Petition updateSupport Phone-Free SVVSD Schools -- But Allow Smartwatches in "School Mode" for PK-8

SVVSD Said It Listened to Families. Where Is the Record on Restricted Smartwatches?

Braun MincherErie, CO, United States
23 Sept 2026

135 signatures and growing. Thank you. When a school district credits families for a decision affecting children, it should be able to show the record.

In its August 12 letter to families, SVVSD described listening to families and school staff, then attributed the device-policy changes to their feedback:

"These changes come directly from the feedback we received from our community and from our school administrative teams..."

We support phone-free classrooms. But the records produced so far by SVVSD do not substantiate parent consultation on the specific requirement at issue: making children remove smartwatches already operating in a restricted school mode.

What the records show

On September 3, I submitted a Colorado Open Records Act (CORA) request for the records behind that requirement, including parent input, watch-specific evidence, and consideration of restricted-mode alternatives. The district produced more than 1,100 pages.

The production includes an administrator survey and staff descriptions of parent support for existing cellphone practices. Our review has not found records of a parent survey or other district-led process asking families, before adoption, whether watches operating in a restricted school mode should have to be removed.

Support for putting phones away does not establish support for making children remove restricted watches. Announcing a decision to parents does not establish that parents were consulted before it was made.

We have repeatedly asked district counsel to identify records correcting this finding. None has been identified. The Board has not identified that process or its records either, despite requests on September 8 and 22.

When were parents asked about this specific requirement? What were they asked? What did they say? Where are the records?

Aurora shows what a record looks like

The production includes an Aurora Public Schools presentation. It reports that before its pilot, Aurora "hosted 14 parent/guardian engagement events across the pilot schools."

Aurora's proposal also required younger students' smartwatches to be stored. Its 14 events concerned the broader device-policy pilot. That documented outreach raises a direct question for SVVSD: when did it invite families to weigh the restricted-watch removal requirement? The district still has not identified that process or its supporting records.

Getting the public record should not require this much chasing.

Twenty days after our request, key records and search questions remain unresolved. The district first declared its production complete on September 11. After I identified specific missing attachments, it produced additional attachments on September 17 and replaced its "image-only copies" with searchable files on September 18. It has declared its response complete five times: September 11, 15, 17, 18, and 22. Repeating that the process is complete does not supply the missing evidence.

Did the search include text messages and Google Chat or comparable internal messaging used for district business? Our review has not found any such messages in the production. Counsel's position is that CORA does not require the district "to document its search process." We do not need a search log; a one-sentence answer would do. I have asked at least five times since September 14. The answer remains a general assurance of a "reasonable search."

The evidence for mandatory removal also remains unexplained.

My request asked for existing smartwatch incident data, watch-specific analysis, and any evaluation of restricted modes. Our review has not identified incident data demonstrating classroom problems caused by watches operating in Schooltime or an equivalent restricted mode, or a documented evaluation explaining why restricted wear was rejected in favor of mandatory removal.

The production does include an American Academy of Pediatrics educator resource on elementary-school smartwatch distractions. It says there is "little to no research" on how smartwatches affect distraction in children. It recommends school-hour do-not-disturb settings, muting nonessential notifications, and restricting games and media. It also explains Apple Schooltime and how parents can review temporary exits.

The resource does not require schools to allow watches, but it treats restricted school-hour settings as a practical way to reduce distraction. The district has not said whether it evaluated that approach before choosing removal.

The Board should address the alternative we actually proposed.

The Board favors consistency and wants to avoid staff review of individual device settings.

The current policy also requires off/silent settings. Under our proposal, parents would configure devices and staff would address observable misuse. The Board should explain why that approach is inadequate for qualifying watches.

Whatever your position on smartwatches, every parent and taxpayer deserves a clear account of whose input shaped this decision.

It is not too late to do the right thing.

The solution is narrow and practical: allow qualifying, parent-managed smartwatches to remain on children's wrists in a scheduled restricted mode, with ordinary school-day use limited to checking the time.

Parents manage the settings. Students follow the rules. Staff address observable misuse. A watch that becomes a distraction can be removed, and the individual student can lose the wearing privilege. Teachers would not be responsible for configuring devices or conducting daily settings checks. Phone-storage requirements and testing, emergency, and accommodation rules would remain in place.

The district can make this clarification, explain its reasoning publicly, and work with affected families now. We remain ready to help.

Please make your voice heard.

The Board has said it does not currently plan a formal written evaluation or survey. On September 8, its president said the superintendent could report stakeholder feedback in October. She added that the district had "not received concerns regarding smartwatches through these channels beyond those you have shared with us."

If this rule affects your family, the district needs to hear from you. Explain your experience, ask for the restricted-watch clarification, and ask the district to show the record of parent input.

  • Email: BoardofEducation@svvsd.org and Kapushion_Jackie@svvsd.org.
  • Speak tonight, Wednesday, September 23: The Board meets at 6:00 p.m., 395 S. Pratt Parkway, Longmont. Each speaker has up to three minutes. Advance signup is strongly encouraged through the district's online form; in-person signup begins in the Board room at 5:30 p.m. Speaking time is limited, so a turn is not guaranteed. Public-comment details and signup.
  • Attend a superintendent town hall: Monday, September 28, Lyons Middle/Senior High School; Tuesday, October 6, Erie High School; or Monday, October 12, Longmont High School. Each runs 5:30–7:00 p.m., with Spanish interpretation available. Town hall details.

Thank you to everyone who volunteered for the upcoming reporter interview. We have enough participants for now. To be considered for future media opportunities, email Braun@BraunMincher.com.

Please keep sharing SmartWatchChoice.org, and encourage others to sign, write, and speak.

Parents deserve more than an assurance that their voices mattered. They deserve the record showing how -- and a meaningful opportunity to help correct this policy now.