

25+ Children. One Administrative Error. An Unjust Punishment. Our Children Deserve Better
The Issue
Dear Executive Board of the Bi-County Junior Scholastic Football League (BCJSFL): Mr. DeMaio, Mr. Tripodi, and Ms. Clarino,
I am writing to you not only as the parent of a 13-year-old boy who has proudly played for the Englewood Jr. Raiders for the past four years, but as a parent who believes deeply in fairness, accountability, and the responsibility we have as adults to set the right example for our children.
I have thought long and hard about whether to write this letter. I am not someone who is quick to make accusations or pass judgment. I believe in forming my own opinions based on what I personally witness. Unfortunately, after four years of watching my son and his teammates compete, and particularly after the events of this season, I can no longer remain silent.
Before my son joined the Raiders, I was warned that the team had historically experienced unfair treatment, including questionable officiating, unequal enforcement of rules, and instances of racial hostility. I chose not to form an opinion based on what others told me. I wanted to see things for myself.
Over the years, however, I have witnessed situations that have left me deeply troubled. I have watched touchdowns called back, penalties enforced inconsistently, and opposing players engage in behavior that appeared to go unpunished while our boys were penalized for responding. Most disturbing have been instances of racial slurs and derogatory comments directed toward our players, including the use of the N-word, without what appeared to be appropriate intervention.
I understand that football is competitive, that referees are human, and that not every call will go in our favor. I also understand that a disagreement with an official does not automatically constitute discrimination. But when troubling incidents occur repeatedly, year after year, they deserve to be examined rather than dismissed.
And then came this season.
The decision to strip the Englewood Jr. Raiders A Team of multiple victories because of an administrative registration error involving a child who never even played is, in my opinion, one of the most troubling examples of unfairness I have witnessed in youth sports.
As I understand it, a child from another municipality registered through the recreation department's online system, and his address eligibility was not identified during the registration process. The child was new to the program and never participated in a game. Yet the consequences of that administrative oversight were imposed on an entire team of more than 25+ boys who had absolutely nothing to do with it.
I respectfully ask each of you: What lesson were these children supposed to learn from that decision?
That hard work can be erased because of someone else's mistake?
That victories earned on the field can be taken away for circumstances entirely outside their control?
That even when they follow the rules, practice tirelessly, and outperform their opponents, the outcome can still be decided against them?
These are children. Children who have spent months, years actually, practicing multiple days a week, sacrificing their free time, and even gathering on their days off to practice without their coaches simply because they love the game.
I have watched their dedication firsthand. I have watched them push through exhaustion, disappointment, and adversity. I have watched them develop not only as athletes, but as teammates and young men.
And I have also watched them cry.
Not because they could not accept losing. Not because they believed they were entitled to win. But because they felt that no matter how hard they worked, they were not being given a fair opportunity.
There is an enormous difference between teaching children how to lose with dignity and forcing them to accept an injustice in silence.
These boys have repeatedly been taught by their coaches to remain composed, to avoid confrontation, and to walk away when provoked. I have seen the frustration on their faces as they struggle to understand why they must remain silent while others appear to face no consequences for behavior directed toward them.
Just this past Monday, I personally witnessed a parent from an opposing team openly call the referees "pussies," without any apparent repercussions. I could not help but wonder how differently that situation might have unfolded had those words come from an Englewood parent.
That question alone should give this committee reason for reflection.
I recognize that the Englewood Jr. Raiders represent a predominantly Black and Brown team, competing against teams from communities with different demographics and socioeconomic backgrounds. I am not suggesting that every unfavorable decision is racially motivated. However, the repeated appearance of unequal treatment, combined with incidents of racial hostility, raises legitimate concerns about whether all teams are being held to the same standards.
Every child in this league deserves the same respect, protection, and opportunity, regardless of race, ethnicity, ZIP code, or the financial circumstances of the community they represent.
With respect to the forfeited victories, the consequences extended far beyond the loss of points in the standings.
