Petition the US Government to restrict human/animal hybrid (chimera) research

Petition Closed

This petition had 64 supporters

The Issue

"Every ten minutes, a person is added to the national waiting list for organ transplants. And every day, 22 people on that list die without the organ they need. What if, rather than relying on a generous donor, you could grow a custom organ inside an animal instead?" (National)

Thus opens the National Geographic article on the first successful human-pig hybrid embryo, published on January 26, 2017.

Human-animal hybrids -- called "chimeras" -- are an ethical problem for the scientific community. Thousands of articles debating the ethics of chimera research appear under Google scholar, using only the free and public medical file search. It is unfathomable how many more debates on its ethical implication might take place in private within the scientific community.

Petition the United States government to restrict or even ban human-chimera research.

Following is a very brief argument for the petition, and against the acceptability of chimera research by the US Government, as the civic guardian of citizen freedoms and stonewall against dangers to society.

 

I. What is a chimera?

A chimera is defined by livescience.com as "a single organism that consists of cells from two or more individuals — that is, it contains two sets of DNA, with the code to make two separate organisms, somewhere within it."

 

 

II. Why are chimeras allowed?

Currently, science permits it primarily under the premise it is necessary in order to provide services which will better the lives of human beings: the achieved good (above) is greater than the perceived evil of combining a human being with an animal, to create a single living, breathing organism.

Organ donation is at the forefront of these arguments. If science could create a pig which grew human organs, the organs from this pig could be harvested and given to people who might otherwise die as a result of waiting for an organ donation from a human being.

Despite its supposed necessity, even bioethicists are concerned about its implications:

"There's also great concern about the level of human-animal mixing that might result in animals that are not 100-percent animal and not 100-percent human. We may be flirting with an area of human dignity that we just do not want to cross, even if the scientific value of the work may be quite high." (Insoo Hyun, a professor of bioethics and philosophy at Case Western Reserve University, in an interview with NPR news on chimera research).

 

III. Why is "chimeras are necessary for organ donation and human life enhancements" a groundless argument?

The organ shortage problem was nearly solved by the advent of 3-D printers. In 2014, CNN ran an article addressing the future of 3D printers and suggested that it was almost scientifically certain that, soon, 3D printers would be able to print human organs (click here to read the article).

On Feb. 13, 2016, Quartz Media ran an article about Wake Forest's success with 3D organ printing:

"Researchers at Wake Forest University in North Carolina say they have created a 3D printer that can produce organs, tissues, and bones that could theoretically be implanted into living humans. The group’s work was published in the scientific journal Nature Biotechnology today."

"It’s worth noting that the Wake Forest researchers aren’t the only ones researching bioprinting like this. Todd Goldstein, a researcher at the Feinstein Institute for Medical Research at Northwell Health, told Quartz that 'this [3D organ printing] isn’t completely novel.' Goldstein is currently working on 3D printing human cells to use in implantable tracheas." 

In this article, Goldstein indicated that their process was achieving incredibly quality results in the organs produced. 

Quartz media and other media outlets who have reported on the subject indicate that there are many more individuals and research groups who have achieved remarkable success in 3D organ printing, as well, despite it not being perfected...yet.

Given this evidence, Chimera research is unnecessary with the advent of 3D organ printing.

It is worth considering that 3D organ printing - a principle applicable to nearly any organ or tissue within the human body - might be more quickly perfected if the funds going to chimera experiments were redirected to 3D organ printing research.

 

IV. Chimeras are not progressive for the greater Good of the human race

The world at large considers these scientific advancements as breaking progress for humankind. However, this is not the case:

In the 1920s the Soviet biologist Ilya Ivanovich Ivanov carried out a series of experiments to create a human/non human ape hybrid (called a "humanzee"). At first working with human sperm and chimpanzee females, none of his attempts created a pregnancy. In 1929 he organized a set of experiments involving non human ape sperm and human volunteers, but was delayed by the death of his last orangutan. The next year he fell under political criticism from the Soviet government and was sentenced to exile in the Kazakh SSR; he worked there at the Kazakh Veterinary-Zootechnical Institute and died of a stroke two years later. To read more about Ivanov's work, click here.

