas – awjking@gmail.com.

Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ ethos appears not to legislate for the minor social evil of failing to respond to a message from 131,869 individuals. Meanwhile, the tax avoidance strategy that has seen Google dodge a £1.5bn tax bill in the UK - cash that could pay for 60,000 NHS nurses, remember – evidently extends to stubborn avoidance of the issue entirely.

I’m actually emboldened by this second tier of avoidance. It means that this is a tough subject for Google’s PR strategists to engage with. One can only speculate, of course, but their silence suggests a collar-teasing hope that this will all blow over, and Google’s brand will come out of this ‘blip’ unscathed. I can assure you, I won’t let that happen.

Second: Google’s splashing the cash

One of the chief counter-arguments I hear when I mention our campaign to friends and colleagues runs along the following lines:

“But Google use that cash to invest in new technologies that people around the world – including you - can use for free! And they’re doing loads of good stuff for charity…”

Guilty as charged, you’ll see from the email address provided above that I use Google’s free products myself – and I’m sure most of you do, too. As it’s Sunday, I’ll spare you a long-winded deconstruction of the "But Google Use That Cash..." argument. I’ll just say that its flawed logic implies that we should favour unaccountable and undemocratic corporate social justice over that provided by the state.

What does this corporate social justice look like, though? How does Google spend excess cash on social issues?

Well, a reported £16.5m has been spent by the company on this year’s ‘Camp Google’ – a three-day ‘summit’ of A-list celebrities on the southwest coast of Sicily. The secretive and glamorous gathering is this year discussing the environment and climate change. The celebrities’ journeys to the island, on yachts and private jets, is estimated to have released 100,000kg of CO2 into the atmosphere.

Spent instead on carbon offsetting, the £16.5m Google splashed out on Camp Google would offset a huge 2,200,000,000kg of CO2 in the earth’s atmosphere. It could otherwise pay for 660 nurses, or roughly half of a new-build hospital in the UK.

This is what unaccountable, pick-and-choose corporate social responsibility looks like: a jet-setting contingent of billionaires dipping into the azure waters of social responsibility when it suits them, while elected representatives miss out on the tax revenue required to serve the people transparently, responsibly and - most importantly - in a way that's accountable to us, the public.

Let's continue this campaign to ensure corporations don't see their own social initiatives - whatever they may be - as more pressing than those policies that governments are elected upon.

Warm regards to you all,

Alex King

Member, United Citizens