The Raiders earned more victories on the field than some of the teams ultimately placed above them. Yet those earned victories were removed, changing the standings and forcing the boys into a shootout that they otherwise might not have faced. They ultimately lost to a team they had previously defeated.
I understand that any team can win or lose on any given day. That is the nature of sports. But what I cannot accept is that the Raiders were placed in that position because victories they had legitimately earned were taken away as punishment for an administrative error.
And the consequences did not end with Englewood.
By removing the Raiders' victories, the league also altered the competitive standing of other teams. As a result, the final rankings no longer reflect solely what was earned through competition on the field. If I were those teams I would not feel so proud to have been given a place that I did not earn at the expense of a team who did and was treated unfairly.
A championship standing should be a reflection of athletic performance, not the unintended beneficiary of an administrative punishment imposed on children who did nothing wrong.
How can we teach children that sports are about integrity, fairness, and earning your place when the standings themselves have been altered in a way that does not accurately reflect the results of the games played?
I am not writing to diminish the hard work of any other team. Every child in this league deserves recognition for their effort. But no team should benefit from an injustice committed against another.
What troubles me most is the message this decision sends.
The purpose of youth sports should extend far beyond winning championships. These programs are supposed to build character, discipline, resilience, teamwork, confidence, and respect. They are supposed to teach children that effort matters, that rules apply equally, and that adults can be trusted to make fair and responsible decisions.
When the adults responsible for upholding those values make a decision that punishes innocent children, we undermine the very lessons we claim to be teaching them.
I wonder whether those who made this decision have considered what it felt like for these boys to walk off that field knowing that their season had been fundamentally altered by something they neither caused nor could have prevented.
Have you considered what it feels like for a 12 or 13-year-old child to believe that his hard work does not matter?
Have you considered how difficult it is for coaches to continue teaching sportsmanship, restraint, and respect when their players feel that those same principles are not being demonstrated by the adults governing their league?
Have you considered the lasting impression this experience may leave on children who are still learning what fairness and justice mean?
These are not professional athletes. They are not paid competitors. They are children who simply wanted the opportunity to play football, earn their victories, accept their defeats, and know that the rules applied equally to everyone.
They did not ask for special treatment. They asked for fair treatment. And that should never be too much to expect.
I respectfully ask the Executive Committee to provide a clear explanation, to us as parents, of the rule under which these victories were forfeited, how that rule was applied, whether the fact that the ineligible registrant never participated was considered, and whether less punitive alternatives were evaluated.
I also ask that the committee review the decision and its effect on the final standings, as well as the broader concerns regarding inconsistent officiating, racial hostility, and unequal enforcement of standards.
If the committee believes that the decision was justified, then I ask that you explain, to us as parents and to the 12 and 13-yr-old players, how punishing more than 25+ children for an administrative error they did not commit serves the principles of fairness, accountability, and sportsmanship that this league is supposed to represent.
We are fully aware that this letter may not change the outcome of the season. Although I do believe this should be remediated. But I hope it will at least prompt some honest reflection and meaningful accountability.
We hope that each of you will remember that behind every team name, every score, and every standing is a group of children who trust the adults around them to do what is right.
The Englewood Jr. Raiders A Team deserved, and still deserves, the opportunity to finish their season based on the games they actually played and the results they actually earned.
Instead, they were left with disappointment, frustration, and a profound sense of injustice.
You can take away victories in the standings, but you cannot erase what these boys accomplished on the field. And you cannot expect them to forget how they were made to feel.
I sincerely hope that the members of this committee will reflect not only on whether this decision was technically permissible under league rules, but whether it was morally fair, proportionate, and worthy of an organization entrusted with the development of young athletes.
Because ultimately, the integrity of a youth sports league is not measured by how strictly it can enforce a rule. It is measured by how fairly, consistently, and responsibly it applies those rules, especially when the well-being of children is at stake.
These boys deserved better. And the children who come after them deserve to know that the adults in charge are willing to recognize an injustice and take meaningful steps to prevent it from happening again.
