Petition updateSupport Phone-Free SVVSD Schools -- But Allow Smartwatches in "School Mode" for PK-8

197 supporters -- the district has said a firm "no," but we are far from done!

Braun MincherErie, CO, United States
Nov 5, 2026

Thank you to all 197 supporters -- just three more signatures will bring us to 200. Your signatures, comments, and conversations are keeping this practical proposal in front of district leaders.

In our last October 26 update, we promised to report back after the district responded. Superintendent Dr. Jackie Kapushion delivered that response on October 30, 2026. We appreciate receiving a direct answer, but we strongly disagree with the decision and the refusal to evaluate a reasonable alternative.

Read the refreshed petition, supporting sources, and full proposal.

What the district has now confirmed

  • Parents were NOT asked about smartwatches separately from phones before the policy was adopted.
  • Parent-managed restricted wear was NOT separately evaluated, and the district does NOT plan to evaluate it.
  • The district will NOT authorize a pilot this school year or later. It also declined another meeting and considers the matter closed.

The district cites potential misuse, the ability to exit restricted settings, and staff workload. It reports broader cellphone feedback through in-person conversations and says the current policy is working. But support for putting phones away does not establish informed support for requiring children to remove restricted watches.

Wearing is not the same as using

Our request remains narrow: allow qualifying, parent-managed smartwatches to stay on PK-8 students’ wrists in Schooltime or an equivalent restricted mode, with ordinary school-day use limited to checking the time. Calls, messages, games, and other unauthorized use would remain prohibited. Parents would manage settings; staff would address observable misuse, with removal or loss of the privilege when warranted.

No restricted mode is tamper-proof. Clear rules and consequences are part of the proposal, without requiring teachers to configure watches or conduct daily settings checks. Continuous wear also reduces the chance of a watch being forgotten or misplaced before the trip home.

This is a practical distinction already reflected in other districts’ policies: Weld RE-4 permits silent smartwatch wear for timekeeping at all grade levels, and Minnesota’s School District 197 exempts elementary smartwatches from storage while restricting their use. Their rules differ, but both show that phone restrictions and conditional smartwatch wear can coexist.

A limited pilot could measure distraction, compliance, and staff workload. St. Vrain’s own design-thinking instruction emphasizes understanding users, prototyping, and testing. In our view, listening to affected families and testing this narrow alternative would put those principles into practice. Refusing even to evaluate it leaves the central question unanswered.

More than two months later, the records work remains unfinished

Our Colorado Open Records Act (CORA) request was submitted September 3. Substantial records have been produced, but the district described its response as complete 6 times in September. Our diligent follow-up nevertheless resulted in additional records, replacement files, and further searches.

CORA generally presumes a three-working-day period for making records available, with a limited extension for qualifying circumstances. More than two months into this request, we are still seeking completion and a clear account of the searches.

On November 2, district counsel supplied a text-message screenshot and said confirmations from some Board members and staff were still pending. Our November 3 reply sought clarification of search coverage, outstanding work, and completion timing. We have not identified incident data in the records reviewed showing material classroom disruption specifically from watches operating in Schooltime or an equivalent restricted mode.

Review the records and correspondence (request access through the link).

Please help us reach 200 -- and keep growing

We are preparing a response to Dr. Kapushion, continuing to ask the Board to reconsider, and considering another focused CORA request. With election season behind us, we also plan to renew media outreach. The district’s decision to close the conversation does not resolve the concerns families have raised.

Please share SmartWatchChoice.org with at least one other family today. Ask them to read the proposal, sign if they agree, and pass it along. We are only three signatures from our next milestone.

Add a comment explaining why this matters to your family, and consider sharing your experience with the SVVSD Board of Education. If you are an SVVSD parent, say so. Specific experiences help show the people and practical concerns behind the signature count.

Current district rules remain in effect while we seek a change.

Thank you for standing with us for focused classrooms, meaningful parent input, and responsible smartwatch choice.

Braun Mincher
Braun@BraunMincher.com