Ask WYSO to End Its Reliance on BBC News

125

Let’s get to 200 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

We're asking WYSO to eliminate BBC News content from WYSO's programming and replace it with other independent news sourcing the community can trust to be fair and accurate.

WYSO has earned its reputation as a pillar of the Miami Valley through a commitment to accurate, balanced journalism and community oriented programming. But WYSO's international coverage is currently delivered through the BBC, and the BBC's own reporting on Israel/Gaza is now the subject of serious, documented concern from within its own newsroom.

In November 2024, more than 100 BBC staff members — joined by over 300 other media professionals, historians, and public figures — signed an open letter to the BBC's Director-General accusing the network of “failing to uphold a basic journalistic tenet” in its coverage of Gaza, and calling on it to “recommit to fairness, accuracy, and due impartiality.” Some signatories said colleagues had resigned over the network's coverage. The BBC has also faced criticism from outlets like Declassified UK and independent journalists such as Owen Jones, and from former BBC staff — including researcher Karishma Patel, who has spoken publicly about internal editorial pressure.

 “Why I Walked Away From the BBC” — Karishma Patel: youtube.com/shorts/Za03cH8qiis

“'National scandal': The BBC's Gaza cover-up” — Mark Curtis: declassifieduk.org

“BBC staff: we're forced to do pro-Israel PR” — Owen Jones: owenjones.news

When a broadcaster's own staff say they can't trust their organization's coverage, that's not a fringe complaint — it's a signal a partner station should act on, not absorb without question. WYSO has built its credibility on holding itself to a higher standard than what it's currently rebroadcasting.

We're asking WYSO to drop BBC News from its programming and commit to international/independent news sourcing that meets the same editorial standard WYSO applies to its own local reporting.

[Edit]
A new study from "Middle East Monitor" that provides more proof that the BBC should no longer be considered a trusted source of professional, honest, Journalism.

"BBC presenters put Israel’s case in 252 interviews but the Palestinian case in only 15, study finds.

BBC News presenters repeatedly put Israel’s position to guests who criticised its conduct in Gaza, but rarely put the Palestinian position to guests who defended Israel, a new study of three years of the corporation’s coverage of the Gaza genocide has found.

The study, BBC: The Would Say Files, was published on 5 November by the media monitoring platform NewsCord and written by Nima Akram. It examined broadcast interviews and written articles from October 2023 to this month. 

The researchers searched the subtitles of more than 51,000 BBC News channel programmes for phrases such as ‘Israel would say’, then checked each result by hand to confirm that a presenter was putting one side’s position to a guest from the other side.

 
 

Of 267 such interviews, BBC presenters put Israel’s case to critics of Israel in 252. They put the Palestinian case to Israel’s defenders in 15. The plainest form, “Israel would say”, was put to critics in 75 interviews, while “Palestinians would say”, or the same phrase naming any Palestinian group, was put to defenders in four.

NewsCord has compiled clips of these exchanges to show the scale of the gap. Its compilation of BBC presenters putting Israel’s case runs to 48 minutes and 12 seconds. The compilation of presenters putting the Palestinian case runs to 2 minutes and 38 seconds.

The study also found that the Palestinian case almost disappeared from BBC interviews after the first weeks of the genocide. Ten of the 15 cases came in the six weeks after 7 October 2023, and only five in the three years that followed. Presenters were still putting Israel’s case to its critics in 2026. NewsCord says this points to an editorial shift, in which the BBC stopped conveying what Palestinians were saying but continued to tell audiences what “Israel would say”.

The same imbalance appeared in the BBC’s written coverage. In 1,618 articles, when the BBC reported criticism of Israel’s conduct in Gaza, it added Israel’s position 49 per cent of the time (1,771 of 3,648 claims). When it reported Israel’s claims, it added a Palestinian or UN position 38 per cent of the time (914 of 2,431), and a Palestinian position alone only 25 per cent of the time.

The gap was wider when the researchers compared official sources. When the authorities in Gaza made a claim against Israel, the BBC added Israel’s response 58 per cent of the time (334 of 575). When the Israeli government or army made a claim, it added a Palestinian or UN position 39 per cent of the time (855 of 2,165).

Looked at article by article, 71 per cent of articles reporting criticism of Israel gave Israel’s position at least once, compared with 53 per cent of articles reporting Israel’s claims that gave a Palestinian or UN position. NewsCord said this means Israel’s claims went entirely unchallenged in almost half of the articles in which it made them.

The study cites a ruling by the BBC’s Executive Complaints Unit on an interview broadcast on 3 November 2023. In that ruling, the unit defended putting opposing views to public figures, saying this does not mean an interviewer endorses them. NewsCord’s findings question whether that principle has been applied equally to both sides. The full report, including every broadcast and article in the study, is free to read online.

The findings add to a growing body of evidence on the BBC’s coverage of Palestine. In 2024, a study by the Centre for Media Monitoring found that British media consistently favoured Israeli narratives over Palestinian perspectives in the first month of the genocide. An investigation by journalist Owen Jones, based on interviews with 13 current and former BBC journalists, described how senior figures skewed coverage in Israel’s favour and ignored internal complaints. The BBC also faced criticism for declining to air Gaza: Medics Under Fire, a documentary on attacks on Palestinian healthcare workers. More than 600 media figures signed a letter in 2025 urging the corporation to broadcast it.

The Greater Dayton Peace Coalition

avatar of the starter
Kevin GwinPetition StarterGreater Dayton Peace Coalition

The Decision Makers

Ron Rollins
Chair of WYSO Governing Board
Luke Dennis
WYSO Station Manager

Petition Updates