Respectfully,
Parent, Englewood Jr. Raiders A Team

264
The Issue
Dear Executive Board of the Bi-County Junior Scholastic Football League (BCJSFL): Mr. DeMaio, Mr. Tripodi, and Ms. Clarino,
I am writing to you not only as the parent of a 13-year-old boy who has proudly played for the Englewood Jr. Raiders for the past four years, but as a parent who believes deeply in fairness, accountability, and the responsibility we have as adults to set the right example for our children.
I have thought long and hard about whether to write this letter. I am not someone who is quick to make accusations or pass judgment. I believe in forming my own opinions based on what I personally witness. Unfortunately, after four years of watching my son and his teammates compete, and particularly after the events of this season, I can no longer remain silent.
Before my son joined the Raiders, I was warned that the team had historically experienced unfair treatment, including questionable officiating, unequal enforcement of rules, and instances of racial hostility. I chose not to form an opinion based on what others told me. I wanted to see things for myself.
Over the years, however, I have witnessed situations that have left me deeply troubled. I have watched touchdowns called back, penalties enforced inconsistently, and opposing players engage in behavior that appeared to go unpunished while our boys were penalized for responding. Most disturbing have been instances of racial slurs and derogatory comments directed toward our players, including the use of the N-word, without what appeared to be appropriate intervention.
I understand that football is competitive, that referees are human, and that not every call will go in our favor. I also understand that a disagreement with an official does not automatically constitute discrimination. But when troubling incidents occur repeatedly, year after year, they deserve to be examined rather than dismissed.
And then came this season.
The decision to strip the Englewood Jr. Raiders A Team of multiple victories because of an administrative registration error involving a child who never even played is, in my opinion, one of the most troubling examples of unfairness I have witnessed in youth sports.
As I understand it, a child from another municipality registered through the recreation department's online system, and his address eligibility was not identified during the registration process. The child was new to the program and never participated in a game. Yet the consequences of that administrative oversight were imposed on an entire team of more than 25+ boys who had absolutely nothing to do with it.
I respectfully ask each of you: What lesson were these children supposed to learn from that decision?
That hard work can be erased because of someone else's mistake?
That victories earned on the field can be taken away for circumstances entirely outside their control?
That even when they follow the rules, practice tirelessly, and outperform their opponents, the outcome can still be decided against them?
These are children. Children who have spent months, years actually, practicing multiple days a week, sacrificing their free time, and even gathering on their days off to practice without their coaches simply because they love the game.
I have watched their dedication firsthand. I have watched them push through exhaustion, disappointment, and adversity. I have watched them develop not only as athletes, but as teammates and young men.
And I have also watched them cry.
Not because they could not accept losing. Not because they believed they were entitled to win. But because they felt that no matter how hard they worked, they were not being given a fair opportunity.
There is an enormous difference between teaching children how to lose with dignity and forcing them to accept an injustice in silence.
These boys have repeatedly been taught by their coaches to remain composed, to avoid confrontation, and to walk away when provoked. I have seen the frustration on their faces as they struggle to understand why they must remain silent while others appear to face no consequences for behavior directed toward them.
Just this past Monday, I personally witnessed a parent from an opposing team openly call the referees "pussies," without any apparent repercussions. I could not help but wonder how differently that situation might have unfolded had those words come from an Englewood parent.
That question alone should give this committee reason for reflection.
I recognize that the Englewood Jr. Raiders represent a predominantly Black and Brown team, competing against teams from communities with different demographics and socioeconomic backgrounds. I am not suggesting that every unfavorable decision is racially motivated. However, the repeated appearance of unequal treatment, combined with incidents of racial hostility, raises legitimate concerns about whether all teams are being held to the same standards.
Every child in this league deserves the same respect, protection, and opportunity, regardless of race, ethnicity, ZIP code, or the financial circumstances of the community they represent.
With respect to the forfeited victories, the consequences extended far beyond the loss of points in the standings.
