Add County Travel Restrictions to Rural Reopening Plan


Add County Travel Restrictions to Rural Reopening Plan
The Issue
The Rural Reopening Plan in Maine will gradually lift some limitations on certain businesses in counties where virus community transmission does not exist*. The State's partnership with Maine-based IDEXX Laboratories Inc. to expand testing, coupled with increased resources directed to contact tracing, is what is allowing Maine to move forward on the plan to reopen. A Kaiser Health official said Maine is now second only to Rhode Island in positioning itself to fight Covid because of our expanded testing ability. Testing capability should be on line by the end of this week.
The expansion of testing is incredible news. However, before the testing is in place, it follows that people from counties with documented community transmission should not be circulating in counties where community transmission is nonexistent. However, the Rural Reopening Plan does not make this idea explicitly clear nor include restrictions to prevent this from happening. Without this guidance and restriction, the Plan as is may put people at unnecessary risk for the short term. As Dr. Nirav D. Shah —Director of the Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention— indicated at a press briefing late last week, it will take a little time to get systems in place where that expansion in testing will trickle down to have an impact. In the meantime, under the Rural Reopening Plan, people from counties with documented community transmission may travel to counties where community transmission is nonexistent and visit retail outlets and restaurants.
Dr. Shah has said that once a county has community transmission, it’s not easy to reverse that. In a recent press briefing, Dr. Shah responded to a question from Brian Sullivan of WABI who asked whether the designation of having community transmission ever goes away in a county that has it. Dr. Shah answered no, it was not likely given the reason that: “What we see when there’s community transmission is that cases continue to propagate.”
Therefore, we feel it is common sense to add short-term county travel restrictions to Maine's Rural Reopening Plan to help prevent virus transmission until the expansion of testing and contact tracing is fully in place and until we can see that it is being utilized as a tool to protect communities.
We specifically suggest a 14-day quarantine for travel to another county with an exception for essential workers and those caring for loved ones. To be effective, a change to the new plan should be added swiftly.
This idea mirrors the safety precautions being utilized by the Governor's 14-day quarantine for travel into the State of Maine.
We are aware that restrictions on county travel may be very short lived. However, for the time being until this expansion on testing is actually in place, it makes sense to employ county travel restrictions to ensure the rollout of the Rural Reopening Plan does not set us back on virus transmission, as well as provide reassurance to residents.
Vacation destination towns in Maine may be particularly affected by a failure to add this restriction for the short-term.
We hope Governor Mills and Dr. Shah will agree to take the simple precaution of adding a restriction on county travel to the Rural Reopening Plan to help achieve its intended purpose and not set us back on virus transmission. We feel confident they will receive wide support for this common sense addition. We are grateful to Governor Mills and Dr. Shah for their leadership.
* Those counties with limitations being lifted are Aroostook, Piscataquis, Washington, Hancock, Somerset, Franklin, Oxford, Kennebec, Waldo, Knox, Lincoln, and Sagadahoc.

The Issue
The Rural Reopening Plan in Maine will gradually lift some limitations on certain businesses in counties where virus community transmission does not exist*. The State's partnership with Maine-based IDEXX Laboratories Inc. to expand testing, coupled with increased resources directed to contact tracing, is what is allowing Maine to move forward on the plan to reopen. A Kaiser Health official said Maine is now second only to Rhode Island in positioning itself to fight Covid because of our expanded testing ability. Testing capability should be on line by the end of this week.
The expansion of testing is incredible news. However, before the testing is in place, it follows that people from counties with documented community transmission should not be circulating in counties where community transmission is nonexistent. However, the Rural Reopening Plan does not make this idea explicitly clear nor include restrictions to prevent this from happening. Without this guidance and restriction, the Plan as is may put people at unnecessary risk for the short term. As Dr. Nirav D. Shah —Director of the Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention— indicated at a press briefing late last week, it will take a little time to get systems in place where that expansion in testing will trickle down to have an impact. In the meantime, under the Rural Reopening Plan, people from counties with documented community transmission may travel to counties where community transmission is nonexistent and visit retail outlets and restaurants.
Dr. Shah has said that once a county has community transmission, it’s not easy to reverse that. In a recent press briefing, Dr. Shah responded to a question from Brian Sullivan of WABI who asked whether the designation of having community transmission ever goes away in a county that has it. Dr. Shah answered no, it was not likely given the reason that: “What we see when there’s community transmission is that cases continue to propagate.”
Therefore, we feel it is common sense to add short-term county travel restrictions to Maine's Rural Reopening Plan to help prevent virus transmission until the expansion of testing and contact tracing is fully in place and until we can see that it is being utilized as a tool to protect communities.
We specifically suggest a 14-day quarantine for travel to another county with an exception for essential workers and those caring for loved ones. To be effective, a change to the new plan should be added swiftly.
This idea mirrors the safety precautions being utilized by the Governor's 14-day quarantine for travel into the State of Maine.
We are aware that restrictions on county travel may be very short lived. However, for the time being until this expansion on testing is actually in place, it makes sense to employ county travel restrictions to ensure the rollout of the Rural Reopening Plan does not set us back on virus transmission, as well as provide reassurance to residents.
Vacation destination towns in Maine may be particularly affected by a failure to add this restriction for the short-term.
We hope Governor Mills and Dr. Shah will agree to take the simple precaution of adding a restriction on county travel to the Rural Reopening Plan to help achieve its intended purpose and not set us back on virus transmission. We feel confident they will receive wide support for this common sense addition. We are grateful to Governor Mills and Dr. Shah for their leadership.
* Those counties with limitations being lifted are Aroostook, Piscataquis, Washington, Hancock, Somerset, Franklin, Oxford, Kennebec, Waldo, Knox, Lincoln, and Sagadahoc.

Petition Closed
Share this petition
The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on May 10, 2020