Ban the creation of AI images at Xaverian College

491

Let’s get to 500 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

What do I want this petition to achieve?

If this petition receives 500 signatures, it will be presented to Mr Knowles, the principal of Xaverian College. I hope he will then consider implementing a ban on staff generating images with AI. Every signature counts: the more I have, the better it is!

Why should we stop generating AI images at college?

Images created by generative AI are being repeatedly and needlessly used at Xaverian College in emails, posters, and art. 

The use of generative AI to create images is extremely detrimental to the environment: data centre electricity demand could be 11x higher in 2030 than in 2023 unless governments intervene. It uses massive amounts of water and energy, and is massively disruptive to the wildlife and people who live close to data centres. It is also used to create illegal and unethical content by some people. By creating images using AI, the college is contributing to this environmental destruction and further training the AI models to produce this content, even if it is indirectly. Furthermore, it puts many artists out of jobs, and reduces opportunities for young artists (such as the art students at college) to showcase their work.

The college should not be using a tool that is directly detrimental to the future and safety of the 3400+ students it teaches.

The use of generative AI images directly contrasts the ethos of compassion at Xaverian. It is a Catholic college, however it contradicts Pope Leo XIV's public denouncement of AI. Surely people of any or no faith can agree with his statement that calls for us to stop our acceleration towards “losing [our] humanity” and destroying our planet. Why do we fight climate change, by volunteering in Sri Lanka and working with CAFOD to raise money for Bangladeshi farming communities, whilst simultaneously accelerating it?

Furthermore, many students agree that creating AI images of important figures such as activists celebrated in Black History Month, and religious figures, is incredibly disrespectful. Surely using AI, instead of art or photographs produced by humans, is counterintuitive when these people all represent a fight for peace and equality.

Aside from the direct impact of AI images, there are also less direct consequences. Images generated by AI regularly contain inaccuracies such as a nonsense map on a chaplaincy email, incorrect information in learning materials, and odd looking photos with incorrect anatomy/spellings and weird errors. These images are also look noticeably AI generated and low quality. Instead of generating them with AI, images should instead be sourced from the internet, or created by some of the many talented artists at Xaverian.

Examples of where students have noticed generative AI images being used at Xaverian:

  • a poster for an art competition at the start of the 2025/2026 academic year
  • emails from the chaplaincy
  • until this week (16/11/26), computer backgrounds
  • poster for a creative arts talk
  • Black History Month displays

 Some examples of these will be attached at the bottom of this petition over time.

Why only images, and not all AI generated material?

It is not only the creation of AI images that have negative consequences. Many students complain of having to analyse AI generated poems in English Literature as homework, having AI generated history booklets full of factual errors, and being set AI generated homework that has nothing to do with what they are supposed to be learning in class.

However, the students at Xaverian appreciate the immense time and effort teachers put into their work, and are aware of the ever increasing demands on their time. Whilst a total generative AI ban would be ideal, I understand that this may substantially increase the workload of teachers to an unmanageable amount. Additionally, I understand that AI is often encouraged as a teaching tool, and it may be unavoidable. Therefore, I feel that a ban of AI generated images is a more reasonable request. Hopefully teachers will ensure they are mindful of their AI usage, and perhaps the use of AI at Xaverian can be reconsidered in the future.

What changes can you make in your lives to avoid generative AI?

  • Switch to the Ecosia search engine, where AI overview can be disabled. And, their AI overview reportedly is one of the more sustainable models.
  • Choose not to support places using generative AI where possible.
  • Advocate for human artists on social media, in who you choose to employ/promote, and what content you engage with.
  • Educate others (parents, friends, coworkers) about the harms of generative AI!

Links to read more:

BBC: AI data centres could undermine UK's emissions goals (November 2026)

Greenpeace: The energy and environmental impact of AI and how it undermines democracy (April 2026)

BBC: Pope warns against 'losing humanity' to AI machines (September 2026)

Met Police: Man sentenced after using AI to create explicit images of children (September 2026)

BBC: Child abuse survivor alleges Grok used photos of her to generate new illegal images (September 2026)

 

Examples of some AI generated images at Xaverian:

AI map of Manchester that does not make sense.

The Decision Makers

Xaverian College

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates