

Acquit Arrested Students of Unfair Academic Consequences at SUNY New Paltz
The Issue
By signing this petition, you are asking SUNY New Paltz Administration to acquit students of potential and threatened academic consequences for their involvement in the encampment that occurred this past week. You do not have to agree with the student protestor’s views to sign this petition, but it is plain to see that the students are being unfairly punished for exercising their right to free speech in the face of police sent after the protestors began complying completely with New Paltz campus policy. The students arrested were clearly following all rules designed to keep the campus a safe place for open discussion. Read on for further context.
On May 2nd, 2024, a peaceful protest (formerly an encampment) ran by student organizers at SUNY New Paltz was invaded by state troopers, university police, K-9 units, and county police in riot gear. There was a helicopter and multiple drones flying over the protest as well. Although they were not used, there were policemen with rubber-bullet guns, and each cop surrounding the protest held wooden batons that they used to forcibly remove the students peacefully sat on the ground In SUNY New Paltz’ Parker Quad.
The pitching of tents is against university rules, which the students were aware of. This is explicitly outlined in the student handbook—upon warning at 7 p.m. on the aforementioned May 2nd, the tents were completely dismantled. They ceased breaking any campus policies after this, as peaceful protests are more than allowed on campus (supposedly so) according to the SUNY New Paltz student handbook 535.4 “Freedom of Speech and Assembly; Picketing and Demonstrations”. Specifically, the handbook states that “No student, faculty, or other staff member or authorized visitor shall be subject to any limitation or Sanction Range solely for the expression of his views nor for having assembled with others for such purpose. Peaceful picketing and other orderly demonstrations in public areas of grounds and buildings will not be interfered with. Those involved in picketing and demonstrations may not, however, engage in specific conduct in violation of the preceding Section” (Page 5 of the student handbook available publicly on the New Paltz website). There was no reason to arrest these students after the tents were taken down—they complied with the rules after this point, but continued to express their views vocally and peacefully. Around 10 p.m., law enforcement entered campus and began attempting to intimidate the students into leaving. Eventually, they began to forcibly remove each and every protestor from their place sat on the ground along with random protestors from the crowd. Approximately 130 people were arrested, with around 70-80 of those being students, 11 alumni, and 3 New Paltz employees. Around 100-150 policemen were sent to the scene—for a peaceful protest if I may remind you of that.
After the police arrested each student sitting around their dismantled encampment, they began to charge at students to create panic and thus to intimidate bystanders to run away and stop recording. After the entirety of the student body attending the protest was either arrested or chased away, student’s private property was bulldozed and thrown into a garbage immediately after the protest was violently disbanded. This included their dismantled tents, some phones, blankets, books, more, and then some school property. The students arrested were given pink slips informing them that they had been arrested for “trespassing” on their own campus that they pay to be on.
Students were warned of academic consequences if they did not take the encampment down, and the protestors felt it necessary to follow this and take down their encampment in order to continue protesting, which they did. It is apparent that students were complying with the campus rules, and it was also made apparent that the school did not just want the students to take down the camp, they wanted the protest to cease which is a breach of free speech rights. Students are also owed a “written Charge Letter containing a numbered series of allegations that, either individually or collectively, constitutes one or more violations of Campus or Administrative Regulations. Additionally, these items shall be specific and shall provide probably cause to believe that a violation(s) has been committed” (Page 29 of the Student Handbook). They are owed this within 15 days of their initial “misconduct” but the email sent to students implies that they will not be notified within 15 days of an update on their case or an official statement regarding it.
There is video proof of the brutality these students faced and all of the negotiations with academic higher-ups. The students were well-composed and mature, peacefully stating that they will not “back down” until their demands are met, this was not a threat, or even close to it. They explicitly had stated that the violence would only begin IF police were brought in—also explicitly stating that the violence would NEVER come from any protestors—and it NEVER did.
Arrested students were even taken to non-New Paltz detainment centers. They were taken to Highland and other towns surrounding with no way to get home. Student volunteers with cars picked them up. Multiple students were not told what they were arrested for and only learned once they were handed a pink slip. In addition, the consequences outlined by the school were vague according to protestors. They were aware of the potential academic consequence of keeping the tents up, but were not aware until it was too late that police presence and violence would be used by any means necessary. On May 4th, 2024, all arrested students were sent an email saying that they may be suspended, but they will not know the full extent of their consequences until after the school year ends. These students are attending school not knowing if they will be expelled after the end of the “3-week period”. Many protestors report not hearing the police state what they needed to disperse for or why they would be arrested if they stayed.
This protest and the students afflicted have been supported by MANY student associations and faculty departments within SUNY New Paltz—official statements have been given by the New Paltz Student Association, the Black Studies department, the Black Student Union at New Paltz, the Caribbean Latin Coalition at New Paltz, the Latinx Club, the In Living Color Club, the Muslim Student Association, the New Paltz Dance Association, the New Paltz Zine Club/ Zine Library, Active Minds, and more.
Regardless of beliefs or what it may be thought that the student protestors did “wrong”, the violent arrests of peaceful people not actively breaking any rules is extremely unjust. What is even more unjust is the possible consequences of these arrests, as it can easily be seen that the arrests themselves were unjustified. All of the student body and faculty can realize the issues with the police force used in the aftermath of the dismantling of the tents.
Signing this petition means supporting the students that are facing unjust consequences for an unjust arrest. We want to ask that these students are pardoned of academic consequences because of the brutality they faced at the hands of this institution AFTER following the original demands by the campus—which was to take down the encampment. This is not a petition aligned with a specific viewpoint. The students who were unfairly arrested were clearly following school rules and the protest was a safe environment.
Thank you for your consideration in signing this protest. Please attempt to push all biases aside and unite for our community. We keep us safe.
For good measure, from the Campus Regulations section: “Violations of the regulations set forth by the University may, given certain conditions, result in disciplinary action by both University and civil authorities. Regulations may not, however, be unreasonable or forbid the exercise of one’s Constitutional rights” (Page 10). They may not forbid the exercise of free speech.
The student handbook: https://www.newpaltz.edu/media/student-affairs/Student%20Handbook%20August.2023.pdf
3,455
The Issue
By signing this petition, you are asking SUNY New Paltz Administration to acquit students of potential and threatened academic consequences for their involvement in the encampment that occurred this past week. You do not have to agree with the student protestor’s views to sign this petition, but it is plain to see that the students are being unfairly punished for exercising their right to free speech in the face of police sent after the protestors began complying completely with New Paltz campus policy. The students arrested were clearly following all rules designed to keep the campus a safe place for open discussion. Read on for further context.
On May 2nd, 2024, a peaceful protest (formerly an encampment) ran by student organizers at SUNY New Paltz was invaded by state troopers, university police, K-9 units, and county police in riot gear. There was a helicopter and multiple drones flying over the protest as well. Although they were not used, there were policemen with rubber-bullet guns, and each cop surrounding the protest held wooden batons that they used to forcibly remove the students peacefully sat on the ground In SUNY New Paltz’ Parker Quad.
The pitching of tents is against university rules, which the students were aware of. This is explicitly outlined in the student handbook—upon warning at 7 p.m. on the aforementioned May 2nd, the tents were completely dismantled. They ceased breaking any campus policies after this, as peaceful protests are more than allowed on campus (supposedly so) according to the SUNY New Paltz student handbook 535.4 “Freedom of Speech and Assembly; Picketing and Demonstrations”. Specifically, the handbook states that “No student, faculty, or other staff member or authorized visitor shall be subject to any limitation or Sanction Range solely for the expression of his views nor for having assembled with others for such purpose. Peaceful picketing and other orderly demonstrations in public areas of grounds and buildings will not be interfered with. Those involved in picketing and demonstrations may not, however, engage in specific conduct in violation of the preceding Section” (Page 5 of the student handbook available publicly on the New Paltz website). There was no reason to arrest these students after the tents were taken down—they complied with the rules after this point, but continued to express their views vocally and peacefully. Around 10 p.m., law enforcement entered campus and began attempting to intimidate the students into leaving. Eventually, they began to forcibly remove each and every protestor from their place sat on the ground along with random protestors from the crowd. Approximately 130 people were arrested, with around 70-80 of those being students, 11 alumni, and 3 New Paltz employees. Around 100-150 policemen were sent to the scene—for a peaceful protest if I may remind you of that.
