Judge Brown has dismissed our case. I thank him for his time and respect his decision. At its core, this effort was about transparency and accountability from our elected representatives. In reality, a small fine or administrative hurdle would have been little more than a token victory. Winning a lawsuit against the government is no small task, and we knew we faced many challenges that exceeded simply reading the law.
Regardless, the facts of our case have shown the tendency of a slim majority of our school board to operate in a way that disregards the will of the community, and hopefully we have encouraged Hartselle voters to take a more active role in the 2025 municipal election. I urge you to read the complete ruling, but in summary, our argument failed to convince Judge Brown of the following:
1 - The HCS board policy that imposes a 5-day cut-off for parental participation is wrong given the current practice of posting the agenda on the same day of the meeting.
2 - The private conversations between multiple board members to discuss the selection of the new superintendent two days prior to the meeting were in violation of the Open Meetings Act. Somehow, in those unscheduled and unrecorded conversations, they knew they had the votes to hire Dr. Clayton even though they could not legally eliminate any candidates during those meetings per the Open Meetings Act.
3- That parents with children in the school system are impacted by the decision to hire a superintendent “greater than the impact on the public at large”. Per the ruling, at this time, the administrator running the school system where your child spends 8 hours each day (and who also sets mask policy, etc) has no more effect on you or your family than he/she does on the life of any other citizen anywhere in the state of Alabama.
I have also learned that there is no law that gives a member of the public the right to speak at a meeting. As we approach the 2025 election, please consider that this is your only opportunity guaranteed by law to have a voice in the HCS Board of Education.
Also, I want to thank Mr Daxton Maze and Ms Venita Jones again for standing up for transparency and for their efforts to represent the citizens of Hartselle. As a supporter of this petition, you can be proud of their efforts to fight for our community. They have earned my vote.
As stakeholders, I want to encourage you to support our new superintendent. Attend meetings, get involved, pray for him, show him what Hartselle is about. I travel throughout the country each week and I am quick to tell anyone who will listen about our community and how special it is here. This has been an unfortunate start to his tenure and I sincerely hope that he succeeds in leading our school system.
It’s been an honor to be your voice in this effort and standing up for our kids has been a pleasure. Your support has been overwhelming, and it’s clear that the community is paying attention now. We have something worth protecting here and we must work together to ensure we do not lose it.
Respectfully,
Bruce Wilhite