Demand transparency from Cornell University on essay punishments

57

Let’s get to 100 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

In 2023, a shocking incident shook the Cornell University community that highlighted an unsettling disparity in how justice is served on campuses nationwide. Among the Cornell 7, individuals accused of grievous sexual offenses, two were expelled—a decision not even reflecting the gravity of their alleged actions. And disturbingly, others were merely tasked with writing essays as punishment for actions that carry significant weight. How is it justifiable or equitable that the gravity of a crime as severe as sexual assault is deemed payable with an essay? These perpetrators avoided the burden of criminal charges through questionable leniency.

As someone profoundly concerned with justice and equity, I call into question the integrity of disciplinary procedures where such actions are met with vastly inconsistent repercussions. The double standard, or more accurately, multi-level standards divided by sex, class, and race, are undeniably glaring. Sexual assault is a crime that shatters lives and robs individuals of their dignity and security. It is not an act that can be "accidentally" perpetrated; it demands the utmost accountability from the individuals who commit it, and yet, we observe in this case a striking departure from justice and consequence.

It is imperative that the Cornell community and the public be granted access to these essays. Transparency in these matters is crucial. Every individual should have the opportunity to read the essays that have apparently mitigated the charges against these individuals. What could possibly be argued within those pages that deems their actions worthy of anything less than severe sanctioning?

By demanding to see these essays, we aim to shed light on a system that appears to value narrative over justice, potentially allowing dangerous precedents to be set. We must stand firm against such disparities and advocate for a system where punitive measures are commensurate with infractions of such gravity.

We urge the administration of Cornell University to release these essays in the spirit of transparency and accountability. Let the public knowledge of what constitutes a sufficient "punishment" for such actions inform crucial discussions around reform and justice. We wish to not only read these essays on our own, but also GRADE THEM OURSELVES AND POST THOSE GRADES PUBLICLY. 

Join us in our call for transparency and reform. Sign this petition to demand the release of these essays now and to support a future where justice is truly served and not circumvented.

The Decision Makers

Anne Meinig Smalling
Anne Meinig Smalling
Chair of Cornell University board of Trustees

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates