Council officers list problems with traffic calming measures along Shire Rd

Dear Petitioners,
Below is a reply from BCC (Holland Park Ward Office) to Greg re problems with speed bumps/ slow points along Shire Rd. I've added some responses in square brackets after each point:
From: HollandPark Ward Office [mailto:HollandPark.Ward@bcc.qld.gov.au]
Sent: Monday, 2 December 2019 3:09 PM
To: 'Greg McLachlan'
Subject: RE: Traffic Noise and Hooning Behaviour in Shire Road Mt Gravatt
Hi Greg,
Here’s the information as requested.
Traffic calming Shire Rd would be problematic for the following reasons
· A high number of recreational cyclists use Shire Rd, placing a device would be an impediment to their use and could be a safety hazard.
[no issue for cyclists going up the mountain, some inconvenience coming down, but I'm sure they will trade it for less speeding traffic].
· Given the incline along Shire Rd, a speed platform would not be suitable as this could lead to driver loss of control of a vehicle, causing a run off road crash.
[Speed platforms are not being requested].
· An angled slow point may create water run off issues into adjacent properties and again be an impediment, and potential hazard, to cyclist use.
[Slow-point water run-off issues: can be mitigated/eliminated by a kerbside channel. See Ansdell St photo attached].
· The segment of Shire Rd closest to Logan Rd would not be suitable for a device as this could interfere with the safe and efficient clearing traffic from the intersection.
[Speed bump close to Logan Rd is not necessary. Traffic backup along Shire Rd is only ever 5-6 cars, and the limiting factor to clearing the intersection is the short length of time the light is green].
· The segment west of Tenby St narrows and in combination with the presence of parked vehicles has a speed calming effect.
[It does not. Speeding vehicles take over the entire road and only slow down when the road curves left at the end of the straight].
· Installing a an angled slow point traffic calming device would remove on-street parking.
[This may be a few spots, but will not be an issue as there is plenty of street parking along Tenby St].
· An angled slow point device can present a challenge to “hoons” to increase speed.
[Really? They're pretty much at top speed anyway].
· Traffic noise is typically greater at the location of traffic calming devices as drivers accelerate away from device, and/or screech brakes on approach.
[Yes, but the vehicles are loud anyway. The traffic calming will deter vehicles racing along Shire Rd, so they won't come in the first place].
· Traffic calming devices generate additional environmental pollution including exhaust fumes and brake dust particles associated with the additional accelerating and braking actions.
[Marginal to begin with and more than compensated for by the drop in the volume of hooning vehicles].
Kind regards,
Nea O’Riely
Ward Advisor
Holland Park Ward Office | BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL