Petitioning International Labour Organization and 38 others

Dubai Health Authority deporting residents (Non TB persons) based on fake testing - Exposed


Overview : March 2013, I received employment in a law firm in D.I.F.C. (Dubai International Financial Centre), when I appeared for medical test at al Muhaisna medical centre (A part of Dubai Health Authority), suspected that i have old T.B scar and I was deported immediately without given, a right to appeal.

India's well known government hospitals i.e A.I.I.M.S (All India Institute of Medical Sciences) hospital at New Delhi and L.R.S -  Super specialty TB Hospital conducted checkups i.e. Skin test ( Mantoux ) twice, Chest x-ray, Blood test, Sputum test and a Chest C.T Scan.

20th January 2014 and 22nd January 2014, most recent test reports conducted from two different Pathological labs for the same test on different dates i.e. Quantiferon Tb Gold test (specially designed for detecting latent or old tuberculosis) are also Negative. 

Test results : Based on my test reports, each hospital issued me the fitness certificate stating zero evidence of tuberculosis in my body.

A)  X-rays cannot detect old TB : There are more than 40 reasons for lung scarring.

Here is the evidence :  proves it false. 

B) Blood test cannot detect old TB: Mantoux test or Skin Test or P.P.D test (wikipaedia),

Here is the evidence : proves it false.

Clearly mentions, Mantoux test results can be false positive(50-50).

Doctors are paid to hide this fact since their salary meter is ON and 95% deportation happens on number one fake test i.e Mantoux test for your information.

Why its happening in UAE?

Otherwise, why these tests are not allowed in US, UK, Canada, Sweden, Switzerland like educated countries. 

C)  Quantiferon TB Gold cannot detect old TB :  Quantiferon Gold test seems accurate in results, but this test also shows false positive results.

Here is the evidence : proves it false.

Another proof :- Quantiferon Gold test done again in 2015, now it comes negative (G.C.C. Approved Authority). Mantoux test comes positive .So you can judge the accuracy of these tests very well.

D)  Useless test for Old TB detection : Sputum test can only detect active TB , so it is completely impotent. 99 out of 100 comes negative. 

 Ironically, after our petition, online posts and local awareness , D.H.A doctors again admitted their mistake, stating that this scar can be due to other reasons as well. In 2013, they used to judge it as just Old TB scar. 

As per my knowledge and experience, its nothing more than clear-cut cheating patients by doing fake testing, in my case it was manipulation of test reports agreed by D.H.A on an email conversation with me and there are other malpractices done by D.H.A behind the curtain, that i can disclose on special requests.

Mantoux test and Quantiferon Gold test done in two different semesters for myself are giving wrong results.This time both tests are showing near to false positive. Wikipedia is correct but doctors in Gulf countries are doing wrong by hiding this information. 

Any person without lung scar or never had old or active TB in his life , his test reports will show positive results. Try Mantoux and Quantiferon 2-3 times you will know the secret facts.

Conclusion : Hence proved, Dubai health authority is performing tests which are undeveloped and immature. Doctors should first try it twice on their own body. 100% confirm they will find old TB in their body.


International organisations do not recognize these tests to confirm some one's medical illness in the past. 

As per chest specialists, there is no medicine invented that can remove these scars. Chest specialist confirms that scars goes on its own, as per them,there are lot of cases wherein scars disappeared after couple of months or years on case to case basis.

Suggestion : If you do not have active tuberculosis and the hospital forces you to take TB medicines, please do not accept it . It has severe side effects on your healthy body. Unless you have active TB or severe situation.

Case of Discrimination : health/deportation-laws-reform-lies-dormant clearly mentioned by Dr. Mario Raviglione [Director at W.H.O), this is absolute discrimination.

Comments : Until you are in U.A.E, you have the right to cross examine and argue with your doctors, human rights and news media are the only medicine for victims, based on the information given in this petition. Doctors cannot force you, contrarily they are admitting their judgements. There are many cases where in deportation was stopped. 

Collectively, doctors in G.C.C are now planning to change this policy for once and all. 

Sincerely yours,

 Charanjeet Singh

Letter to
International Labour Organization
Joint Secretary PSP & CPO Hon’ble Shri Muktesh Kumar Pardeshi
(M.O.H)-United Arab Emirates Ministry of Health
and 36 others
Assistant Director General(Department of Tourism) Hon'ble Shri D.Venkatesh
Consulate General Hon'ble Shri Sanjay Verma
JS [AD] Hon’ble Shri Anup K. Mudgal
The Acting Minister- Ministry of Health - United Arab Emirates Hon'ble Abdul Rahman Mohammed Al Owais
International Human Rights Funders Group
Director ( Emigration Services ) Shri Rajiv Wadhawan
Protector General of Emigrants & Joint Secretary (Emigration Services Division) Shri Ruolkhumlien Buhril, IAS
President of United Arab Emirates & Ruler of Abu Dhabi Hon'ble Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan
OHCHR United Nations Human Rights
Board of Directors Unfoundation
IOM Headquarters International Organization for Migration
HAAD (Health Authority - Abu Dhabi) United Arab Emirates
Chief Reporter BBC News
Chief Reporter India Today Group
D.H.A - United Arab Emirates Dubai Health Authority
Joint Secretary & L.A.(Department of Legal Affairs) Hon’ble Shri D. Bhardwaj
Prime Minister of India Hon’ble Dr. Manmohan Singh
Director of Stop TB department - WHO Hon’ble Dr. Mario Raviglione
Embassy of United Arab Emirates Ambassador's Office
Embassy of United Arab Emirates Consulate's Office
Right to Information
Human Rights Commission - CEO
Human Rights Watch
Country Information UNAIDS
Principal Secretary to LG Hon’ble Smt. Nutan Guha Biswas
Minister of Overseas Indian Affairs Hon’ble Shri Vayalar Ravi
Govt. of NCT of Delhi Hon’ble Smt. Sheila Dikshit
Director of Public Grievances Hon’ble Secretary
Cabinet Secretary Hon’ble Shri Ajit Kumar Seth
Minister for Law and Justice Hon’ble Shri Kapil Sibbal
External Affair Minister Hon’ble Shri Salman Khurshid
Cheif Secretary of Delhi Hon’ble Shri Deepak Mohan Spolia
Prime Minister of United Arab Emirates Hon’ble Sheikh Mohammad
Case of Intentional Medical Malpractice,Corruption,Discrimination and shuffling of medical reports in Dubai health Authority.