Ivanov is one of many scientists who have tried his hand at chimera research and developed through the ages. Other scientists under Hitler, in Nazi Germany, were also pursuing this kind of research, until it failed.

Human-animal hybrid research is nothing new, certainly nothing progressive, and certainly nothing truly necessary to advance the greater good of the human race, as advocates of chimera research claim.

 

 

V. Law and the human person -- and the chimera

1 U.S. Code § 8 protects any human infant born-alive as a person, and fetology defines a human person as beginning when cells fuse at conception at begin the process of development in-utero, we must ask whether or not chimera embryos with developing human tissue are considered human, or not. 

Rationally, "human being-ness" and "personhood" cannot have "grey" areas. There cannot be "more" of a person, or "less" of a person, as this violates much of the laws that define both physical and immaterial reality -- in the hard sciences, and in philosophy. More of less of a human being is reminiscent of the 3/5 person principle in early America, which said slaves counted as only part of a person.

Dr. Nathanson’s (founder of NARAL) study of developments in the science of fetology eventually led him to admit that life began at conception and that human life was not a vague concept, but a material reality that began with the fusing of the sperm and the egg.

However, human cells are also considered "living", despite an individual human life being describe under fetology as when egg and sperm fuse. If human cells (even if they are not egg and sperm) are grafted into other cells which then, upon combination, generate life bearing human DNA and characteristics to the degree that it is scientifically part "human", it stands to reason that this new organism possesses a human "life", despite being generated in a lab, under contrived conditions, to meet an expedient need.

If these organisms are human, it is only reasonable to conclude these lab-spawned "human lives", despite bearing animal characteristics, posses equal rights under the United States Constitution and Bill of Rights, which does not discriminate between the fortunate, and the unfortunate. 

Human Dignity is a necessary component of all legal and social rights. The "God of Nature" referenced by the founding fathers is considered an explicit reference to the objective order found in nature. The founding fathers believed, according to historians, that the rights they enshrined in the founding documents were present in the objective nature of the human person, not conferred by government.

If the government is willing to not afford these lab-created human lives -- despite having animal DNA -- such rights, the US Government could be guilty of legal discrimination, and of permitting scientific experiments on viable, valuable, legally-validated human life.

The potential for abuse of all chimera research and creation is too high to allow it to continue without severe regulation and severe government oversight. Perhaps, even, to continue it at all, given its inherently unethical nature.

Petition the United States government to restrict and/or ban human-chimera research due to it being unethical, unnecessary, and contrary to the rights given to human life under the Bill of Rights in the constitution, and a violation of human dignity by signing the petition and passing it on.

By signing this petition, you are agreeing to several things:

1. That chimera research and creation has a grave potential to be highly unethical and should be subject to government investigation, if not permanently stopped.

2. That the stated primary needs met by chimera research and creation -- organ donation -- is closer to being met by 3D printing than by chimera research and creation (CR&C), and therefore CR&C is not a necessary service.

3. That harvesting organs out of "animals" is an unethical principle at the cost of appropriate animal husbandry and even scientific treatment of animals as test subjects.

4. That chimera research and creation violates the essential principle of human dignity that the founding fathers of the America Republic recognized as objective found in human beings, and further conformed to by subsequent leaders of our nation - leaders like Washington and Lincoln, the latter being someone who brought the concept of human dignity to one of the most oppressed group of people in American history.

5. That all chimera research and creation ought to be brought to an immediate halt by the US Government until its ethicality and necessity for the greater good of the human race are both either guaranteed or dismissed. By allowing it to continue unregulated and unreported on, the U.S. Government as a body is potentially allowing abuse of human lives.

Please sign the petition and pass it on. Contact your representatives. Be the change, and do not be silent through fear.

 

More sources and resources for more information:

National Geographic: Human-Pig Hybrid Created in the Lab—Here Are the Facts
​

http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/08/07/489082005/the-chimera-quandary-is-it-ethical-to-create-hybrid-embryos

 

avatar of the starter
Kathryn EPetition Starter

The Decision Makers

Mike Pence
Former Governor - Indiana
Donald J. Trump
Donald J. Trump
Former President of the United States

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on January 26, 2017