Petition updateCall for Accountability at MPB Parish and School-Please keep comments civil and productive

Follow-Up Letter Delivered to Archbishop Aquila

MPB Independent Community GroupDenver, CO, United States
Aug 15, 2025

Here is the letter we have sent to the Archbishop in response to his correspondence last week regarding the petition. We encourage all who feel compelled to reach out to the Archdiocese with your own perspective as well.

————————————————————

August 15, 2025

Dear Archbishop Aquila,

Thank you for your response to the concerns raised by the petition from the Most Precious Blood community. We agree with you that a parish is more than an institution; as you stated, it is meant to be a “stable spiritual community” where we encounter God and bring the love of God to our neighbors. As we have tried to communicate in our petition, our community has regrettably not experienced stability over the last several years. Almost our entire parish staff, more than half of our school faculty, and greater than a third of our student enrollment have left our community since Father Daniel became our pastor.

Although you are correct that we have waited until this year to publicly raise our concerns via this petition, we have been far from silent over the last several years. As the petition states, many of us have tried to communicate our concerns to Father Daniel over the last four years, only to be met with dismissive and belittling responses. On some occasions, Father Daniel has gone as far as mocking and criticizing the feedback he has received from parishioners and school families in homilies during Mass or on posts on his personal social media page, including public responses to this petition.

Additionally, over the last few years, some of us have written directly to the Archdiocese with feedback similar to concerns raised in the petition. In regard to your concern over the anonymity of the petition, please know that this petition was created by current, active, and devoted members of the MPB school and parish. The petition now includes over 700 signatures of people who have shared their full names on the change.org platform. We are aware of many other current parishioners, school parents,and staff members who agree with the sentiments of the petition but are afraid to sign their names due to fear of negative consequences for them or their families, or due to a belief that no meaningful changes will result from the petition.

As we stated in the petition, we feel there has been a loss of "psychological safety" at MPB. Staff , parishioners, and parents do not feel empowered or comfortable sharing concerns, for fear of a vengeful orcondescending response. We pray that you reconsider the Archdiocese’s policy regarding anonymous feedback and consider other ways you can verify concerns, particularly when there is a stated fear for loss of psychological safety.

We would also like to respond to your call for feedback from current members of the MPB community only. While we wholeheartedly agree this is valuable, we would also encourage you to consider seeking feedback from parishioners, school families, and employees who have recently left the parish and school. Many longstanding and actively involved members of our community have left recently due to the concerns raised in the petition, and their voices deserve to be heard, as well.

We agree with you that Father Daniel is a good man who sincerely desires to lead the MPB community well. We greatly appreciate the gift of the priesthood and Father Daniel’s faithful dedication to his vocation. The purpose of our petition is to state clearly that his pastoral leadership style, despite good intentions, has not been effective. Instead of uniting us as one community in Christ, his words and actions have divided us, hurt us, made us feel our feedback is not welcome or valuable, disparaged longstanding traditions and ministries we have cherished, and has consistently driven us away.

We therefore implore you again to consider supporting our request for meaningful dialogue, in the spirit of genuine synodality, over a listening session facilitated by a representative from the Archdiocese, where parishioners, school families, and staff members can openly and respectfully express their concerns. While we appreciate that Father Daniel has organized upcoming parish listening sessions in response to the petition, we feel that a representative from the Archdiocese being present and a Synod-like structure, with small groups composed of a cross section of MPB community members who can safely offer their perspectives, would be more productive.

Please also consider supporting Father Daniel in improving his leadership and communication approaches with formal guidance, perhaps by way of a professional leadership consultant who can offer him objective feedback on the ways in which he shepherds his flock.

Thank you for taking the time to listen to our heartfelt concerns. We pray that our petition, this follow-up letter, and your next response will lead to a period of renewal and growth at MPB, centered on our Eucharistic call to encounter Christ in His Most Precious Body and Blood, our community’s namesake. We pray that we can once again come together as a united and stable community that brings the love of God to all we meet. And on this Feast of the Assumption, may Our Blessed Mother Mary intercede for our community and, as she so beautifully and often does, bring us closer to Jesus and to one another.

Respectfully in Christ,

Concerned Members of the MPB Community