ELCA: Stop Discriminating Against Trans People

1,249

The Issue

Decision Makers: Bishop Eaton Bishop.Eaton@elca.org – ELCA Advocacy advocacy.domestic@elca.org 

Story:

The Evangelical Lutheran Church of America’s inclusion of transgender, gender nonconforming, and intersex (TGNCI) persons has been marked by continued failure to address the needs and personhood of TGNCI individuals. 

Transgender parishioners and clergy in the ELCA continue to get misgendered (referring to an individual as a gender or with pronouns they do not claim for themselves), excluded from ministry opportunities, turned down for internships and calls by ELCA churches (including by Reconciling in Christ communities who have committed to being open to calling transgender ministers), the placing of additional burdens on transgender candidates for both Word and Sacrament and Word and Service candidacy, and the refusal of the ELCA to apologize for the decades of discrimination, harmful rhetoric, and inaction over the last forty years. The inaction of the ELCA during the height of the AIDS epidemic is present in the denomination today as they refuse to actively work with TGNCI Christians and organizations to stand against the onslaught of anti-transgender bills sweeping across the nation (currently 150 and counting).

Despite maintaining a policy that “all are welcome” this welcoming, which has seen expansion since the 2009 decision to ordain gay men and lesbian women, continues to exclude transgender people as both parishioners and clergy. Program director for faith practice and missional development, Rev. Brenda Smith said, in a 2016 article for Living Lutheran “All are welcome: Pastors and members break down the not-so-simple concept of welcoming” by Wendy Healy, “The new reality is that people are beginning to understand that ‘all are welcome’ means that all are welcome—regardless of race, color, creed, age, ethnicity, knowledge of Christ and sexual orientation.” A diverse list of those who are welcomed, with a glaring omission of TGNCI people. Even if TGNCI people are included under the term “sexual orientation” the statement displays a glaring misunderstanding of transgender lives and needs.

Given both the inaction of the ELCA on broader issues impacting the transgender community and their inability to effectively respect and honor the lives of TGNCI individuals within their denomination, we are calling on all LGBTQIA2S+ people and our allies to write to Presiding Bishop Elizabeth Eaton and the ELCA Advocacy staff and demand that Churchwide Assembly, Church Council, Conference of Bishops and elected churchwide officers:

  1. openly and honestly address their continued discrimination against transgender parishioners and clergy; 
  2. begin the process of reforming the wording and intent of governing documents to make certain the language is both inclusive of TGNCI people; and
  3. directly condemns both transphobia and transmisia within the denomination as a sin.

We ask that the ELCA engage in the process of reparations which would take the forms of:

  1. direct and specific apology for the decades of neglect and active harm perpetuated by the ELCA on both the TGNCI community and the LGBTQIA2S+ community more broadly;
  2. re-evaluate rejected transgender candidates for potential entrance;
  3. commit to examining the call process for bias;
  4. develop clear procedures and responses when reporting transphobic harassment and bullying;
  5. amend the governing documents so TGNCI people can vote and be appointed to assemblies and other committees where participation has been divided into male/female so as not to deny voice to nonbinary individuals; and
  6. intentionally lift TGNCI voices in both Churchwide Assembly conferences and publications.

It is our hope that through the Spirit-lead work of advocacy and reparations it will be made clear to the ELCA governing body that the harassment, exclusion, and neglect of TGNCI people runs counter to the message of Christ who commanded that we love one another as he loved us (John 13:34)—self-sacrificially through acts of mercy, service, and inclusion.

We, the undersigned, want to help the ELCA reform through the intentional inclusion of transgender, gender non-conforming, and intersex (TGNCI) people.

We, the undersigned, want to help the ELCA as a denomination and Christianity as a whole grow through the resources and insight TGNCI people bring with their lived experience.

We, the undersigned, want to help the ELCA embody the serenity and call to authenticity that those justified by grace through faith have inherited, the courage to work with G-d as co-partners in creation, and the collective wisdom full-participation adds in richness and insight into our understanding of the incarnation, transfiguration, and resurrection of Christ.

The Decision Makers

Bishop Eaton
Bishop of the ELCA

Petition Updates