MBPJ Response to Potential Wall Collapse into Emergency Passageway.


MBPJ Response to Potential Wall Collapse into Emergency Passageway.
Photo & video: https://www.instagram.com/mbpjcommunity/
Safety access obstruction - trees and potential wall collapse into the safety passageway.
We spent years asking our neighbours, Noble Care Nursing Home to deal with this tree when it was a far more manageable size. They ignored it. It grew to the point where half-eaten fruits started to show up all over my garden.
The stump as demonstrated in the photo and videos also has grown to a point where it could break the wall and cause blockage to the emergency passageway.
We filed a complaint 6th August 2026. They arrived to cut the tree on 12 Nov 2026 in the middle of monsoon season - 99 days or 3 months 7 days after it was reported. We are grateful that they have cut down part of the tree and did not just close the case with 'parties have been notified' which was our experience with MBPJ previously.
Unfortunately, it was still classic local government response in that it was ineffective in dealing with the issue and then again, 'case closed' while on the same day and email thread as the case closed notice, the representative En Syafizul Mohamad admitted that contractors will clean up the waste left onsite - that is to say, the case was not completed at all.
Today, 15 Nov 2026, we have filed two additional follow up complaints, MBPJ.918824 - to remove the remaining stumps and seeds that are spread all across the ground and blocking the emergency access path now and MBPJ.918826 to properly deal with the remaining large stump that still threatenes to topple the fence wall onto the emergency pathway.
We feel partially hopeful that a response was made in the cutting down of the tree with frequent photo and message updates within the case complaint page of the Respons Rakyat app. And we feel dejected that there needs to be a 'but' that follows or even two follow up new complaints that needed to follow.
Perhaps the main error here is that En Syafizul Mohamad jumped the gun with calling the case closed. Given that it took 99 days for any action to be taken, and albeit in the middle of monsoon season, as well as ongoing cases we have where the average response rate is 3 months...anyone who isn't diligently documenting will naturally forget about what they are dealing with by this point. Perhaps with the accountability of social media and the internet, we may chance on a future where local government such as MBPJ will increase their efficiency of their responses.
What is an example you ask? Well, they cut the tree down, but now in the middle of super rainy weather which generally encourages sprouting of tropical seed/plants, the MBPJ team left heaps and heaps of seeds at the spot they cut down the tree, that is, in the middle of the emergency pathway. GO FRIGGIN FIGURE!!! 3 days and counting now...and if we take another 99 days for them to come back to clear this up we will have way more of these trees growing in the middle of the emergency passageway.
On top of this, tree stumps are all over the pathway, there's no way no one be running out on this emergency pathway on an average day let alone during a panicked emergency. Genius.
Is there more that we need to say? Tell me what else is there to say. What can be said? We have learnt our lesson so instead of waiting around, just immediately lodge the follow up complaints.
Tindak Balas MBPJ terhadap Potensi Runtuhan Dinding ke Laluan Kecemasan.
Halangan akses keselamatan - pokok dan dinding yang berpotensi runtuh ke laluan keselamatan.
Kami menghabiskan masa bertahun-tahun meminta jiran kami, Noble Care Nursing Home untuk menangani pokok ini sedangkan saiznya jauh lebih mudah diurus. Mereka mengabaikannya. Ia membesar sehingga buah-buahan yang separuh dimakan mula muncul di seluruh taman saya.
Tunggul seperti yang ditunjukkan dalam foto dan video juga telah membesar sehingga ia boleh memecahkan dinding dan menyebabkan penyumbatan pada laluan kecemasan.
Kami memfailkan aduan pada 6 Ogos 2026. Mereka tiba untuk menebang pokok pada 12 Nov 2026 di tengah-tengah musim tengkujuh - 99 hari atau 3 bulan 7 hari selepas ia dilaporkan. Kami bersyukur kerana mereka telah menebang sebahagian daripada pokok dan tidak hanya menutup kes dengan 'pihak telah dimaklumkan' yang merupakan pengalaman kami dengan MBPJ sebelum ini.
Malangnya, ia masih merupakan respons klasik kerajaan tempatan kerana ia tidak berkesan dalam menangani isu tersebut dan sekali lagi, 'kes ditutup' manakala pada hari yang sama dan thread e-mel sebagai notis penutupan kes, wakil En Syafizul Mohamad mengakui bahawa kontraktor akan membersihkan sisa yang ditinggalkan di tapak - iaitu, kes itu tidak selesai sama sekali.
Hari ini, 15 Nov 2026, kami telah memfailkan dua aduan susulan tambahan, MBPJ.918824 - untuk membuang tunggul dan biji benih yang tinggal di seluruh tanah dan menyekat laluan akses kecemasan sekarang dan MBPJ.918826 untuk menangani tunggul besar yang masih mengancam untuk menumbangkan dinding pagar ke laluan kecemasan dengan betul.
Kami berharap sebahagiannya bahawa tindak balas telah dibuat dalam penebangan pokok dengan kemas kini foto dan mesej yang kerap dalam halaman aduan kes aplikasi Respons Rakyat. Dan kami berasa kecewa kerana perlu ada 'tetapi' yang menyusul atau dua aduan susulan baharu yang perlu menyusul.
Mungkin kesilapan utama di sini ialah En Syafizul Mohamad terburu-buru dengan memutuskan kes itu ditutup. Memandangkan tindakan diambil selama 99 hari, dan walaupun di tengah-tengah musim tengkujuh, serta kes-kes yang sedang berlaku di mana kadar tindak balas purata adalah 3 bulan... sesiapa yang tidak mendokumentasikan dengan tekun secara semula jadi akan lupa tentang apa yang mereka hadapi pada ketika ini. Mungkin dengan akauntabiliti media sosial dan internet, kita mungkin akan menghadapi masa depan di mana kerajaan tempatan seperti MBPJ akan meningkatkan kecekapan tindak balas mereka.
Apakah contoh yang anda tanya? Mereka menebang pokok itu, tetapi sekarang di tengah-tengah cuaca hujan lebat yang secara amnya menggalakkan percambahan benih/tumbuhan tropika, pasukan MBPJ meninggalkan timbunan benih di tempat mereka menebang pokok itu, iaitu, di tengah-tengah laluan kecemasan. AJAIBLAH!!! 3 hari dan semakin bertambah sekarang... dan jika kita mengambil masa 99 hari lagi untuk mereka kembali membersihkannya, kita akan mempunyai lebih banyak pokok ini tumbuh di tengah-tengah laluan kecemasan.
Selain itu, tunggul pokok bertaburan di laluan tersebut, mustahil tiada sesiapa yang akan berlari keluar di laluan kecemasan ini pada hari biasa apatah lagi semasa kecemasan yang panik. Hebat.
Adakah lagi yang perlu kami katakan? Beritahu saya apa lagi yang perlu dikatakan. Apa yang boleh dikatakan? Kami telah belajar daripada kesilapan kami, jadi daripada menunggu, teruskan membuat aduan susulan.