The Raiders earned more victories on the field than some of the teams ultimately placed above them. Yet those earned victories were removed, changing the standings and forcing the boys into a shootout that they otherwise might not have faced. They ultimately lost to a team they had previously defeated.
I understand that any team can win or lose on any given day. That is the nature of sports. But what I cannot accept is that the Raiders were placed in that position because victories they had legitimately earned were taken away as punishment for an administrative error.
And the consequences did not end with Englewood.
By removing the Raiders' victories, the league also altered the competitive standing of other teams. As a result, the final rankings no longer reflect solely what was earned through competition on the field. If I were those teams I would not feel so proud to have been given a place that I did not earn at the expense of a team who did and was treated unfairly.
A championship standing should be a reflection of athletic performance, not the unintended beneficiary of an administrative punishment imposed on children who did nothing wrong.
How can we teach children that sports are about integrity, fairness, and earning your place when the standings themselves have been altered in a way that does not accurately reflect the results of the games played?
I am not writing to diminish the hard work of any other team. Every child in this league deserves recognition for their effort. But no team should benefit from an injustice committed against another.
What troubles me most is the message this decision sends.
The purpose of youth sports should extend far beyond winning championships. These programs are supposed to build character, discipline, resilience, teamwork, confidence, and respect. They are supposed to teach children that effort matters, that rules apply equally, and that adults can be trusted to make fair and responsible decisions.
When the adults responsible for upholding those values make a decision that punishes innocent children, we undermine the very lessons we claim to be teaching them.
I wonder whether those who made this decision have considered what it felt like for these boys to walk off that field knowing that their season had been fundamentally altered by something they neither caused nor could have prevented.
Have you considered what it feels like for a 12 or 13-year-old child to believe that his hard work does not matter?
Have you considered how difficult it is for coaches to continue teaching sportsmanship, restraint, and respect when their players feel that those same principles are not being demonstrated by the adults governing their league?
Have you considered the lasting impression this experience may leave on children who are still learning what fairness and justice mean?
These are not professional athletes. They are not paid competitors. They are children who simply wanted the opportunity to play football, earn their victories, accept their defeats, and know that the rules applied equally to everyone.
They did not ask for special treatment. They asked for fair treatment. And that should never be too much to expect.
I respectfully ask the Executive Committee to provide a clear explanation, to us as parents, of the rule under which these victories were forfeited, how that rule was applied, whether the fact that the ineligible registrant never participated was considered, and whether less punitive alternatives were evaluated.
I also ask that the committee review the decision and its effect on the final standings, as well as the broader concerns regarding inconsistent officiating, racial hostility, and unequal enforcement of standards.
If the committee believes that the decision was justified, then I ask that you explain, to us as parents and to the 12 and 13-yr-old players, how punishing more than 25+ children for an administrative error they did not commit serves the principles of fairness, accountability, and sportsmanship that this league is supposed to represent.
We are fully aware that this letter may not change the outcome of the season. Although I do believe this should be remediated. But I hope it will at least prompt some honest reflection and meaningful accountability.
We hope that each of you will remember that behind every team name, every score, and every standing is a group of children who trust the adults around them to do what is right.
The Englewood Jr. Raiders A Team deserved, and still deserves, the opportunity to finish their season based on the games they actually played and the results they actually earned.
Instead, they were left with disappointment, frustration, and a profound sense of injustice.
You can take away victories in the standings, but you cannot erase what these boys accomplished on the field. And you cannot expect them to forget how they were made to feel.
I sincerely hope that the members of this committee will reflect not only on whether this decision was technically permissible under league rules, but whether it was morally fair, proportionate, and worthy of an organization entrusted with the development of young athletes.
Because ultimately, the integrity of a youth sports league is not measured by how strictly it can enforce a rule. It is measured by how fairly, consistently, and responsibly it applies those rules, especially when the well-being of children is at stake.
These boys deserved better. And the children who come after them deserve to know that the adults in charge are willing to recognize an injustice and take meaningful steps to prevent it from happening again.
Respectfully,
Parent, Englewood Jr. Raiders A Team

The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 18, 2026