After the police arrested each student sitting around their dismantled encampment, they began to charge at students to create panic and thus to intimidate bystanders to run away and stop recording. After the entirety of the student body attending the protest was either arrested or chased away, student’s private property was bulldozed and thrown into a garbage immediately after the protest was violently disbanded. This included their dismantled tents, some phones, blankets, books, more, and then some school property. The students arrested were given pink slips informing them that they had been arrested for “trespassing” on their own campus that they pay to be on.
Students were warned of academic consequences if they did not take the encampment down, and the protestors felt it necessary to follow this and take down their encampment in order to continue protesting, which they did. It is apparent that students were complying with the campus rules, and it was also made apparent that the school did not just want the students to take down the camp, they wanted the protest to cease which is a breach of free speech rights. Students are also owed a “written Charge Letter containing a numbered series of allegations that, either individually or collectively, constitutes one or more violations of Campus or Administrative Regulations. Additionally, these items shall be specific and shall provide probably cause to believe that a violation(s) has been committed” (Page 29 of the Student Handbook). They are owed this within 15 days of their initial “misconduct” but the email sent to students implies that they will not be notified within 15 days of an update on their case or an official statement regarding it.
There is video proof of the brutality these students faced and all of the negotiations with academic higher-ups. The students were well-composed and mature, peacefully stating that they will not “back down” until their demands are met, this was not a threat, or even close to it. They explicitly had stated that the violence would only begin IF police were brought in—also explicitly stating that the violence would NEVER come from any protestors—and it NEVER did.
Arrested students were even taken to non-New Paltz detainment centers. They were taken to Highland and other towns surrounding with no way to get home. Student volunteers with cars picked them up. Multiple students were not told what they were arrested for and only learned once they were handed a pink slip. In addition, the consequences outlined by the school were vague according to protestors. They were aware of the potential academic consequence of keeping the tents up, but were not aware until it was too late that police presence and violence would be used by any means necessary. On May 4th, 2024, all arrested students were sent an email saying that they may be suspended, but they will not know the full extent of their consequences until after the school year ends. These students are attending school not knowing if they will be expelled after the end of the “3-week period”. Many protestors report not hearing the police state what they needed to disperse for or why they would be arrested if they stayed.
This protest and the students afflicted have been supported by MANY student associations and faculty departments within SUNY New Paltz—official statements have been given by the New Paltz Student Association, the Black Studies department, the Black Student Union at New Paltz, the Caribbean Latin Coalition at New Paltz, the Latinx Club, the In Living Color Club, the Muslim Student Association, the New Paltz Dance Association, the New Paltz Zine Club/ Zine Library, Active Minds, and more.
Regardless of beliefs or what it may be thought that the student protestors did “wrong”, the violent arrests of peaceful people not actively breaking any rules is extremely unjust. What is even more unjust is the possible consequences of these arrests, as it can easily be seen that the arrests themselves were unjustified. All of the student body and faculty can realize the issues with the police force used in the aftermath of the dismantling of the tents.
Signing this petition means supporting the students that are facing unjust consequences for an unjust arrest. We want to ask that these students are pardoned of academic consequences because of the brutality they faced at the hands of this institution AFTER following the original demands by the campus—which was to take down the encampment. This is not a petition aligned with a specific viewpoint. The students who were unfairly arrested were clearly following school rules and the protest was a safe environment.
Thank you for your consideration in signing this protest. Please attempt to push all biases aside and unite for our community. We keep us safe.
For good measure, from the Campus Regulations section: “Violations of the regulations set forth by the University may, given certain conditions, result in disciplinary action by both University and civil authorities. Regulations may not, however, be unreasonable or forbid the exercise of one’s Constitutional rights” (Page 10). They may not forbid the exercise of free speech.
The student handbook: https://www.newpaltz.edu/media/student-affairs/Student%20Handbook%20August.2023.pdf
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on May 6, 2024