Actualización de la peticiónKeep the AQE tests this year

Farfetched is becoming reality

Caroline NugentRegno Unito
10 gen 2021

Note: Parents I would recommend you read this before you share it with your children.

With debate becoming heated over this year’s AQE test, non-academic selection is becoming a real possibility for all.  This will affect us all.  Particularly, those with children currently at existing grammar schools.  Read this to the end and please take a minute to ponder the many consequences of the following being allowed to happen.  Please read this, it is important to us all.  It does read a little like fiction, but it is real, and is what is currently on the decision table.

So what does this mean for us all?  Most schools have finally posted their entrance criteria online and it makes stark reading. The following is a summarized example of the typical order of entrance criteria:

As there is no AQE score, children will be admitted in this order:

Providing your child applied for the AQE this year the order is:

1.      Your child is entitled to free school meals.

2.      Your child has a particular religious affiliation. (some have this)

3.      Your child is currently enrolled in our prep.

4.      Your child has a sibling at the school.

5.      Your child has a sibling who at some point went to the school.

6.      Your child has a sibling who did go to the school. (some have this)

7.      You have a parent as a teacher at the school.

8.      You have a parent who attended the school.

9.      … the lists go on but by now you see the “logic” …?

To re-iterate, this is the typical order, but do check grammar schools websites for their exact order.

The easiest way to see this play out is to take some example children.

Child 1: You scored very high on practice tests, perhaps even scoring 100% regularly.  Amazing!  Very well done!  You do not meet the religious criteria.  You go to a regular primary (not the prep).

Outcome: You will in all likelihood now have to consider non-grammar schools this year.  Start your research.  Keep reading to see who gets the places in the school you had set your heart on.

Child 2: You scored poorly at the start of this AQE learning process, and you have worked exceptionally hard to do well now.  You are proud of your achievement, and so you should be, very much!

Outcome: Sorry, but you have the same outcome as child 1.

Child 3: You had mixed results with practice tests but you have worked hard to become more consistent.  You know you have learnt skills for a lifetime.  I and all the people who signed this petition are proud of you and very well done!

Outcome: Sorry, but you have the same outcome as child 1.

Child 4: You have dyslexia.  You have learned to work with your dyslexia.  Perhaps learning to use a C-Pen, a device that reads the words into little earphones.  This process has been life changing for you.  You can sit independently and do the papers, and now knowing you have a fighting chance, you have fought, you have worked exceptionally hard and you now know that you can score well.

Outcome: I know just some of you out there, and you have been in touch, and it breaks my heart to have to tell you this, but you also have the same outcome as child 1 too.

Child 5: You are entitled to free school meals.

Outcome: You are able to get in to any grammar school you like.

Child 6: You went to prep school.

Outcome: Provided the number of children meeting Child 5’s criteria doesn’t fill your school, you are in to your grammar school this year, no questions asked.  Now if you haven’t been scoring very well in your practice tests so far, and you really don’t like all this testing, prepare yourself for a further 7 years of struggle.

Child 7: I could go on …

……………..

I know this does not cover everyone, but I think it illustrates the current situation fairly well.

All children:  Northern Ireland currently has a fantastic education system.  The children have worked very hard and deserve the opportunity to show what they can achieve on their own merits.  The uncertainty of this situation has been difficult for our children.  They look to us for guidance, strength, and protection.  We have taught them fairness, and are about to show them the exact opposite.  They expect protection and we are powerless to provide it.

Overall outcome (of using these non-academic selection criteria):

1.      A clear message is sent to our children that your hard work is worthless, your ability is too.

2.      This is not equality.

3.      This does not reflect a duty of care.

4.      With the doors flung wide open to those who qualify for free schools meals, many who had thought that certain schools were beyond their reach may well adjust their plans.

5.      The effect on grammar school culture will be profound, with immediate effect.  Will this be for better or worse?

6.      Next year, with the non-academic criteria applied, classes in grammar school will have a very wide range of ability children. As any teacher will tell you, teaching a wide range of abilities requires a very different strategy.

7.      Grammar school teaching practices, which have so successfully served so many of us to date, will have to be radically changed immediately for this new intake.

8.      Many children will be mismatched with their new school’s academic expectations and will consequently suffer, unless we compromise by lowering the expectations on these institutions.  In the end, who does this benefit?  Not the children, and not the schools.

9.      Existing pupils at the school exhibit the values of the school, they worked hard to get in with their own AQE test, and continue to be tested.  How will they react to this new intake?

10.   There are many more consequences, but this illustrates the point.

I struggle to see any positives coming out of this situation for our children, who are talked about so much in the media as the apparent priority in all this.  If this is them being prioritised, then I despair!

Is there no academic criteria they can be measured by? I hear you ask.  Well apparently not!  Have our children not been in primary school for 7 years?  Could records like annual reports, or other tests, not attest to the abilities of each child in their care?  Well apparently that is “complicated”, and essentially they are not permitted to do so.  This is not acceptable, and is not providing a duty of care to our children.

No matter which “example child” your child, or children, most closely matches above, you have to agree that this non-academic criteria is not fair and equitable, and could lead to a massive raft of litigation.  Are we as a society so crippled by the threats of litigation, and blinded in some cases by our own selfishness, that we do not recognise that this decision will bring about a profoundly negative legacy to destroy our education system?

So in conclusion, if you haven’t already done so, act now.  Please call people, ask them to vote for this petition (anonymously or otherwise), and share with them the ridiculousness of what is rapidly becoming a reality for our children.

Thank you again,

Caroline Nugent

ps. If you haven't already done so, please read the comments left by so many.